Theres a couple of things I dont like about gathering and refining magical reagents to make stuff with. First off it seems like finding and gathering reagents takes waaay to long. If it was that painstaking it would NOT be possable to have magic shops all over the place selling tons of magic materials. The prices would be astronomically high on everything. There would be wars being waged over places where reagents can grow.
Another thing that I hate is the fact that reagents have to grow in the wild so you cant mass produce them and I understand the concept that it came from the earth and so it is imbued with a little bit of earth's mana but......I think its total bullcrap. People can grow bigger and stronger plants unnaturally not to mention more of them with agriculture and whats the difference? They still grow, they still get fed.
Take diamonds for example to. Now we can just make some gemstones including diamonds that are indistinguishable from the crap that formed in the earth naturally. I dont see why the chemical process that makes a diamon in the earth is any different than one that makes one in a lab.
It makes more sense to me that there are people who go hunt down plants, and paranormal animals and crap and capture or colect them alive so they can be brought back and raised and reproduced.
Would a clone of a mage be totally mundane because he was made artificially even though he has his own personality and stuff? Thats kind of a good argument why bioware reduces essense in a mage just like cyber.
I just really dont like that fact that to make anything manually it would take months and months for each little thing you wanted to make. Also how long it takes to refine the crap you do find which takes yet more months. Your looking at getting maybe 1-4 magical items made a year.
I think if the timeframe would have gotten downgraded one notch to where Months become days, days become hours then it would have been much more realistic. It should take 28 hours to refine a reagent, checking up on it every 4 or 8 hours I forget. It should only takes days to find reagents. Months if your looking for radical or those 4 uber radicals i forget what they are called.
What do you guys think about the time frames for that stuff??
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I haven't finished street magic yet but anchoring spells/anchoring foci looked interesting and turning a paracritter into a vessel for a spirit is also extremely awesome. I guess also scary, imagine running into a hellhound on your next run and your troll steps and is like "dont worry i got this" and yanks out an assault rifle. Only this hellhound has been possessed and has hardened armor and a host of other powers like movement and is instantly in the trolls face and tearing the crap out of him much to the shock and horror of the troll.
Having your own possesed animal sounds wicked though. Mages have always had pet animals but there have always been those ninja who have had pet animals to like shinobi and his wolf. A hell hound with hardened armor and a physical armor spell cast on him by his mage would be a freaking tank.
Hmmm like i said i havent finished. If you make a vessel and have a spirit possess something does it still only have a certain amount of services?? Is there some addiction/willpower test it has to make to leave the vessel?
Im starting the spirit section next so... Its all pretty complicated to me so im only reading sections at a time.
I think the rules are fine just the way they are, as far as Reagents and the like are concerned.
Way ahead of you on the ally spirit Check out "Crucible" in http://www.knasser.me.uk/content/shadowrun/npc_roster_1.pdf. Note that you want Inhabiting for your ally spirit rather than Possession (probably). Of particular note is that the beast has the Ram (door) spell for added PC Scaring. ![]()
As regards the rules for gathering reagents, you have a different world view than what is officially presented. Which is fine if you want to swap things round so that big corps mass-produce reagents. But in terms of balance, the Street Magic stuff works okay. Say you want to make a force three sustaining focus. That's 30,000:nuyen: to buy. An enchanter can take varying degrees of effort to maximise profit, e.g. purchase a formula or craft one's own. If for the sake of argument the crafter wants to make maximum money, you're looking at the following:
A professional enchanter of middling talent (Arcana 3, Enchanting 3, Magic 2) will take about 5 days to prepare the formula.
Next, the enchantment itself has to be done and with a dice pool of 5 and a focus force of 3, the enchanter is going to need about a +4 or +5 to the dice pool to be reasonably certain that she can pull of the threshold 17 extended test. That can come from a range of options, such as a couple of units of orichalcum or exotic telesma, etc. As we're interested in doing everything in house for the sake of assessing whether the enchanting rules are realistic, we'll assume Virgin Telesma and a few radical reagents. What would be required for making the virgin telesma is going to be down to the tradition involved, GM-fiat, etc. Examples given are things like flint knives, bird skull amulets, etc, so I'm happy to lay down a couple of days work tops for this.
We're now up to 7 days work plus about eight or nine days for the actual enchanting. So it's two weeks work plus whatever we determine gathering and refining the reagents will take.
We need three units of three different reagent types. If we assume a similar level of competency with locating and gathering reagents, we're looking at about ten days to locate nine units of raw reagent, about five days to refine them all and then a few months to further transform them into radical reagents.
Thus doing everything in house will take about three and a half months work to produce a 30,000
worth sustaining focus. Middle lifestyle cost is 5,000:nuyen: per month. High is 10,000. Thus our talismonger is making a pleasant living at this work which sounds right for a mage with low to average ability.
This isn't the way things would normally be played however. The fluff implies, but the rules don't require, that a person gathering reagents needs to be magically active. You could even make good use of Task spirits for this work. So if reagents start off being sold at 50:nuyen: plus, then I think it's reasonable that a skilled gatherer is getting paid 30:nuyen: a day for getting these items. Any messing with this is going to have an impact on the economics of the rest of the chain and could make it way to cheap and quick for PC mages to churn out foci and make large amounts of money, upsetting the game balance.
Even in your example you just gave though 1 average level foci took 3 months to make, how do explain walking into to just about any magic shop and finding lots and lots of foci and materials for magical use ? And there being shops like that all over the country and the world. Do you really think there would be that many places "untouched" by humans? We are deforesting the planet and are exploring above and below the north/south poles of our planet humans are everywhere.
Anyways im interested in hearing other opinions.
----------
The spirit section was pretty nice but i have a one or two questions.
Ok I have a pencil that I have enchanted as a vessel. I summon a spirit and it inhabits the pencil and it results in a true form spirit. The pencil explodes and turns to ash instantly. Now what does the spirit look like?? I guess the spirit would instantly go back to the astral plane and look like...a pencil? a archetypical magic tradion spirit type form like a humanoid shape (hermetic), a bird or turtle(shaman)?? It is unable to do anything on the physical plane until it inhabits another vessel?
A follow up to true form spirits. Street Magic said that an Ally spirit that does a true form inhabitation destroys the telesma but also retains that shape. Retains it where? It can materialize? So it would looks like whatever the telesma was in the astral? What about when it inhabits another telesma? I dont remember if you even roll another inhabitation test when an inhabit spirit goes into a new object...
I forget the title of the novel but obviously this is what that mage in the one novel did to get an ally spirit who could turn into a motorcycle. They said a "possessed" vehichle wouldnt boost its handling attribute. Would a possesed motorcycle even be able to drive itself or would it just fall over? Do any spirits have a power they could use to keep it upright ??
Street magic said an ally spirit can only take materialization or inhabitation, what about possesion? Why would it not be allowed?
------------------------------------------------------
Some parts of street magic are really good but I really hate other parts like the descriptions of the new types of spirits and of other traditions. The descrption of task spirits is one freaking sentence. And again just like in the core book they only give examples for like half the stuff.
Shadow Cloak is a stupid power. And how come plant spirits dont have some kind of regenerative power. I also dont like how only some spirits are capable of using magic. Or how certain traditions can only summon certain types of spirits. Shamans are totally clueless to plant spirits? Dont have a freaking clue how to summon ancestrial guide spirits?
----------------------------
Im still not finished. Oh I didnt understand very well why a spirit and a human would enter into a pact and why they couldnt just go there seperate ways whenever they wanted. The book says that they almost never end unless one of the individuals involves dies.
| QUOTE |
| Theres a couple of things I dont like about gathering and refining magical reagents to make stuff with. First off it seems like finding and gathering reagents takes waaay to long. If it was that painstaking it would NOT be possable to have magic shops all over the place selling tons of magic materials. The prices would be astronomically high on everything. There would be wars being waged over places where reagents can grow. |
| QUOTE |
Another thing that I hate is the fact that reagents have to grow in the wild so you cant mass produce them and I understand the concept that it came from the earth and so it is imbued with a little bit of earth's mana but......I think its total bullcrap. People can grow bigger and stronger plants unnaturally not to mention more of them with agriculture and whats the difference? They still grow, they still get fed. |
| QUOTE |
It makes more sense to me that there are people who go hunt down plants, and paranormal animals and crap and capture or colect them alive so they can be brought back and raised and reproduced. |
| QUOTE |
| Would a clone of a mage be totally mundane because he was made artificially even though he has his own personality and stuff? |
| QUOTE |
| The fluff implies, but the rules don't require, that a person gathering reagents needs to be magically active. |
| QUOTE |
| Do you really think there would be that many places "untouched" by humans? We are deforesting the planet and are exploring above and below the north/south poles of our planet humans are everywhere. |
| QUOTE |
I forget the title of the novel but obviously this is what that mage in the one novel did to get an ally spirit who could turn into a motorcycle. They said a "possessed" vehichle wouldnt boost its handling attribute. Would a possesed motorcycle even be able to drive itself or would it just fall over? Do any spirits have a power they could use to keep it upright ?? |
| QUOTE |
| Ok I have a pencil that I have enchanted as a vessel. I summon a spirit and it inhabits the pencil and it results in a true form spirit. The pencil explodes and turns to ash instantly. Now what does the spirit look like?? I guess the spirit would instantly go back to the astral plane and look like...a pencil? a archetypical magic tradion spirit type form like a humanoid shape (hermetic), a bird or turtle(shaman)?? It is unable to do anything on the physical plane until it inhabits another vessel? |
| QUOTE |
A follow up to true form spirits. Street Magic said that an Ally spirit that does a true form inhabitation destroys the telesma but also retains that shape. Retains it where? It can materialize? So it would looks like whatever the telesma was in the astral? What about when it inhabits another telesma? I dont remember if you even roll another inhabitation test when an inhabit spirit goes into a new object... |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Even in your example you just gave though 1 average level foci took 3 months to make, how do explain walking into to just about any magic shop and finding lots and lots of foci and materials for magical use ? And there being shops like that all over the country and the world. Do you really think there would be that many places "untouched" by humans? We are deforesting the planet and are exploring above and below the north/south poles of our planet humans are everywhere. |
There are numerous cases in Shadowrun where powers have fought viciously to return the land to its natural state. Amazonia is a good example. Tibet, which is completely encircled by a magical storm, is another. Also the Yakut. Don't believe the hype, this isn't done for purely altruistic reasons.
Lots to go through:
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Even in your example you just gave though 1 average level foci took 3 months to make, how do explain walking into to just about any magic shop and finding lots and lots of foci and materials for magical use ? |
| QUOTE (SR @ pg.301) |
| Most standard items have no Availability rating, which means that they can be purchased normally from a retail ven- dor—either an actual physical location or an online Matrix store. In this case, the character merely has to pay the listed cost for the item. |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Ok I have a pencil that I have enchanted as a vessel. I summon a spirit and it inhabits the pencil and it results in a true form spirit.  The pencil explodes and turns to ash instantly. Now what does the spirit look like?? I guess the spirit would instantly go back to the astral plane and look like...a pencil? a archetypical magic tradion spirit type form like a humanoid shape (hermetic), a bird or turtle(shaman)??  It is unable to do anything on the physical plane until it inhabits another vessel |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| What about when it inhabits another telesma? I dont remember if you even roll another inhabitation test when an inhabit spirit goes into a new object... |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| I forget the title of the novel but obviously this is what that mage in the one novel did to get an ally spirit who could turn into a motorcycle. They said a "possessed" vehichle wouldnt boost its handling attribute.  Would a possesed motorcycle even be able to drive itself or would it just fall over? Do any spirits have a power they could use to keep it upright ?? |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Street magic said an ally spirit can only take materialization or inhabitation, what about possesion? Why would it not be allowed? |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| And how come plant spirits dont have some kind of regenerative power. |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Shadow Cloak is a stupid power. |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| I also dont like how only some spirits are capable of using magic. Or how certain traditions can only summon certain types of spirits. Shamans are totally clueless to plant spirits?  Dont have a freaking clue how to summon ancestrial guide spirits? |
| QUOTE (Abbandon) |
| Oh I didnt understand very well why a spirit and a human would enter into a pact and why they couldnt just go there seperate ways whenever they wanted. The book says that they almost never end unless one of the individuals involves dies. |
the mage with the bike was talon, and the bike was not possessed but one of the optional forms he gave his ally . . the other being a falcon or hawk or something like that . . basically if you give your ally the form of a toaster the ally will be able to toast bread . . if you give your ally the form of a motorcycle the ally gets to play horse with the ass on the back . .
To be precise, not one of those was done for altruistic reasons? And wars were fought about the YotC natural orichalcum vains?
You do not walk into a Talismonger shop and buy a focus. You may buy fetishes, ritual materials, spell formulae, books on magic theory and new-age crap. No problem.
If you want to give meaning to a focus, it has to be a unique item. A few thousand nuyen and some karma is not all it takes to make one. It should not feel like "Hey, another +2 bonus dice". It should at the absolute lower end be the arcane stick of HP, with that super-special feather inside. There should be few foci available, all with a GM-defined form, and a players wishes should easily require custom-ordering the focus. Unless the player defined something that is basic iconography for his tradition.
A spirits form does not offer any abilities. It can use the capabilities of a possessed body with its own skills, normal movement not needing skill. So you better hope not to make a true form out of your motorcycle... the spirit could likely carry you (depending on its strength), and maybe even move quite fast, but it would not use anything like vehicle stats.
Plant spirits have regenerative power, like all spirits. One short trip to their home plane...
Oh yeah, not to mention, its MAGIC, it doesn't have to make logical sense.
True and I would add that in the hippy-tree-hugger philosophy of Shadowrun, "Natural = Good, Man-made = Bad" because men are evil and everything they touch is tainted with their evil. That's why a diamond gently massaged from the womb of Mother Earth is so much better than an artificial diamond created in a lab.
Goddammit I hate hippies.
| QUOTE (Ryu @ Jan 6 2008, 12:43 PM) |
| You do not walk into a Talismonger shop and buy a focus. You may buy fetishes, ritual materials, spell formulae, books on magic theory and new-age crap. No problem. |
Yes. A game looses much feel if having the best gear is taken for granted. It is very satisfiying for the players if they eventually manage to aquire anything they want, if they can not have it up front. Any more important purchase should soon be played out in the game. A samurai may feel his higher reaction or damage resistance, a mage his higher mana flow. A game that does not emphasize such things does play the same game all the time, but with higher DP.
The economic system of SR is not set up as a base for the game world; the economic system is only usable to model some simplified form of market in such a world, without adaptability. What we collectivly want is not a interchangeable, everyone can do it feel, but an individually choosen advantage point in a negative and destructive environment. There may be many weapon foci in the world, but YOURS is the enchanted katana your father gave you. You are going the right way if the players start to pay extra for style.
| QUOTE (Whipstitch) |
| A nahuali is not going to be able to walk into a corner store and find some radical obsidian sitting in a ziplock bag next to a Force 3 or 4 mÄ?cuahuitl weapon focus formula |
| QUOTE (knasser) | ||
It's not just allowed, it's mandated. Followers of a possession tradition replace Materialisation with Possession for any spirit they summon through a normal process (i.e. everything but Free Spirits, which is not really the same sort of summoning). |
Oh, I definitely agree that talismonger shops will definitely be colored by the local flavor. To me, the -real- tricky part of the equation was the "radical" and "Force 3 or 4 weapon focus formula" part; finding things appropriate for your tradition is another wrinkle to contend with, but it's easier to manage than the legal ramifications. Weapon foci and Symbolic link foci formula are terribly illegal; the powers that be are fine with letting people have low grade weapon foci provided they are licensed and registered, but the last thing they want to see is some mom 'n' pop outfit selling such items to any Awakened they see fit. A lot of formula are considered proprietary as well, which is probably why something as benign as a low grade Health formula requires licensing while combat formulas are outright illegal.
What would be some reasons why you would make a spirit inhabit an object?
Would it be possable to have the spirit use its powers on anyone who attempts to use the object that isnt you? If some dude knocks your possessed sword out of your hand can the spirit use a power or spell to fly back into your hand ?? Haha or what about like a throwing axe
There's considerable difference from inhabitation and possession. The primary use of inhabitation on an ally is to bind the spirit into an animal-so you really could have a talking, magical cat.
I once had a Force 4 Ally Spirit Inhabit a Caduceus, gave him the levitate spell(so he could move), the heal spell, and the death touch spell(so if someone tried to steal him they would have to contend with force 4-8 death touches). As well as normal spirit ju-ju. Kept him pinned to my shirt to identify me as a healer and to heal my ass when I got shot. Also I liked the symbolism inherent in touching someone with a caduceus to heal them.
Chris
ok but these anti magic plant thingies and bacteria can be mass produced no problemo?? *shakes head*
Eh, n/m.
If you setup a breeding camp for hellhounds, you will get hellhound puppies, it's the same with FAB and the various awakened plants, the anti-magic properties are part of what they are so they don't have to worry about being "natural" unless of course you start installing cyber in them.
Powered by Invision Power Board (http://www.invisionboard.com)
© Invision Power Services (http://www.invisionpower.com)