Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: AR hiding illegal
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Edward
AR hiding illegal

I was just looking at SR4 (working my way threw it) and noticed the AR example 3 says there are places where it is illegal to operate your commlink in hidden mode, the comlink description says some information must be made available in certain arias. What would this mean for somebody who did not have a commlink (ether threw choice, poverty, loss or inconvenience (today I take no id to the beech with me)

Edward
-Nyx-
QUOTE (Edward)
What would this mean for somebody who did not have a commlink (ether threw choice, poverty, loss or inconvenience (today I take no id to the beech with me)

That he is not allowed to go there.

Greetings,
Nyx
mdynna
They might accept another form of ID (like a Credstick) but begrudgingly, and most likely with further questions. (Why aren't you carrying a Commlink, don't want anyone to know who you are?)
Backgammon
Honestly, those zones would be fore sure corporate core sectors or governement establishments. And there's no valid reason for anyone not to have a commlink in those areas. People are there for a specific reason - business. If you forget your commlink at home, you can probably get a temp RFID sort of ID at your office.
Ophis
Now that is a cool idea, trick is convincing the guard your on the system...
Shrike30
QUOTE
What would this mean for somebody who did not have a commlink


They're disenfranchized.

There's a big deal going on right now about how all of the broadcast TV networks are going to have to be digital in the next few years. Of course, this means you'll need a digital television in order to watch it, something which, if you don't have a lot of income, you might not be able to afford.

The only way this was really able to get pushed through legislature was with a clause that set aside money to provide digital converters for those who couldn't afford to buy a new TV, so that they wouldn't be cut off from utilizing a public utility (the airwaves, which are owned by the government and rented by networks) by the legislation.

In Shadowrun, with so much of the population SINless (read: illegal, undocumented), you're just begging for police attention walking through high-end neighborhoods with your commlink in "SINless bum lowering your property value just by being here" mode.
Edward
The fluff example was on the street in a AAA suburb,

If you live near the beech you have to take your comlink when you walk to the beech for a swim.

Sounds a bit over the top to me.

And to an office cleaner a cheep comlink is a fortnights salary, having a job cleaning offices means this person dose have a sin.

Edward
Butterblume
The rules state, commlinks typically carry your personal date, like ID and SIN. This would mean, there are alternatives.
One alternative might be a security RFID, implated under your skin, which contains the necessary data. Technically, this would be like broadcasting your ID.
Shrike30
The economy of the cyberpunk future is a bitch. If you don't have the money to afford a commlink, society doesn't want you. If you're a dude who cleans offices, you had to have a SIN to get that job, and Mr. Ares Hiring Manager could go through the hassle of reading hardcopy SIN documentation, digging up your records online, and being sympathetic with your plight of "I need this job because I can't even afford a commlink," but the next guy in line for your job, whose SIN is in his commlink alongside of his resume and his direct-deposit payroll account obviously has his shit together a lot more than you do... why hire the screwball? If you want to interact with the world at large, you need a commlink, period.

Sure, small businesses in crappy neighborhoods (and various shadow-contacts) will take your certified credstick over the counter, but they're not even going to let you into a restaurant in a good neighborhood (read, anywhere your typical wage-slave aspires to live) without your commlink showing some ID. If you're too poor to afford a second-hand bottom-of-the-barrel commlink, that's too bad... we don't want you in our neighborhood, and Mr. Lone Star just down the block is going to come by and hassle you until you go somewhere else.

The corporations have a vested interest in this kind of thing. Sure, there's a bunch of SINless people out there without commlinks, and that keeps their dollars out of the economy... but they don't have much money to spend in the first place. Meanwhile, keeping the vast majority of the wageslaves equipped with the means to spend money as quick as a thought (and making hundred- or thousand-nuyen pieces of hardware into combination wallets/status symbols) is even better for business.

Nobody swims anymore, either. The oceans will burn your skin off if you stay in them for more than a few minutes. And the rain will bleach your clothes if you don't wear your poncho. And there are no more kittens or puppies, either, just robotic equivalents. nyahnyah.gif
mfb
as well, having a thriving underground economy provides a sort of neutral ground for corps to work with--a buffer zone, a source of shadow talent, etcetera. the lower class can be really handy!
Shrike30
Not to mention a great testbed for new products, be they ecological, pharmaceutical, or ballistic.
Kremlin KOA
<quote>
Nobody swims anymore, either. The oceans will burn your skin off if you stay in them for more than a few minutes. And the rain will bleach your clothes if you don't wear your poncho. And there are no more kittens or puppies, either, just robotic equivalents.</quote>

it isn't quite that bad in SR, hell they even prove s much in the old cyberpirates book
Shrike30
That's why there's a big old nyahnyah.gif on the end of that paragraph. cool.gif

Nobody in their right mind goes swimming at the beach in Seattle anyway, though. Even if you ignore the whole pollution thing, the water averages about 55 degrees Fahrenheit. Hypothermia will take you out of the picture in about 30 minutes.
stevebugge
QUOTE (Shrike30)

Nobody in their right mind goes swimming at the beach in Seattle anyway, though. Even if you ignore the whole pollution thing, the water averages about 55 degrees Fahrenheit. Hypothermia will take you out of the picture in about 30 minutes.

Is it really that warm? It feels more like 40.

Random Puget Sound thought of the day: Awakened Dogfish
Shrike30
It varies from time of year, etc. I just remember that as being the temperature all the guides at the aquarium warn you about.

Awakened dogfish? Heh...
Dissonance
Or even worse, awakened Dopefish.

Swim. Swim. Hungry.
Ophis
Awakened Devil fish, the honking huge Octopi you get in that area of the world according to my nature programs.

editted for to much Y not enoufh T.
Dale
Hell, things are a bitch now. I currently don't have a valid credit card and it feels like I lost my damn citizenship or something. The whole AR commlink thing would compound the misery.
Btw, how do I get my free digital converter nyahnyah.gif
TheOneRonin
So the prices for Commlinks in the book are pretty much canon, but what about a real world corrollary: Cell Phones.

You don't need $300 cash to buy a nice cellphone...many of them now are free, or pretty darned cheap if you sign a contract. Perhaps that, or at least some sort of financing is available for commlinks. I mean, just because a Eurocar Westwind 3K lists at $85k doesn't mean a person HAS to have $85k in cash on hand to get one.

I mean, I'm on my 4th automobile since getting my license and never once have I had the kind of money to pay cash for one.
Rotbart van Dainig
QUOTE (TheOneRonin)
You don't need $300 cash to buy a nice cellphone...

You do, and will pay a lot more if you want a state of the art one without entering any contracts.

Keep in mind that 'free' cell phones are just sponsored by the provider.
Piecemeal
QUOTE
I mean, I'm on my 4th automobile since getting my license and never once have I had the kind of money to pay cash for one.


stop stealing cars.. yeash.
Moon-Hawk
For an average joe, getting a cheap to halfway decent commlink every few years and making the payments on it are part of lifestyle. Anyone with Low or better should have a crappy commlink included, I think. Not a commlink that a runner would ever want to use, of course.
For squatters and lower, well, all those rich people throw out old commlinks, maybe if they're lucky they can find a working one in the trash. smile.gif
James McMurray
Hey! I'm the one taking up a ressurecting old threads hobby around here!

But this is as good as any. smile.gif

I would hesitate to let players buy things on credit, for a couple of reasons. The primary being balance and the secondary being ease of use.

Balancewise you can end up in a situation where characters are getting high priced merchandise for a fraction of the cost. For example, if the campaign is only going to last 1-3 years in game time, entering into a 5 year contract to buy a Westwind will save them lots of money.

Second, it's incredibly easier to just say "buy the car from the book." If they want it cheaper they can get a stolen one. The game flows much faster when I don't have to try and decide what a decent down payment and monthly fee would be for a luxury sedan in 2070. smile.gif

All that said though, if a player was intent on the idea I'd work something out with him. And it could be fun to have the repo man show up at his house after a dry spell of jobs. smile.gif
Moon-Hawk
Just for the record, I don't think anyone was talking about runners buying anything on credit. We were discussing average joes.
blakkie
QUOTE (Rotbart van Dainig @ Apr 19 2006, 02:27 PM)
QUOTE (TheOneRonin @ Apr 19 2006, 10:09 PM)
You don't need $300 cash to buy a nice cellphone...

You do, and will pay a lot more if you want a state of the art one without entering any contracts.

Keep in mind that 'free' cell phones are just sponsored by the provider.

But you don't need that much cash, you need the credit. Which is what i think TheOneRonin is talking about too.

As well there has been speculation on this board about reduced purchase costs to the commlink user based on business models centered around advertising or data collection. Top that off with a monthly payment system, or a pay as you use data system system (like pay as you go phones) and you really lower the economic entry point for commlinks. Not canon for runners obviously, but a reasonable assumption for a fully realised game world.

If you have a SIN, which is the real trick, to put on your commlink then you should be able to muster up a commlink in some form. If you don't have a SIN or fail the basic society test of being able to scrounge up a commlink then keep the hell out of our nice, clean secure zones, scumbag. cool.gif

As for having a commlink with you all the time, given that so far the art appears to have the lower end of the size range down around a beefy wrist watch that shouldn't be too much of an issue. In modern electronics the size and form constraint is increasing based more on the user interface than the bit that buzz inside. Once the user interface goes AR and all connections go wireless you are golden to switch size and form priorities to the physical ergonomics of carrying.

All in all it rates pretty low on world inconsistancy scale.
hobgoblin
first of, shadowrunners are not avarage joes. avarage joes have more or less signed their life away to some corp (mega or not). this means that they have a legal SIN, a "fixed" income, and all that stuff.

their comlink could be a corp comlink, their car could be a corp car (if they are that high up). most likely however if they are a office "rat" they either work from home using VR, or commute using corp coverd public transport (or maybe a corp carpool or similar).

corp is mother, corp is father.

shadowrunners are independents. if they are listed as anything its security consultants wink.gif
FanGirl
QUOTE (Edward @ Mar 20 2006, 05:42 PM)
The fluff example was on the street in a AAA suburb,

If you live near the beech you have to take your comlink when you walk to the beech for a swim.

Sounds a bit over the top to me.

And to an office cleaner a cheep comlink is a fortnights salary, having a job cleaning offices means this person dose have a sin.

Edward

No, you probably wouldn't need to take your commlink to go to the beach, unless it was a fancy exclusive beach where only those who are "on the list" are allowed. Anyway, I don't think that the commlink requirements are all that stringent compared to modern ID requirements. For example, if you get pulled over while driving your car, you will get a ticket if you don't have a valid driver's license in the car with you. The important thing isn't whether or not you're a licensed driver, it's whether or not you can prove that you're a licensed driver. Therefore, it's just common sense to have your driver's license with you whenever you're driving your car.

As for the objection that commlinks aren't cheap enough for the poor to be able to afford them. . .well, it's not like we try all that hard to accommodate the poor today. Why would that behavior change in the future?

EDIT: Actually, the cheaper commlinks out there aren't all that expensive. A Meta Link with Vector Xim installed only costs nuyen.gif 300. Your office cleaner is most likely getting paid at least enough to support the average Low lifestyle of nuyen.gif 2,000 per month. Assuming that he's getting exactly nuyen.gif 2,000 a month, that works out to nuyen.gif 500 per week. That means he can get his commlink with less than a week's pay--not an entire "fortnights [sic] salary" as you say. Sure, he'll have to skimp on 'non-essentials' (e.g. food, clothing, transportation) for a while in order to get the cred he needs, but a commlink is not that far out of his reach.
James McMurray
There are tons of people today that can't afford cell phones but still have them. I've known jobless people for whom their cell phone was last on their list of thigns to get rid of when money got too tight. In a world where your cell phone let's you play Duke Nuke'm in full 3-D during your bathroom breaks at work that would probably be even more true.
Shrike30
rotfl.gif
hyzmarca
QUOTE (Moon-Hawk)
Just for the record, I don't think anyone was talking about runners buying anything on credit. We were discussing average joes.

Personally, I'd let runners buy stuff on credit under two programs.

1 - They have a credit history. This means they have a legal SIN or a fake one so good that it would have cost more than a Eurocar in the first place. The lender would take samples of DNA, finger prints, retinal scans, dental x-rays, and full-body cyberscans for their own records (at a bare minimum). The runner in question will be required to have a full physical medical examination and the details of this exam will be used to determine the runners expected lifespan (with uncanny accuracy) based on arcane actuarial formulas pioneered by Pythagorean hermetics. The lender knows everything about the character's life. The item purchased with credit is forever tied to that character via every identification method known to man and some that aren't.

2 - Loan Shark. They need an underworld contact for this but a fixer is good enough. Base interest is 200% compounded weekly. This can be reduced to 150% weekly minimum with negoation but the sky is the limit for increasing it.

James McMurray
The first one can possibly turn the SINner defect into a benefit. If you're going to let characters get bonuses from their flaws you may want to lower their BP value. Then again you may not. smile.gif

The second would also work in my game, but none of my current crop of players would probably think about doing it. Long term it's going to be more costly than buying the actual item. Short term you run the risk of the job you're buying the item for going south and suddenly finding yourself forever in debt to Guido and Nunzio.
hobgoblin
about homeless and mobile phones. was there not a story about a homeless guy in new york that had got a old desktop computer going and used to haul it into places with wifi access to go online?
hyzmarca
QUOTE (James McMurray)
The first one can possibly turn the SINner defect into a benefit. If you're going to let characters get bonuses from their flaws you may want to lower their BP value. Then again you may not. smile.gif

Having diviners, psychometers, hackers, and forensic accounts going over your past, present, and future with a fine-toothed comb present so that you can purchase an item that will forever be tied to your real identity is not going to be a benefit of any sort.

Possible complications include, from bad to worse -

Lender:"I'm sorry sir. Our actuarial service reports that you are going to die of ... lead poisioning ... next Tuesday. I'm sure you can understand why we can't give you this loan."

Cop: "Sir, are you aware of the fact that your vehicle has been used in a crime."

Lender: "There were some discrepancies in your history. The armed guards and I would like for you to stay while our parent company sends some people to interrogate you it."
James McMurray
Obviously you don't use that method to purchase the getaway vehicle.
ronin3338
There's always the pre-paid option. For cheap, you get last year's commlink, and your AR/VR is limited to your pre-paind account, probably by the month. The ID broadcasting/banking aspects are free.
hobgoblin
QUOTE (James McMurray)
Obviously you don't use that method to purchase the getaway vehicle.

who buys their getaway vehicle?
blakkie
QUOTE (James McMurray @ Apr 19 2006, 06:01 PM)
Obviously you don't use that method to purchase the getaway vehicle.

Any vehicle you drive is a potential getaway vehicle. Sometimes it's a bitch keeping business and pleasure separate so you don't always get to choose the times you are 'runner and the times when your are upstanding citizen J.Q. Public.
James McMurray
My group frequently foregoes the "buying" portion of getting a getaway vehicle altogether, preferring to swipe one and keep their own rides clean.

Yes, while it's quite possible for bix to interfere with life, it's easily possible to choose not to take your purchased car on a run. The other things you can't really avoid, because your GM will throw them at you wherever he deems logical and/or fitting. That's what I meant by "getaway vehicle"... The vehicle you use to get away from your crime.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012