A matter of posting on topic... Options

[Pendaric]

I am resurrecting this poll, for there have been many like it in the past, as a guide to the newer members and reminder to the older ones. I place myself in both categories.

After all this is a public forum, the majority of the SR community who benefit from it don't post/are members, so lets aim to be relevant and inspiring.

Dumpshock has come a long way (in the seven and some years since I encountered it) and I am sure we all appreciate the general mood, hopefully it can continue and perhapes improve.

Thank for your participation.

[The Stainless St...]

Phys-Ad.

[DocMortand]

I had to vote for one of the lines.

Never, ever seperate poll questions with lines.

Normally I read completely through before replying. *shrug*

[stevebugge]

Didn't vote, because honestly my approch changes dependent on the length of the thread and when and where I am posting from. 1-5 posts I'll read carefully, 6-20 I'll read, skim, read the last and post. 2-3 pages I'll porbably just read the last 3-5 posts and answer from there. 4 or more pages and I may not even look at the thread much less try to post in it, with one notable exception being the Holy Scriptures of The Drop Bear Conspiracy.

[DocMortand]

[Kagetenshi]

Unless something in the middle of a thread really grabs me by the throat and screams "reply to me!", I make it a point never to post in a thread I haven't read entirely. As a result, I tend to end up not reading threads that are longer than about forty posts by the time I first see them.

~J

[Calvin Hobbes]

I voted line. It was the least biased of the possible answers.

FOREGO YOUR LIMITED FORUM UNDERSTANDING.

A: Because it breaks the logical causality between question and answer.
Q: Why is blog posting bad?

Phys Ad that can cast sorcery.

[FrankTrollman]

Physads with Sorcery are worse than street sams or adepts. You spend points on being crappy at spellcasting, and end up with a character who is neither gooc at magic nor at ass-kicking.

Personally, I've always found Street Samurai to be better than Adepts whether the game is long or short. The adept has theoretically unlimited expansion potential, but even characters of mine played for multiple editions never managed to hit the extensibility wall of the street sam hard enough for the adept to catch up. There's a lot you can do with Beta Grade Cyber.

-Frank

[Blaze]

*Laughs* I think that's the fastest I've ever seen a thread go off-topic, here or anywhere else.

On the question in hand, I've voted option-1. I've been around here about five or six years now, and the vast majority of the time I only post when I feel I have something valuable to advance to the discussion, a new idea that I would like honest and objective feedback on, or a question I would like a well-thought-out answer to. If I'm lucky, sometimes I get what I'm after. ;) I've no interest in debating whether adepts or street samurai prod more buttock than the other- in either case the choice is secondary to the construction of the psyche, history and consciousness of a character. You can do some sick and wrong things with either (gods know I have done in the past), but for me the biggest question is not magic or wetware, it's whether you build the character's personality first, or his/her stats. I find the former provides a more entertaining RP experience, but your mileage may vary.

I get the feeling I may have taken this even further OT- sorry, Pendaric...

-JH.

[Guest_MK Ultra_*]

1 or 2 mostly

Have to second Blaze on the off-topic discussion, though I often start the process by visualizing the upcoming pc (not its stats).

[Kagetenshi]

[Wounded Ronin]

Well, I think that physads are better for a number of reasons. Bear in mind that I haven't touched SR4, so I'm talking about SR3.

1.) They're a lot easier to create at chargen. I can whip up a physad very quickly, whereas making a sammie is usually a lot slower because you have to purchase more 'ware with highly detailed and variable prices.

I realize that this dosen't impact in-game power, but personally I think it's worth a lot if I can make a new character quickly. Like, let's say my character I've been using in a campaign dies, and I need to make a new one. Am I going to waste a few hours making an ultimate sammie, or am I going to whip up a new physad and get back into the action?

This is one aspect of the physad that I think is a positive aspect, but which hasn't been brought up that much.

2.) Next, I'll just reahash the old argument that the physad, through theoretically unlimited initiation, is a better long term choice than the sammie, who faces diminishing returns due to his Essence.

[Brahm]

Yes.

[Brahm]

I hate those dashed lines.

[eidolon]

Combo of one and two, depending on the thread/topic.

Depends on the karma level at start of game. A lot? Physad all the way. None? Whichever fits the team better.

[fistandantilus4....]

perhaps the thread wouldn't have drifted if Frank head read the whole topic and all the replies carefully, then thought out and carefully type , cross-referenced, and spell checked his reply. :D

In general, I try to read through everything , then go back to the points that caught my attention the most, where I wanted to make a reply. That way I don't have to waste time posting, then going back and editing my post to include "Oops, Jray already said that.", and feel like a dope. But hey, some times you feel like a dope...

[PiXeL01]

Looks like the dots are in a good second place at the moment. I did vote for number two though ...

And on the half rerailing .. I prefer Street Sams. To me they seem easier to compile into something you like faster than a PhysAd. I havent played an adept after SotA64 so ...

[Critias]

----------------------- for the win.

[Brahm]

The -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- I voted for is in 2nd to last place, just ahead of #4. :( Now I really hate them.

[Pendaric]

And history repeats itself. Or at least rhymes.
Any bets on the line to win? 2:1 on line 1.....

[Dog]

I try to take a look at who's posting. There are a certain few names, that if I see them every second or third post, I know it's probably just "nuh uh!" and "uh huh!" so I skip it.

[nick012000]

Line #1 for teh win. :D

[nezumi]

I like that a quarter of all respondents voted "-----------------------" It's like swordfish mustardball, but longer!

[Brahm]

Swordfish mustardball?

[Critias]

*wooooooooooooooosh*

That's the sound a joke makes, flying over Brahm's head.