QUOTE (Heath Robinson @ Apr 24 2009, 07:17 PM)
Seriously? You wouldn't spend 2 BP for +2 dice on using Wheeled Ground Vehicles, or Semi-Automatic Pistols?
Or are you stating how you feel people would play the game in your ideal world?
what he means is that the BP-to-Karma ratio of specialisations is terrible. 2 BP for a specialisation or 2 Karma for a specialisation = 1:1, which is not very good.
for example, let's go with attributes, assuming we compare all costs as if we're starting from 0 (under the new system, for a human; incidentally, for some metatypes this "efficiency rating" can go much higher in some attributes, particularly for trolls and body or strength)
for 2: 10 BP, 10 karma (1:1) (note that this is the worst efficiency, and is still as good as specialisations)
for 3: 20 BP, 25 karma (1:1.25)
for 4: 30 BP, 45 karma (1:1.5)
for 5: 40 BP, 70 karma (1:1.75)
for 6: 65 BP, 100 karma (1:1.54) <== the actual efficiency of going from 5 to 6 is worse than this value, this is just a comparison
normally it would be a bad choice to boost resonance to 6 (as compared to 5), but because we also have 10 complex forms at 6 it actually becomes efficient (complex forms are in fact one of the most efficient expenditures of BP you can make, since it costs so much karma to actually improve them... for example:
rating 1: 1 BP, 2 karma (1:2) <== note this is already higher than any of the attribute ratios
rating 2: 2 BP, 4 karma (1:2)
rating 3: 3 BP, 10 karma (1:3.33)
rating 4: 4 BP, 18 karma (1:4.5)
rating 5: 5 BP, 28 karma (1:5.6)
rating 6: 6 BP, 40 karma (1:6.67)
if you were wondering, the 1:6.67 ratio is *extremely* high. there is a reason it is important to buy as many of your complex forms as you can (that you want) right at chargen, and this is it. this is also the reason it's actually a really good idea to set resonance to 6, *if* you can afford it (and provided you're buying enough complex forms... iirc, it's something like 7 or 8 to break even)
so in a manner of speaking, he's right... it really isn't an efficient use of BP to spend them on specialisations. in general, a specialisation should only be used if it's absolutely necessary, which in the case of the TM above for dodging, i would personally say it is.