QUOTE (Eugene @ Aug 6 2009, 04:18 AM)

I mostly liked it, Knasser, especially the language and the noir style. But Omen's actions at the end didn't jive with his description of himself as "a samurai. Real one - one with some honor, not just chrome."
That's deliberate. Nobody thinks of themselves as a bad guy save for a few desperate souls trying to find some way to be special. Omen lies to himself all the way through. He says Angelo is his friend and betrays him because "it's [Angelo's] own fault". He doesn't want Bluebell to be helped, he wants to be the one that helps her. It's an important difference because at the end, when she decides she doesn't want that help, he is furious and determined that "she would appreciate it". He
is a hypocrite, seeing himself as better than he is.
The difficulty in writing something from one person's point of view, is showing things that they themselves can't see. And that includes their conceits. It's hard to do that without resorting to exaggeration. You have to dwell on their inner dialogue of justifying their actions to themselves. The more extreme their actions, the more you can elaborate this internal dialogue (and no, I don't mean monologue - that's the point of hypocrisy). But the longer the story, the more you can be subtle about it, because you have the space to apply many subtle nudges to the reader that something is skewed about the view point character's perspective. The shorter the story, the more heavy-handed you must be.
When hypocrisy is unmasked, there are four basic ways that you can go, created by two axes. These axes are Surprise and Acceptance.
Surprise and Acceptance: This is fine for the reader. The big unmasking of the wrongness of the viewpoint you've had all along is unexpected, but it works well and is believable to the reader. This is usually a shock ending. Think Sixth Sense.
No Surprise and Acceptance: This is also fine for the reader. It is the growing awareness that the view point provided is incorrect. This is what I was going for in The Perfect Run. The reader learns from the hints and wrong actions that Omen is not the honourable character he claims to be. By the time the end is reached, or even before, the reader is separating themselves from the viewpoint character but without separating themselves from the story. They accept that the viewpoint is incorrect.
Surprise and Lack of Acceptance: This is a bad result for the reader. The big unmasking of the incorrect viewpoint falls flat. It doesn't fit with what the reader has seen so far (in their opinion) and is therefore not accepted. They are jarred out of the story. This can result from a story where the author wasn't going for Surprise at all, but the clues were too subtle meaning that the reader never got what was going on and then at some point is suddenly hit with the incorrectness of the viewpoint and rejects it, jarring themselves away from immersion in the story.
No Surprise and Lack of Acceptance: This is the same as the previous category except even worse - the reader refuses to accept the hypocrisy all along, perhaps finding it implausible and therefore losing immersion in the story early on, and consequently not enjoying it for a prolonged period.
Perhaps for some people, The Perfect Run fell into the third category. Omen said to them at the start that he was a "real samurai", that he had "honour", and they believed him and didn't question it. I would have needed to add larger pointers in the story through more exaggerated internal dialogue or through more extreme actions (e.g. he could strike someone unarmed on his way to the Ancient's meet and give a "justification" for it, which would raise alarm bells with the reader). Perhaps I personally am more used to distrusting people's statements about themselves, particularly claims of honour, so this didn't carry so much weight with me and was more easily discarded. When I re-read the story, that line did strike me and I wondered whether I should take it out or leave it in. I decided to leave it, because I wanted to keep the hypocrisy level in the story. It explained things like his hesitation at the end about how to treat Bluebell. He needed time to rationalise his behaviour somehow.
QUOTE (Earlydawn)
Agree with Eugene. One of those fantastic pieces that deals with runners, not runs or running, but doesn't mesh with his description. I thought that the end would turn into a would-be rape scene, he wouldn't do it, and claim something dark but honorable like just seeing if she would go for him.
I can't see anything honourable in that. It didn't go to a rape scene, but it did go to somewhere not nice. Were you disappointed in Omen's behaviour at the end? If so, did that damage your immersion in the story? Or did it survive not going where you expected?
All these comments are very useful to me and I appreciate everyone who posted. My stats say 94 downloads so far, so those that posted comments are the top 1% of people, as far as I'm concerned.

QUOTE (The Dragon Girl)
That is a beautiful piece of fiction.
And thanks for this comment. Made me smile.

K.