Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: [SR4A] Did you like the new designs for the guns?
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
silva
With the exception of Ares Viper, I didnt. And, overall, I didnt like the "blue aura" look. Feels ... dont know...unserious?

I would like it better if they had just adopted the traditional models ( like these here: http://biometal79.deviantart.com/art/My-Sh...tion-1-48801985 ).

How about you guys?
Heath Robinson
Most of the SR4A weapon design falls into the "BRUSHED METAL LOOKS GRITTY SCIFI" trope that I dislike in weapon design. A lot of the designs fall victim to the "indistinctive slab of steel" design principle as well. Boring.

Still, the weapon illustrated beneath the Colt America L36 entry is pretty nice. I'm pretty biased in my like of longer ports and stainless slides, though. Looks like a mix of US, German and Belgian design traits, though you can find it's closest real world analogue in a South African design. The one beneath the MGL-12 entry is cool, but I've always had an attraction to the distinctive FAMAS design.
Larme
I like how the guns are colored and detailed for the first time ever, and how there seem to be a lot more of them pictured. The aura doesn't really bother me.
paws2sky
Unless something has changed in the re-revision, I'm really unimpressed with the gear art in SR4A. The "aura" around them makes them look like dropped l00t I might pick up after beating an opponent in Miracle Shooter. I can just hear the bling sound now...

Give me the classic Street Samurai catalog line art any day.

-paws
Dakka Dakka
I second that biometal79's guns would have looked a lot better. I don't mind the auras so much, but have the artists even read the descriptions of the weapons they should paint?
- Where are the four barrels on the Sakura Fubuki?
- Why does the Colt Manhunter look almost like the Ares Predator of SR4?
- Where is the drum on the Super Warhawk? This is supposed to be a revolver, not a "shootybox".
- Where is the grenadelauncher with a 6 grenade magazine hidden on the Ares Alpha?

The AK-97 looks OK as does the Ingram Smartgun. The HK-227 X actually looks more in line with the description. The XM30 and AM-CMDT look just plain ugly IMHO, whereas their pictures in SR4 look a lot better.
Heath Robinson
Dakka Dakka,
Because there's no actual relationship between the guns and the images, most likely.
Dakka Dakka
QUOTE (Heath Robinson @ Apr 8 2009, 06:05 PM) *
Dakka Dakka,
Because there's no actual relationship between the guns and the images, most likely.

If that is so, why are there images at all?
ICPiK
QUOTE (silva @ Apr 8 2009, 05:18 AM) *
With the exception of Ares Viper, I didnt. And, overall, I didnt like the "blue aura" look. Feels ... dont know...unserious?

I would like it better if they had just adopted the traditional models ( like these here: http://biometal79.deviantart.com/art/My-Sh...tion-1-48801985 ).

How about you guys?

Man those are awesome... where are the stats for that salvette penetrator?
Heath Robinson
QUOTE (Dakka Dakka @ Apr 8 2009, 06:21 PM) *
If that is so, why are there images at all?

To look pretty, of course. Why else is there art in an RPG book?
Dakka Dakka
QUOTE (Heath Robinson @ Apr 8 2009, 09:00 PM) *
To look pretty, of course. Why else is there art in an RPG book?

There are a lot of images that are prettier, if it is acceptable to select images that are unrelated to the text.
Adarael
In all subsequent releases of Shadowrun, I demand all gear pictures be replaced with images of bows, ponies, candy, and kittens.
Dakka Dakka
Rainbows not bows for archery, I assume.
Moon-Hawk
QUOTE (Adarael @ Apr 8 2009, 02:07 PM) *
In all subsequent releases of Shadowrun, I demand all gear pictures be replaced with images of bows, ponies, candy, and kittens.



QUOTE (Dakka Dakka @ Apr 8 2009, 02:10 PM) *
Rainbows not bows for archery, I assume.


Ooooh. See, I thought he meant a hot lesbian ninja weretiger stripper named "Candy" riding around rigging a horseman, firing a ridiculously over-sized "troll bow."
...What?
Heath Robinson
QUOTE (Dakka Dakka @ Apr 8 2009, 08:05 PM) *
There are a lot of images that are prettier, if it is acceptable to select images that are unrelated to the text.

But those ones are inappropriate to the section these pictures are in.
Larme
QUOTE (Dakka Dakka @ Apr 8 2009, 10:24 AM) *
I second that biometal79's guns would have looked a lot better. I don't mind the auras so much, but have the artists even read the descriptions of the weapons they should paint?
- Where are the four barrels on the Sakura Fubuki?
- Why does the Colt Manhunter look almost like the Ares Predator of SR4?
- Where is the drum on the Super Warhawk? This is supposed to be a revolver, not a "shootybox".
- Where is the grenadelauncher with a 6 grenade magazine hidden on the Ares Alpha?

The AK-97 looks OK as does the Ingram Smartgun. The HK-227 X actually looks more in line with the description. The XM30 and AM-CMDT look just plain ugly IMHO, whereas their pictures in SR4 look a lot better.


I think the pictures are a bit out of order with the text, probably based on spacing, so they're not trying to present a single barreled gun as the sakura fubuki. Like all editions of the Shadowrun core book, it's a bit ambiguous which pictures are intended to go with each gun.
silva
Some guns illustrations are out of synch with the text: The Colt Manhunter description has the Ares Predator illustration. The same goes with the light pistol.

Well, when my copy arrives, I will insert a print of the biometal79 guns in this page. smile.gif
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (silva @ Apr 7 2009, 10:18 PM) *
With the exception of Ares Viper, I didnt. And, overall, I didnt like the "blue aura" look. Feels ... dont know...unserious?

I would like it better if they had just adopted the traditional models ( like these here: http://biometal79.deviantart.com/art/My-Sh...tion-1-48801985 ).

How about you guys?



Agreed, I think that they should have just kept the original line art from the SR4 BBB... Much better looking in my opinion...
I prefer my guns to look realistic, rather than cartoony Sci-Fi'ish... Even the traditional Sci-Fi Guns of most other products tend to look more Realistic thatn in the SR4a document....
Oh Well...
silva
QUOTE
I prefer my guns to look realistic, rather than cartoony Sci-Fi'ish..

Pretty much sums up my feeling about it.
toturi
QUOTE (Moon-Hawk @ Apr 9 2009, 03:14 AM) *
Ooooh. See, I thought he meant a hot lesbian ninja weretiger stripper named "Candy" riding around rigging a horseman, firing a ridiculously over-sized "troll bow."
...What?

I like the way you think. Especially the "troll bow" part.
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (toturi @ Apr 8 2009, 06:41 PM) *
I like the way you think. Especially the "troll bow" part.



Definitely Creative... Gotta Give Credit...
Backgammon
I liked a lot of them. Hated the shotguns though. I want my shotguns to look manly and trailer-trashy. Overall I prefered the previous illustrations, though only by a little.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012