Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Reunification
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
moosegod
Anyways, after reading Threats 2 (aka, how to screw over players Mk. II), I gots to thinking.

(Dangerous, I know)

Anyways, who would be likely to reunite? I was thinking CAS and UCAS, if the UCAS is willing to cut welfare programs. Maybe the Manitoo seperatists with the UCAS to get support against the Algonquins. And the PCC for military aid.

The Ute would never, since they are psycotically racists. The Sioux are also an no, since they effectively exist as an anti-UCAS nation. And Tsimshan since Mitsuhama wouldn't like it and the UCAS might enforce some sort of enviromental regulation wobble.gif

The others I can see going either way.
Arethusa
Every time the 60s come around, a war divides the nation...
moosegod
Don't forget the 29s for market crashes, either.
Voran
And every time you masturbate, god kills a kitten.

Anyhoo. After reading through Shadows of NA, I was actually surprised to see that the CAS seems better put together than the UCAS. Sure its seems the UCAS technically has all the old offices and structures (pentagon, DC, various intelligence hqs) but it seems all corrupted and chaotic. The Shadows of NA painted the CAS is relatively stable strokes. I wouldnt be surprised if the CAS slowly gobbles up a bit more space of UCAS. Seems like some of the UCAS states might even welcome it.
Centurion
Indeed, as odd as it sounds, the CAS looks like one of the most stable and most similar to the old style democratic republics before everything went down the swisher; and thats on a global comparison, just not North America.
Abstruse
What's so shocking? Us Southern boys aren't all uncoothed rednecks and cowboys line dancing you know...

The Abstruse One
Austere Emancipator
QUOTE (Centurion)
CAS looks like one of the most stable and most similar to the old style democratic republics before everything went down the swisher

That will change once SoE comes out. Either it does, or the SoE-team can look forward to being murdered.
shadd4d
This had better not be in comparison to Germany. Germany's strong but not that stable. What can you say about a "country" made up of 19 little countries, of which 1 is a Mercenary monarchy, 1 is a troll monarchy - king, 1 is a theocracy, and 4 are free cities. And that's just the tip o' the iceberg.

Don
Nath
QUOTE (Austere Emancipator)
That will change once SoE comes out. Either it does, or the SoE-team can look forward to being murdered.

*add it to the pile of death threats*

Hmm, he looks less dangerous than the Belgian nationalists...
Austere Emancipator
I somehow doubt Belgian nationalists have a strong interest in what happens to Belgium in Shadowrun. nyahnyah.gif
Cray74
QUOTE (moosegod)
Anyways, after reading Threats 2 (aka, how to screw over players Mk. II), I gots to thinking.

(Dangerous, I know)

Anyways, who would be likely to reunite? I was thinking CAS and UCAS, if the UCAS is willing to cut welfare programs.

I tend to think it'd be easier not to have nations balkanize in the first place, but that's some heavier rewriting of the setting.
TinkerGnome
If the CAS catches up in terms of technology, they've also got one of the best militaries on the continent. I don't know if they would ever reunite (being from the south, I can conclusively say that Southern pride is not often overstated). If the UCAS were to want to join the CAS, that might happen, but I can't see it happening the other way around.

You're more likely to see a strong alliance with free trade agreements and possibly more lax borders.
Nath
QUOTE (Austere Emancipator)
I somehow doubt Belgian nationalists have a strong interest in what happens to Belgium in Shadowrun. nyahnyah.gif

With the sample of strange, bizarre and weird people you daily encounter here on Dumpshock, how could you doubt there can't be also a Belgian nationalist playing SR somewhere in the world ? Well... you don't need to search the whole world, he's in Belgium. And an agressive one with that !
moosegod
From what I remember from SoNA, I think part of the CAS's technology lag is also ideological. They have a brown water navy and their gear isn't as good. Why? 'Cause that's how they do things.
Nath
I agree. The CAS Navy is supposed to have a strong submarines force (including those new sub carrying aircraft) and two med-sized air carriers (one less than 15 years old). That's enough to make a blue-water navy. So for the CAS to have a brown-water navy, it must be a matter of method and use, rather than of equipment.
moosegod
Two carriers? You could do a blue water navy, I guess, but you can bet at least one battlegroup will be sitting and waiting for Aztlaner aggression.

That leaves only one... Not really effective projection of force.

Submarines are good at 1) denying the use of the ocean 2) nukes and 3) covert insertions. None of those will really help you use the ocean, just stop others.

In other words, it's partially ideological and partially equipment based.
Jon Szeto
Carrier battlegroups are expensive to maintain. Also, why bother to project power across the Atlantic when your major enemy lies on the other side of the Gulf of Mexico? While controlling the Atlantic might be a nice ego stroke for the UCAS, the more important priority for the CAS is being able to control the Caribbean.

The middleweight carrier groups the CAS maintains really aren't power projection capital ships, but rather auxiliary options. After all when it comes to achieving air supremacy over the Caribbean, the CAS already has a dozen or so unsinkable carrier platforms: Pensacola NAS, Eglin AFB, Maxwell AFB, MacDill AFB, and lots of others along the Gulf Coast. The Confederation carriers are there mostly to give the CAS the option of conducting an attack from the seaward side of the Carib.
theartthief
QUOTE (TinkerGnome)
(being from the south, I can conclusively say that Southern pride is not often overstated). 


Definitely never overstated. An elementary teacher shared this story with my mom who is still teaching.

On a field trip to a Civil War battle site the teacher asked, "Who won this battle?" expecting the response, "The Confederacy".

She got, "We did!"

Not to mention that there are bumper stickers I see all the time that say stuff like:

Yankees 1
Rebels 0
Halftime

Now, assume that these feelings were still there when the split occurred and I don't see much hope for reunification.

[edit] The political views of my neighbors are not my political views. [/edit]

- theartthief
Centurion
QUOTE (Abstruse @ Apr 19 2004, 08:14 AM)
What's so shocking?  Us Southern boys aren't all uncoothed rednecks and cowboys line dancing you know...

The Abstruse One

Oh, I know. I'm just glad the SR metaplot didn't paint it that way. After all that wacky stereotypical stuff involving Native American genocide, Japanese imperialism, etc, I'm both happy and surprised they didn't do something retarded along the lines of african-american orks being lynched from spurting oil derricks in the middle of a swamp with endless desert plains and cowboys in the background while an Immortal elf dressed as J.R. Ewing cackles in the foreground.

Also, looking forward to the metaplot finally catching up and delivering Hall of Montezuma pt. II: This time, it's personal
Dax
You sound a little bitter there Centurion. sarcastic.gif
Bearclaw
It seems like it would go the other way. Increased balkanizaion rather than reunification.
Try this: Texas demanding that CAS declare war on Aztlan, then seceeding when they don't. Then allying with CFS and Amazonia, and forcing Aztlan to withdraw from Columbia, San Diego and Austin, or face a 3 front war.

I mean seriuosly, talk about southern pride. Texans are more proud of being Texans than anyone else I've ever met from anywhere. What are the odds of Aztlan taking the capitol and holding it for what, 10 years now? That's probably the most unbelievable thing in a list of improbable things they've put in the story.
Centurion
Dax: is it a good or bad thing that I was actually pretty happy when I wrote that?

Bearclaw: Don't even get me started. I actually think the whole Atlzan uber police state was such an incredible waste, story wise. They could have kept Mexico exactly the way it is and it'd be perfect for Shadowrun.
Arethusa
Centurion, you have my complete agreement. In fact, it really is a shame. A third world country full of drug runners and little law enforcement and political instability really would've been a lot more interesting than Aztlan.
Centurion
Are, well, unlike the NAN, which is so hardcoded into the SR plotline it's dang near impossible to modify muchly, Atzlan is easier to modify and still keep the canon coherent. Just keep the shadowy rich cartel doing all the blood magic wackiness and keep all the wonderful little El Mariachi/Desperado/From Duck 'till Dawn goodness. And if you want to have them win the Texas war, just make it because they could unleash force 300 blood spirits or something along the line to rampage through the middle of El Paso, San Antonio, etc. Personally, in my SR verse, I had them take south Texas but it's currently a rather nasty Chechnya style tit-for-tat. Sure it's flat and open country and not really suited to guerilla operations, but I'm sure guerillas can get creative when they have the backing of CAS, the Texas state gov't, and Ares.

(And flipping through this copy of NAGTNA and looking at the pic of Texan forces...no wonder we lost, we had BARNEY FRICKEN' FIFE on our side.)
Crimsondude 2.0
QUOTE (Arethusa)
Centurion, you have my complete agreement. In fact, it really is a shame. A third world country full of drug runners and little law enforcement and political instability really would've been a lot more interesting than Aztlan.

Ah, I think you're overestimating the integrity of the Aztlan military and law enforcement. Moreover, the SB focused on the frontier warzones, Yucatan and Tenochtitlan; but I have no doubt that very little has changed in the backwater parts of Aztlan. Same assholes, new uniforms. BFD.

As for the "country full of drug runners;" why would Aztechnology want the competition? Just because ORO went kind of legit (and renamed itself) doesn't, in my mind, mean that the drugs aren't still there.
Arethusa
A lot of similar elements are still there, but they're now much more official. What Aztlan really does, unfortunately, is kill the potential to have something like Once Upon A Time In Mexico. Not just plot elements, but motifs and atmosphere. It's just not the same. Sniff.
Gotti
I really don't see reunification happening. The south is THE SOUTH. In addition, it's becoming one of the most integrated places in america. The white guys and black guys are all proud of being southern. We're building our own Rap genre. Something that is surprisingly popular among even oldstyle rednecks.

In my personal opinion, I've always pictured the south as being highly militarized(paranoia about the UCAS, and dealign with Aztlan), with regular troops being supported by the "militias"(aka nat'l gaurd units) of most states. The reason for paranoia is simple: most of the strategic air and missile portions of the old US went to the UCAS. So the CAS maintains a heavy, highly mobilized(mostly motorized) military. I also like the idea of Penal units...

Crimsondude 2.0
QUOTE (Arethusa @ Apr 20 2004, 05:16 PM)
A lot of similar elements are still there, but they're now much more official.  What Aztlan really does, unfortunately, is kill the potential to have something like Once Upon A Time In Mexico.  Not just plot elements, but motifs and atmosphere.  It's just not the same.  Sniff.

Yeah, but there's still plenty of patronismo in Aztlan, and Aztechnology (emphasized more in Aztlan, but still present in Corporate Download.), to play with.

But that's just good clean fun--just like The Hunt in TT.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012