Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: The Tir and Russia
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Dax
As I am a slight histroy buff, I was noticing something when I took a look at one of my books on the history of the Russian empire today. During the decline of the Romanov family line, around the time of the first World War, you had a situation very similar to what's happening in Tir Tan in the Shadowrun timeline right now.

Russia was one of the last absolute monarchies on the planet at the time, and the Tzar's right to absolute rule was being challenged on every front by revolt and revolution. The working class was no longer willing to serve an absolute monarch. The Tzar at the time, Nicholi Alexander Romonof, was forced to set up a limited form of representation, the Russian Duma. However, when the assembly demanded radical reform, Nicholi responded by dissolving the entire thing. After more than 30 years of enforced industrilzation, Russia's poor were poorer than ever. On Jan 9th, 1905, a massive protest marched on the Tzar's Winter Palace, in a non violent demonstration, asking for things to improve. The Palace Guards responded by opening fire on the crowd.

Meanwhile, in the Tir, the great numbers of elves are feeling a similar economic crunch, becoming just as destitue as the Serfs of Russia. They are becoming more and more willing to take matters into their own hands. The High Prince had really done squat to resolve the problem, excpet toss the people a bone in the form of the next Right of Progression. The Star Chamber is completely ignored by the Council of Princess. Mass protests and strikes rocked the country in 2059, only to be shut down with a brutality that would have done Ivan the Terrible proud.

Really, the only thing that the Tir needs is its own Lennin-esq figure who's willing to remake the country in his own radical image. The upshot of all of this is that I perdict that the Tir will experiance its own revolution within about 10 years of game time at max. And it will come so fast and so sudden that not even Surehand will see it coming before its too late.

....Course that's just my opinion at least.
Kakkaraun
That's Lenin wink.gif. And...who's the Tir's answer to Rasputin? biggrin.gif
Dax
I'd have to say Harlequin considering how many smart ass comments he made about the country in the Tir T sourcebook. biggrin.gif
shadd4d
He just doesn't seem ruthless enough, nor does he actually seem like he wants to take down the Tir. My top choice, however, would be Niall O'Conner, just because he can seem to speak the truth, is elven, and actually would enjoy some support from your average elvish guy, or even someone else in the Shadow community.

Don
Dax
Good point.
A Clockwork Lime
If you're just looking for a crazy guy in a position of power who has the greatest chance of being murdered a dozen different ways, I'd say that ork prince (I can't remember his name, dammit) would be a prime candidate. smile.gif
Dax
Larry Zincan?

I would hardly say he's the "crazy guy". If anything he's the one Prince who is actually trying to do something for the common man in the country, who is in a state of exile beacuse the establishment didn't care for his ideas.

Rasputin hardly fit that category.
Ancient History
Bah. Green Lucifer! vegm.gif
shadd4d
Or it can be a plot by Alichia to finally get back on the throne. I could actually imagine someone like her doing that.

Actually imagine if that actually went down, and Tir Taingre goes into a revolution. There's a war right there, with California trying to get Redding back, Tir's neighbors trying to get their share, Aztech willing to help anyone trying to eliminate the Tir, while Tir na Nog probably trying to send in path aids to help do "peace-keeping", which will probably make it even worse.

Don
Abstruse
Laughing Man's remained oddly silent about the recent uprising in TT, even though the name of the organization seems to bring back memories for certain princes...my money's on Harlequin being behind the whole thing. That's also an obvious choice...

The Abstruse One
CircuitBoyBlue
Rasputin didn't want the downfall of the Russian state. He was a big supporter of the tsar, actually. For Harlequin to be a close approximation of Rasputin, he would need to be a) widely known by the populace and suspected of using Surehand as a puppet ruler and b) hated by the aristocracy.

Also, I'm not entirely sure what the Corporate Courts rules against overthrowing governments are, exactly, but I'm sure they'd make an exception if a workers' state came into being, or at the very least they'd stop it from happening (nothing against helping nations stay in power, is there?).
Dax
QUOTE (Abstruse)
Laughing Man's remained oddly silent about the recent uprising in TT, even though the name of the organization seems to bring back memories for certain princes...my money's on Harlequin being behind the whole thing. That's also an obvious choice...

The Abstruse One

Well, one thing did occur to me. The fractured nature of the Rebels' of the Spire might stem from the fact that you have several different "backers". Harlequin, Zincan, Alichia could all be in control of a major faction. But then again, maybe not, though I do find H's silence somewhat un-nerving. That probably means he's up to something...

QUOTE
Also, I'm not entirely sure what the Corporate Courts rules against overthrowing governments are, exactly, but I'm sure they'd make an exception if a workers' state came into being, or at the very least they'd stop it from happening (nothing against helping nations stay in power, is there?).


Well, yes. Technically the Corp Court says no over throwing governments. (Not like Aztechnology cared.) But I don't think they would follow that completly if there was some amount of "back channel negotiation" going on. And that could happen for either side really.

QUOTE
Actually imagine if that actually went down, and Tir Taingre goes into a revolution. There's a war right there, with California trying to get Redding back, Tir's neighbors trying to get their share, Aztech willing to help anyone trying to eliminate the Tir, while Tir na Nog probably trying to send in path aids to help do "peace-keeping", which will probably make it even worse.


That does depend on how fast the rebel forces moved, and if different rebel factions came to blows again. After Lenin's group came to power, there was almost a counter revolution by extremeist from the other side of the scale. So it is possible that one faction could grab the whole country if they moved fast enough and hit hard enough, but that would also depend on a great deal of the army revolting along side the common population. (A country can't exist without the support of its educated strata.) If the Tir was to be rocked by Revolution, I definatly see California tryign to take back their territory. How far they'd get would definatly depend on Hesteby. Somehow I don't see her likeing any kind of army marching through her domain. Of course, if the rebels didn't move fast enough they'd get hammered by both California and the Salish-Sheide council. It would be one hell of a situation to be sure.
CircuitBoyBlue
It was one hell of a situation when it happened in Russia. They got invaded by 19 countries at once, and half their army went White.
Nath
QUOTE (Dax)
Technically the Corp Court says no over throwing governments. (Not like Aztechnology cared.)

The Corporate Court says no corp shall overthrow a government, nothing more, to the word. It's okay to support a future government to overthrow the old one. The Court's point is just that there always should be a national government ultimately reponsible for the lands (Boeing's unnamed island and Harris-3M's L5 space station demonstrate the trouble with corporate land not included in a constitued nation).

As a side note, Aztechnology couldn't care about the rule of a Court created almost ten years after it overthrew the Mexican/Aztlan government. The point could be argued for the rest of Central America, Colombia and Venezuela, but then they had the Aztlan gov as a proxy to do it.

QUOTE (Abstruse)
Laughing Man's remained oddly silent about the recent uprising in TT, even though the name of the organization seems to bring back memories for certain princes...my money's on Harlequin being behind the whole thing. That's also an obvious choice...

I don't find it at all obvious. About that name linked to the City of Spires, Hestaby says "What? No jests? No mocking prophecies of doom? No curiosity?" and Harlequin replies "No need. These events speak for themselves." It does not sound at all to me like he had something to do with it. You don't speak about the 'events' when you're the one behind them. It'd make sense if he was saying the name speak of itself, but that's not what he says. Alson Hestaby's two first questions are clearly adressed to Harlequin, so it's likely the third is as well. And Harlequin wouldn't be curious about it if he was behind it.
moosegod
One thing that the Californians have to think about is Saito. Now, Saito striking North is not inconcievable, but I doubt the communities in between them would like it.

Also, we have to remember someone very important. Hestaby. I mean, which ever side she jumps to (or, more likely, her own side) will get a huge boost. And she wouldn't like Saito coming on up, that's for sure. She already stopped one invasion. I think she can do a bunch of corp/deserters/Humanis scum rotfl.gif
booklord
I don't see the Tir - Russia analogy holding.

The majority of Tir's residents came from democratic countries. They left their homes to escape prejudice to the so called land of metahuman freedom. Now that they're Tir citizens all that democratic tradition baggage they brought with them is rubbing raw against the monarchy. This is particularly bad for non-elves since they obviously are second class citizens.
Gem the Troll
Never deal with a Dragon...what is a revolution supposed to do to neutralize Lofwyr and his assets? If trouble started you don't think he'd drop the hammer on it (so to speak)? Someone commented on Tir Na Nog sending in "peacekeeping" assets...rebellion might be the key for Saeder Krupp to get into the Tir. Dragons and Elves...I don't think the Tir needs anymore instigators to cause problems...there's plenty there already.
mfb
lofwyr has a vested interest in removing the current Tir government from power. any revolution would more likely benefit from lofwyr's involvement, though they might not like what they end up with.
booklord
Hetsaby seems to have a vested interest in helping the Rinelle ke'Tesra. Given Hetsaby's position as prince she is much more dangerous than Lofwyr. As for Lofwyr's attempts to force his way into the Tir corporate scene. Last I heard all you needed was to get on one prince's bad side and the cost of doing business in Tir goes way up.
Omer Joel
The fact that the Tir is itching for a Revolution doesn't say it has to be a Socialist one (even though a communist Tir will annoy the heck out of some corps, which will make th situation more interesting game-wise, especially if the direct assault option won't work. Shadowrunners will have tons of work in a second cold war, win' they?).

As always, the revolution might turn out quite different from what would be commonly expected - think of Iran. The workers got rid of the Shah (sp?), just to place religion in his place. On a second thought this might be an interesting model to rely on for the Tir revolution. Just think of the UB-equivalet taking over the Tir devil.gif devil.gif devil.gif

Or the Orkish minority doing something nasty against the Elven overlords. Not an all-out revolution, they lack the orkpower for that (but on the other hand, so did the NAN smile.gif), but mass-scale terrorism comes to mind. A little bit of FAB-III will have a nice effect on some of the super-mage Tir nobility, don't you think so? And there are enough corps which will be ready to supply the stuff.
northern lights
i am showing my total cluelessness here. but where did all this info come from??? last thing i had on TT was the TT sourcebook in 2ed

i'm always interested in bantering between immortals, so if someone could help me out here.

and personally i don't think harly cares what the hell happens in the tir or any other government for that matter.
Nath
Read Shadows of North America (aka SoNA).
northern lights
damn. i thought you'd say that. fanpro isn't going to come out with anything before i'm 30 and i had cought up on most everything else.

my thanks.
mfb
he certainly gives a damn about the government of the Tir; it's one of the larger concentrations of pure power on the globe. the sheer magnitude of some of the Tir's political players makes TT politics worth paying attention to.
Nath
They set up a multi-decenal plan and used their pure power to take over Oregon rotfl.gif Who'd take them seriously after that ?
northern lights
i honestly doubt that as an individual, harly is taken as enough of a threat by the tir to warrent actions against him.

and so long as they leave him alone, he'll leave them alone.

hey have agreed that metahumanity isn't ready for the big news flash and that info is about the only threat harly poses to the tir's power.
mfb
harly is one of the biggest proponents of keeping the ED history secret, as shown by multiple posts throughout the SR books, dating back to PANA (if not earlier). and dunk, who was a proponent of pulling back the curtains and revealing everything, took harley as enough of a serious threat that he wasn't willing to risk doing it against harley's wishes. granted, there was probably some mutual respect and no small amount of dialogue involved, but harley made some distinctly threat-oriented comments in at least one place (can't recall exactly where), and dunk seemed willing to concede his point in the face of those threats.

i think the thing about harley is, he doesn't give a flying fuck. most immortal players, they play a very deep game and never get directly involved--direct involvement means direct exposure to risk, and it only takes being unlucky once and you're out of the game permanently. players like harley, aina, and lofwyr are dangerous because, in immortal terms, they have some kind of psychotic deathwish. lofwyr and aina have a history of getting up close and personal with their enemies, and harley jumped into the middle of a ritual that would've opened the gateway to something that could destroy him without even noticing. in terms of human lifespans, that's like playing russian roulette every morning before breakfast.

which means that harley does pose enough of a threat to the TT gummint--or anyone who torques him off--that they'll definitely want to watch out for him. harley is capable of throwing everything he's got against them, with nothing in reserve. when a human decides that he's either going to accomplish something or die trying, it's a bad thing to be in that human's way. when an immortal elf decides that he's either going to accomplish something or die trying...
CardboardArmor
Course, he might get his wish without achieving anything. Happens more often than not to people with those kinds of wishes, you know.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012