QUOTE (PraetorGradivus @ Jun 11 2017, 10:10 PM)

By RAW its not a debate- Program Carrier doesn't work on commlinks because, not as you have argued in point 2, but rather the wording says your deck... and a commlink is not a deck. However RAW is often thrown out with the dish water to make sense of this game. Thank you Catalyst for your wonderful editing and consistent use of wording.
If you're going to spend the money required to turn a commlink into a substandard deck- I'm not going to stop you from putting in a program carrier with virtual machine. I think you're better off with an actual deck myself. But hey- to each his own. I really don't think it breaks the bank.
Me=- I'm more concerned over cheese like..2 used cyberfeet w/bulk[1] armor [3] and skates so we can add 6 armor and double our speed.
Ultimately things that might have a difference between RAI and RAW isn't really a question for this board. Sure you can get peoples opinions, but the final arbiter is your GM- ask him whether or not he'd allow it. Of course, if its for Missions- than the final arbiter are the wonderful people that volunteer their time keeping it going. (No- that wasn't sarcasm like my previous Thank You. The people responsible for maintaining the Missions FAQ probably don't get enough thanks for their hard work.)
edit- and while I'm at it, thanks Kiirnodel. You put in a lot of effort answering questions and offering opinions on this and the official board. I don't always agree with your opinions but usually follow your logic nonetheless.
Actually, per Data Trails pg 65 you can wire up a cyberdeck module to any device.
The reason I was going on this tangent was because I was wanting a way for non-hackers to be able to defend themselves vs a hacker. If you have a Fairlight Caliban (with an attack dongle 6) and a program carrier with Virtual Machine. You could run a Rating 6 Agent and Wrapper. Wrapper would make your commlink look like something innocent and might fool the enemy hacker for long enough to shoot him in the face (if he's present), or turn off wireless. If the hacker does find you, you have an IC program with Cybercombat 6, Attack 6 and Logic 6** to attack, and Firewall 7 and Willpower 6** to protect yourself.
This gives the street sam/mage some Matrix protection without having to be slaves to the hacker/technomancer
Also with Virtual Machine you could change out the second program for things like Encryption (to make your Firewall

, Signal Scrubber, Browser, Edit, ect, ect. Because, let's be honest, unless you're a hacker,, you really can't use the cyberdeck to it's fullest extent.
** == Per SR5 core rules page 246, you use the Agent's rating for attributes.