Dragonscript
Oct 13 2005, 01:38 PM
QUOTE (Jaid) |
all right, we'll try this from another angle:
there's been five years since SR3 plotlines ended. those would be the ones with the weapons as you knew them. now, realistically speaking... weapons technology is going to improve, given five years. making an underbarrel mount on an integrated grenade launcher doesn't exactly sound that unimaginably difficult to me, at least, so i don't see why it seems so impossible to you.
in SR3, your Alpha couldn't play music, or store an agent, or any number of other things. should we just ignore that, too? |
Gun designs don't change in that manner. The M-16A2 has been in service for damn near 30 years, and it has not changed in any significant way. The AK-47 has been used since the end of WWII and with cosmetic exceptions it hasn't changed since, in any way that would overly matter anyway. (I know the ak-47 has evolved but not to the point where it would matter to this discussion)
Now, it can be argued that tri-pods don't in fact connect to the under-barrel of a weapon in the first place, only bi-pods do. Tri-pods act as a cradle for the weapon and are usually mounted just slightly forward of the trigger, so that would mean that a Ares Alpha COULD be mounted but the AK-97 could not. But you would only get 1 grenade, just in case you haven't looked the grenade launcher is a manual pump action.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 01:41 PM
And the Ares Alpha GL has a 6 shot box-magazone or clip in SR terms
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 01:45 PM
So what catagory would you put a Smartgun under? If i put it as Average it's a Novatech Airware, an Iris Orb O/S, AND a camera. What would you pay for this regular 2350

value package? But wait, before you answer, what if i also throw in the extra sensors, servos, and actuators required for tricking out my weapon? Would you pay 400

for that?
In the words of Bugs Bunny, something screwy is going on around there.
At 400

, less 300

for the camera (and a nifty quality camera at that), it must be somewhere around Dumb? So you have to unload whatever makes it work as a Smartgun just to get anything into it? Or what it actually does for a living is that suppose to be it's "System"?
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 01:47 PM
treat it as a drone with no locomotion, just a turret.
So a rating of 3 for system, response, signal, firwall and pilot.
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 01:50 PM
P.S. Screw the commlink, i'm buying a Chrysler-Nissan Patrol-1 for 22,700

and getting the 6500

worth of commlink upgrades for free.

(and a better "commlink"/OS combo than you can buy off the shelf, the closest being 9,000

).
If you need me to hack something i'll be in my car.
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 01:51 PM
QUOTE (Nikoli) |
treat it as a drone with no locomotion, just a turret. So a rating of 3 for system, response, signal, firwall and pilot. |
I mean just the Smartgun itself.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 01:52 PM
how do you figure that Blakkie?
Smartgun potentially adds +2 to the attack pool.
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 01:55 PM
Device Type Complex, Device Rating 4,
Security vehicles, alphaware, research terminals, security devicesP.S. Don't get me started on doing the same thing with a 100

maglock.
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 01:56 PM
QUOTE (Nikoli) |
how do you figure that Blakkie? Smartgun potentially adds +2 to the attack pool. |
Ok, you have to start using the Quote feature because i have NO idea what you are talking about.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 01:58 PM
QUOTE (blakkie) |
P.S. Screw the commlink, i'm buying a Chrysler-Nissan Patrol-1 for 22,700 and getting the 6500 worth of commlink upgrades for free. (and a better "commlink"/OS combo than you can buy off the shelf, the closest being 9,000 ).
If you need me to hack something i'll be in my car. |
That's what I'm asking what do you mean.
I see absolutely nothing in the fluff text to indicate what you are saying abou the vehicle.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 02:00 PM
QUOTE (blakkie @ Oct 13 2005, 08:55 AM) |
Device Type Complex, Device Rating 4, Security vehicles, alphaware, research terminals, security devices |
Ah, yes. But look at all sample drones, even the security ones have a pilot and therefore system score of 3.
--edit--
Of course, the manufacturer could have just been cheep and it has a system of 4 but only a pilot of 3
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 02:08 PM
QUOTE (Nikoli @ Oct 13 2005, 08:00 AM) |
QUOTE (blakkie @ Oct 13 2005, 08:55 AM) | Device Type Complex, Device Rating 4, Security vehicles, alphaware, research terminals, security devices |
Ah, yes. But look at all sample drones, even the security ones have a pilot and therefore system score of 3.
--edit-- Of course, the manufacturer could have just been cheep and it has a system of 4 but only a pilot of 3
|
Ya, i get the 3,000

worth of Pilot software thrown in as a bonus.

It has that going for it over the Maglock(1), and wheels. But i'm really leaning towards the Maglock for it's strong points, the 100

price.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 02:10 PM
well, to be fair, when you have written you're own pilot program you can sorta stamp out copies much cheaper than the runner scum can buy it.
--edit--
oh, as for security devices with ratings, guess which I go with as a GM. the rating of the device, not the generic chart for guestimation. You skimp on a maglock and get rating one hoping for a system of 4 you'll be sadly mistaken.
And you still haven't explained how the Chrysler-Nissan Patrol-1 is better than the best off the shelf commlink/os
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 02:12 PM
QUOTE (Nikoli) |
well, to be fair, when you have written you're own pilot program you can sorta stamp out copies much cheaper than the runner scum can buy it. |
Yes, same for the Firewall and System. I'm just talking bargins here though. No need to Pir8 when The Man does it for you.
Nikoli
Oct 13 2005, 02:13 PM
heh
hyzmarca
Oct 13 2005, 02:30 PM
QUOTE (blakkie) |
QUOTE (Lord Ben @ Oct 13 2005, 06:31 AM) | A wireless Smart Platform is far more useful than a wired one... |
...and a Skinlinked one even moreso.  Well safer at least, as opposed to being able to let go of it and still fire it, eject the clip, and look through the camera (the last likely being the most useful). |
A skinlink would make a smart firing platform kind of redundant. You could usually get more out of your own skills. Unless you could mount it to the back of a cybertorso. Then that would be highly advantageous. You wouldn't have to turn armound to shoot people who are trying to sneak up on you.
calypso
Oct 13 2005, 02:41 PM
By the way, the Smart Firing Platform is an amazing deal. You get:
300 - Tripod
3000 - Pilot
600 - Targeting Autosoft
Even assuming it doesn't come with any firewall, you're still paying 2000

for a 3900+

value.
Calypso
blakkie
Oct 13 2005, 02:48 PM
QUOTE (hyzmarca @ Oct 13 2005, 08:30 AM) |
QUOTE (blakkie @ Oct 13 2005, 08:18 AM) | QUOTE (Lord Ben @ Oct 13 2005, 06:31 AM) | A wireless Smart Platform is far more useful than a wired one... |
...and a Skinlinked one even moreso.  Well safer at least, as opposed to being able to let go of it and still fire it, eject the clip, and look through the camera (the last likely being the most useful). |
A skinlink would make a smart firing platform kind of redundant. You could usually get more out of your own skills. Unless you could mount it to the back of a cybertorso. Then that would be highly advantageous. You wouldn't have to turn armound to shoot people who are trying to sneak up on you.
|
I actually misread/misunderstood Ben initially. However even when deploying the platform the skinlink would allow you to still give the platform commands (at a touch), where as disabling wireless entirely would require you to either DJ into it or flip the wireless back on and then spend the action to jack out or turn off the wireless again after you gave it the command.
It would depend heavily on intended use, whether or not you wanted to give it new commands between setting it down and leaving it and then returning to it again.
TheNarrator
Oct 14 2005, 03:22 AM
QUOTE (Nikoli @ Oct 13 2005, 08:41 AM) |
And the Ares Alpha GL has a 6 shot box-magazone or clip in SR terms |
.....dang, I just checked and you're right.
Well, that's a change since SR3. Doesn't really fit with the appearence of the weapon in the little picture, honestly. And personally, I'd rather have the pump action. Lets you load a particular kind of grenade on the spot by putting it in the tube, then working the pump action and firing. ("Hmm... I've got five Concussion grenades in my launcher, but this situation calls for White Phosphorus. Five years ago, I could have grabbed a WP from my bandoleer, loaded it, pumped and fired in less than 3 seconds. Now I have to eject my clip, load in a WP round, reload the clip, and then fire and it might take 6 seconds. Progress sucks! Even if the rifle does play .mp3's of punk rock during combat!")

Well, whatever. It is what it is.
Jaid
Oct 14 2005, 03:40 AM
well, if you have it smartlinked (ie, 90% of the time) you can eject the clip as a free action, load the new clip as a simple action, and fire as a simple action. that's still just one IP.
Gothic Rose
Oct 14 2005, 03:43 AM
QUOTE (Jaid) |
well, if you have it smartlinked (ie, 90% of the time) you can eject the clip as a free action, load the new clip as a simple action, and fire as a simple action. that's still just one IP. |
Like all of them

Ares Alpha comes with integral smartlink.
But yeah. Same amount of time used to get the same effect.
Jaid
Oct 14 2005, 03:50 AM
i suppose i should have clarified that: if you are smartlink-capable, then you can do it in 1 IP.
and if you're not, that should be because you've been captured, and someone took away your visual gear, and you aren't cybered up. because there's no reason to not to be smartlink capable anymore, you're not gonna get a much cheaper +2 dice on attacks than that.
TheNarrator
Oct 14 2005, 04:38 AM
QUOTE (Jaid) |
well, if you have it smartlinked (ie, 90% of the time) you can eject the clip as a free action, load the new clip as a simple action, and fire as a simple action. that's still just one IP. |
Heh. Yeah, I suppose I should have considered that the runner would probably have had the foresight to load the alternate kinds of grenades into their own clips ahead of time.
(Although, you will be dropping your clip in that scenario, I suppose that's a non-issue when you suddenly find yourself needing a different kind of grenade on short notice.)
For purposes of style, however, I still miss the pump-action grenade launcher.
Corywn
Oct 14 2005, 08:02 PM
QUOTE (TheNarrator @ Oct 14 2005, 04:02 PM) |
...I still miss the pump-action grenade launcher. |
Just for note... "Pump Action" doesn't necessarily mean it can't be clip fed... Unless you're assuming pistol/rifle/whatever style firing mechanism, where the force of the "shot" ejects the grenade shell. Which might not be the case here.
[EDIT]messed up the quoted name...[/edit]
FrankTrollman
Oct 14 2005, 08:10 PM
QUOTE (TheNarrator) |
Although, you will be dropping your clip in that scenario, I suppose that's a non-issue when you suddenly find yourself needing a different kind of grenade on short notice. |
I know that the first thing on my mind when firing grenades all over the place is leaving as few traces of my presence as possible. "In and out like a ghost", that's the motto of every shadowrunner with a diverse set of grenades for his grenade launcher.
No wait... it's not.
-Frank
TheNarrator
Oct 14 2005, 09:25 PM
Well, they are kind of expensive.
Kremlin KOA
Oct 14 2005, 10:22 PM
what? can't I pick up my grenade clip after the battle?
blakkie
Oct 15 2005, 02:22 AM
The only possible concern about dropping clips i can think about is not having use of them if you relocate before you have time to pick them up.
Jaid
Oct 15 2005, 02:35 AM
then have them on a string leading to your belt.
or, if you're one them rich shadowrunners, have it hanging on stealth cord or something =P
and besides, if you have:
1) broken out the grenade launcher
2) felt the need to upgrade the ammo, and
3) feel the need to leave without taking the time to pick up your clips
then i think you probably have bigger worries on your mind than those 30-45

grenades you just dropped on the ground. sure, that's possibly over 200

sitting there, but if you can't spare the simple action to pick up your grenades, then getting out of there is a touch more important.
(besides, you can always set them to proximity detonate to cover your rear... thanks to wireless connectivity =D or at least, i think you can... )
blakkie
Oct 15 2005, 02:53 AM
It isn't the cash. Its the loss of being able to use it. If i don't have time to pick up the grenades before relocating bad things are likely still happening.
BTW is pulling out a clip from easy access pockets included in the Simple Action to insert a clip? If so picking up a clip off the ground is slower, although i personally wouldn't rule picking it up so if they were prone and the clip right there.
P.S. I forsee disabling wireless on any grenade/explosive my PC is carrying, and 'vigorously' encouraging the rest of my teammates to follow the same policy.
Jaid
Oct 15 2005, 03:00 AM
well, yeah, you don't keep the grenades wireless all the time, just when they're not on your person =P (maybe when they can't detect you anymore... although that still only gives you 3 meters)
i presume clips are kept stored in such a place as to be readily available to be part of the loading a clip action. but the simple action i meant was just for picking them up, not for loading the clip also. i coulda swore it was a simple action anyways...
blakkie
Oct 15 2005, 03:08 AM
QUOTE (Jaid) |
well, yeah, you don't keep the grenades wireless all the time, just when they're not on your person =P (maybe when they can't detect you anymore... although that still only gives you 3 meters) |
But they need to be in wireless mode to detect that, no?

QUOTE |
i presume clips are kept stored in such a place as to be readily available to be part of the loading a clip action. but the simple action i meant was just for picking them up, not for loading the clip also. i coulda swore it was a simple action anyways... |
What i was refering to is if you pick a clip back up off the ground that has a grenade type you want to change back to (Simple Action), eject the current clip (Free Action), and insert the clip you just picked up (Simple Action), you don't have time to fire till the next IP. Basically it's mostly a one-way trip to the ground until you've got some free time. Of course i guess you could have duplicate clips of given types, but eventually the GM is going to start asking awkward questions about all the bits of gear you have so readily available for use.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.