Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: WE NEED POWER ARMOR!
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2
emo samurai
It would be awesome, but it would destroy the game. But it would be awesome!
nick012000
Military-grade hardened armor is powered, and there are rules in Rigger 3 for creating vehicles than can be used to create mecha.
emo samurai
Is it REALLY awesome? And adaptable for SR4?
SL James
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.
Jaid
actually, SR3 had one kind of powered armor as i recall. i don't think hardened armor was really powered (although it was most likely environmental, but not neccessarily... i think it had to be added in).

but anyways, there was an underwater powered armor. that was it for that.

there were also rules for building vehicles that moved around by walking, and that had arms. you could certainly have built mecha, but with the rules, i don't think you could have made actual powered armor (although a few simple houserules would have solved everything, as i recall... the only difference with the powered armor was that the RAS override wasn't operative, pretty much, i think, and you didn't suffer any penalties for it).

anyways, they seem to have basically planned for the possibility i would say... i mean, what else are you supposed to do with pilot anthroform skill? it's either that, or they intend to make rules for rigging humans with skillwires, and i'm personally leaning towards mecha or mecha-like vehicles.

[edit]
QUOTE (SL James)
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.
hmmm... that's funny... coulda swore that's what happens when someone posts a "psionics are overpowered" thread over on the psionics forum of the wizards boards...

ah well, so be it:

MRAOW! KABOOM!

[/edit]
Hasaku
I completely forget whose site this is. Regardless, I give you... Teh Awesome!

edit: You're thinking of the JIM suit in SR3. It was basically an anthroform submersible that seating one. Do a search of the Shadowrun forums; you'll find plenty of threads about power armor.
SL James
QUOTE (Jaid)
anyways, they seem to have basically planned for the possibility i would say... i mean, what else are you supposed to do with pilot anthroform skill? it's either that, or they intend to make rules for rigging humans with skillwires, and i'm personally leaning towards mecha or mecha-like vehicles.

Snake-Eyes: For rigging best friends.

And, I use the skill to pilot arachnodrones and various mini-walkers. But that's me.
emo samurai
God only kills kittens if the capitalization's unwarranted. Which it isn't, since POWER ARMOR IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!
Jaid
in SR4, there is only one vehicle i am aware of that should obviously use the pilot anthroform skill. personally, i consider i unlikely that they put in an entirely separate pilot skill just for the Kanmushi, and therefore presume they intend to expand on the number of drones that would require pilot anthroform.

of course, two other vehicles *may* use the skill (also both drones), as they are defined as "crawlers". of course, if they just mean tracked vehicles (which i personally could also see the description as applying to) then they would presumably be ground vehicles. it's hard to say based on SR4 only, since there are no labelled pictures of the various drones AFAICT. of course, a better knowledge of SR3 than i have might help with the other two drones. the aztechnology crawler, and the GM-Nissan doberman are the two.

in fact, iirc, anthroform is better classified as humanoid in shape, as i understand it... which, if it is meant to mean humanoid, then not even the kanmushi requires pilot anthroform.

basically, what i am saying is that the fact that they have included a skill specifically to pilot anthroforms indicates that they are planning to introduce some anthroform type vehicles at some point.

of course, i could be wrong, mind you.
Tanka
QUOTE (emo samurai)
God only kills kittens if the capitalization's unwarranted. Which it isn't, since POWER ARMOR IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!

Sigh.
Critias
QUOTE (SL James)
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.

That's not god. That's me.
Gothic Rose
QUOTE (emo samurai)
God only kills kittens if the capitalization's unwarranted. Which it isn't, since POWER ARMOR IS AWESOME!!!!!!!!

...

I'm going to assume you're being jesterly at this point.

Bullet Raven
Why on earth would you want to add mecha to Shadowrun?
Adarael
Do you not see his capitals?
They indicate emphasis.

Emphasis implies immediate, overpowering, jaw-clenching NEED.
Bullet Raven
couldn't you work out a suit of powered armour using some cyberware rules?

i.e. while you're wearing it your attributes are as if you had cyberlimbs, bone lacing and some headware but you're limited to one initiative pass at a penalty to initiative and take a penalty to all tests involving fine motor control.

You couldn't wear anything under it and it would be more than obvious that you were wearing it to security forces.

and then somebody hacks it and hilarity ensues
Mr.Platinum
I do not know if it would ruin the game having power armour.

I KNow it would be extremley hard to get like Mile Spec Armour, and i don't feeli it would unbalance the game but potentially increase the opposition difficulty.
Bull
QUOTE (SL James)
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.

Play nice smile.gif At least the entire post wasn't all in Caps. Though I am all for God killing Kittens. ork.gif

And I will say this regarding Power Armor... I'd never allow it in my games, but there are a lot of different play styles and play groups out there. I've been seeing requests for, or house rules to create, Powered Armor since I first got on the SR mailing list back when Dinosaurs roamed the earth.

Personally, I'm still waiting for FanPro to just say that Kerensky (No idea if I spelled that right) from battletech is really Harlequin, and that battletech is the 7th world ork.gif

Bull
Ed_209a
QUOTE (SL James)
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.


Don't feel too bad, God kills kittens for lots of stuff. They are kind of fragile.
Ed_209a
I feel that mature Drone/Rigger technology killed the concept of power armor.

ANthro drones wouldn't have the soft messy part in the middle, so they can be smaller for identical capabilities. With a rigger in residence, you have nearly identical capabilities, with much less exposure to risk. If one drone takes a Panther sabot round, you just jump into another, and let the damaged one keep up as best it can.
Darkness
QUOTE (Bull)
Personally, I'm still waiting for FanPro to just say that Kerensky (No idea if I spelled that right) from battletech is really Harlequin, and that battletech is the 7th world ork.gif

The spelling is correct... but don't give me any funny ideas grinbig.gif
hyzmarca
Unless someone really fragged the mana cycle mechwarrior should be an adept discipline. Of course, someone already fragged the mana cycle twice now, halting it for some time in the Fourth World and accelerating it in the Sixth, so it is quite possible.
Bull
QUOTE (hyzmarca)
Unless someone really fragged the mana cycle mechwarrior should be an adept discipline. Of course, someone already fragged the mana cycle twice now, halting it for some time in the Fourth World and accelerating it in the Sixth, so it is quite possible.

This is getting horribly off topic, but it's been stated by FASA (FanPro just avoids the issue, I think) that the mana cycles are not "set". AKA< there's no designated time period that they last, there's no "Maximum" and "Minimum" for the mana to rise or fall... It's pretty much random.

Bull
PBTHHHHT
QUOTE (Ed_209a)
QUOTE (SL James)
Every time someone makes a thread title in all caps, god kills a kitten.


Don't feel too bad, God kills kittens for lots of stuff. They are kind of fragile.

I heard they can be tasty too, though I've never (or will) try it.
The way I hear they're prepared in China is you toss the cat in a boiling pot, and then hold down the lid. Voila.

You guys sickened yet? Darn. nyahnyah.gif
Mordrid Soud
One of my players comes up to me one day, "I want power armor.". I say, "sure buddy, here you go.", and in comes the Lone Star T.A.C. unit that has been tracking him since the National Bank of Seattle "incident" consisting of a 3 man point team all wearing power armor. "All you have to do is take it.". Don't feel too bad for him... he never checked for tracers from the bank loot and never moved his safehouse which Lone Star knew about from the Seattle Harbor Master "incident". The fact he was able to pull off the bank job was shear luck combined with a bit of karma. In the end it was his time smile.gif .
I have no problem with power armor in Shadowrun, keeping in mind that it is very expensive, and the only people who could reasonably afford its cost and upkeep would be corps. Keep in mind when I refer to power armor I am not talking 20-50 foot mechs (Those just aren't economically/logistically viable even to me to use in SR).
Ed_209a
"All you have to do is take it"

Oh, that is classic. The moment, the line, the setup, oh!

That is the kind of thing GMs long for their entire career.

Ed_209a
QUOTE (PBTHHHHT)
The way I hear they're prepared in China is you toss the cat in a boiling pot, and then hold down the lid.  Voila.

I would eat cat, but not if they prepared it like that.

It's not _that_ hard to grab a back leg and swing it's head against a wall...

And skin the nasty thing first!
jervinator
Power armor is about as feasible as cyber-zombies. You spend many thousands, possibly millions of nuyen on a single combat item that has less battlefield effectiveness than a (relatively less expensive) fully-loaded LAV.
Technologically, there is no reason why not. But is it worthwhile? Not really. If you keep it semi-realistic, you will wind up wind an overpriced, maintainance-intensive suit that can still be taken out by a single sprawl ganger with a 1,000 nuyen.gif rocket launcher. If you make the suit either reliable and/or reasonably priced (under 250,000 nuyen.gif , including the specialized gear required to maintain/repair it and Black Market mark-up) then I believe you are being a little too generous.

That said, my players received two sets of light powered armor, with just enough musculature to negate it's own encumbrance, though not enough to actually enhance strength, from their employer. Many times the price-tag isn't measured in nuyen wink.gif
emo samurai
What about personal energy shields? And how effective are anti-bullet barriers?
hyzmarca
QUOTE (emo samurai)
What about personal energy shields? And how effective are anti-bullet barriers?

It depends on how many successes you got on the sorcery test.
FrankTrollman
QUOTE (emo samurai)
What about personal energy shields? And how effective are anti-bullet barriers?

Not very. You get 1 point of hardened armor for every hit you get on the spellcasting test. Which means that if you had six hits on a personal bullet barrier you'd still get no "hardening" benefit against a heavy pistol with standard ammo in it (if it hits you, there's at least 1 net hit and that means a DV of 6 and an AP of -1). And so as far as that goes you might as well just use an Armor spell (which can't have holes punched in it).

Interestingly, the barrier spell actually provides almost complete protection from Flechette or Explosive ammo, and actually complete protection from StickN'Shock, so there's substantial reason to deploy one.

-Frank
Athenor
For the record?

System Failure Spoiler.... wink.gif

[ Spoiler ]



No, I'm not terribly evil yet, but it's a cool concept!
Azralon
I hereby designate the first power-armor organization in Shadowrun to be called the Drop Bear clan.
Hasaku
The closest I intend to get to mecha in SR is a few think tanks (from GitS) guarding ultra-secure facilities.

edit: Something like the S-K Thinktank in this thread.
Toptomcat
QUOTE
ANthro drones wouldn't have the soft messy part in the middle, so they can be smaller for identical capabilities. With a rigger in residence, you have nearly identical capabilities, with much less exposure to risk. If one drone takes a Panther sabot round, you just jump into another, and let the damaged one keep up as best it can.

QUOTE
Power armor is about as feasible as cyber-zombies. You spend many thousands, possibly millions of nuyen on a single combat item that has less battlefield effectiveness than a (relatively less expensive) fully-loaded LAV.

What about regions of heavy jamming, where it's really difficult to rig properly?
PlatonicPimp
QUOTE (Ed_209a)

And skin the nasty thing first!


After all, there is more than one way to do it......
Liper
Jamming doesn't matter if you're hooked up through wires, or laser communications.

It's only wireless.
PlatonicPimp
OH, the "Plug your Mecha In" route. 'cause, y'know, trails of fiberoptic cable behind you don't get in the way at all, and they aren't obvious targets.

And lasers, huh? well, 'cause it's lasers, it must be better. Sure, you need direct LOS, and smoke, raised dust, high humidity and other comomn battlefeild conditions royally muck up their usefulness, but com'n! It's Lasers!
Ed_209a
QUOTE (toptomcat)
What about regions of heavy jamming, where it's really difficult to rig properly?


I see a military rigger unit being a handful of drones, tailored for the mission, an armored vehicle for the primary rigger to rig from while the secondary rigger drives. A support unit consisting of signals Intelligence people and a self-propelled mortar stay in supporting positions.

Drones move up to do the mission, with the riggermobile a km or so back. The support unit is 2-3 km behind them. They locate and suppress enemy ECM units with indirect fire in support of the primary team's mission. Something like a Anti-radiation guided mortar shell would be ideal.

Of course, if we are talking a serious committal of assets, we may have large aerial drones loitering with standing orders to engage any ECM emitters that don't have the right IFF.

I think the tech for this would be cheaper than powered armor, and you only put 2 people onto the battlefield, as compared to an entire squad.
Shrike30
Good lord... whatever happened to just getting some infantry on the ground?

I can understand drones being rigged in as overwatch/surveillance and to provide fire support, but being your primary unit on the ground?

Commo gear of the future is good and powerful, but the possibilities of counter-hacking (or someone simply firing an antiradiation missile of their own targeted at your ECCM) would seriously worry me. Personally, I think I'd rather field powered armor.
Adarael
I should like to point out that "Powered Armor" conjures different ideas for different people.

Armor - that is to say, something worn to protect you from getting bullets in you - that is 'powered' - that is to say, has some manner of integrated 'extra' load-bearing capability - is a pretty good idea when it comes to infantry.

Any accusations that armor that helps you carry extra stuff is 'more expensive than an LAV and less useful' is projection of an idea as to what the phrase means.

Just to point that out.
Shrike30
You wouldn't think that powered armor would be too hard to do in SR. Take the military-grade body armor, fit it with a bunch of the myomer that we already use in cyberlimbs, build in trodes or a datajack connection to allow the suit to pick up on the movement of the wearer and move with him, and you're set for low end stuff. Strength augs and the like rapidly boost your user up to the level where using an MMG like an unarmored person would use a rifle wouldn't be hard, carrying a couple hundred pounds of gear wouldn't be hard... and it's not horribly out of whack with the rest of the world.

If we want to start talking the higher-end CP2020 style APCA suits which are heavier than cars and carry low-caliber railguns, that's another thing entirely...
jervinator
QUOTE (Ed_209a)
QUOTE (toptomcat)
What about regions of heavy jamming, where it's really difficult to rig properly?


I see a military rigger unit being a handful of drones, tailored for the mission, an armored vehicle for the primary rigger to rig from while the secondary rigger drives. A support unit consisting of signals Intelligence people and a self-propelled mortar stay in supporting positions.

Drones move up to do the mission, with the riggermobile a km or so back. The support unit is 2-3 km behind them. They locate and suppress enemy ECM units with indirect fire in support of the primary team's mission. Something like a Anti-radiation guided mortar shell would be ideal.

Of course, if we are talking a serious committal of assets, we may have large aerial drones loitering with standing orders to engage any ECM emitters that don't have the right IFF.

I think the tech for this would be cheaper than powered armor, and you only put 2 people onto the battlefield, as compared to an entire squad.

Exactly! Good tactics/strategy are much cheaper. Even a top-notch ECCM suite would be more cost-effective.

It's not so much that power armor is hard to do exactly. However, considering the costs involved in making a man-portable laser weapon and the matching power supply, coupled with the power demands of an enhanced suit, tackling all of the technical challenges involved in powerring it for any useful period of time in a cost-effective manner is, in my opinion, just not possible as of 2070.
Does the stuff exist? Most likely yes... in limited quantities, and possibly only experimentally. JIM suits existed in SR3, but were a little pricey and not really usable on land; they relied on buoyancy to help the myomers counteract the weight of the suit.

That said, technology marches on. A wireless Matrix connection was virtually impossible in 2060, unreliable in 2064, and dirt-cheap in 2070. Maybe in 2075 we can wear ceramet-plated exoskeletons wink.gif

Squinky
But...they've already made a man portable Laser back in SR2, and then in SR3 it was even more portable, in the form of a redline....
emo samurai
I WANT STARSHIP TROOPERS LEVEL POWER ARMOR GRRRR!!!!!!! Although that's probably pretty much impossible cost-wise and probabtly not due until maybe SR10, which will probably move beyond cyberpunk.
PBTHHHHT
by then, the next age has gone and passed and it's time of Kerensky and mechwarriors... Nooooo!
Azralon
If only there were a game system that allowed power armor and mechs.
jervinator
QUOTE (Squinky)
But...they've already made a man portable Laser back in SR2, and then in SR3 it was even more portable, in the form of a redline....

I know they did; I think you missed my point.
How much did it cost? Wasn't it rather large and heavy compared to more normal weaponry? With a limited number of shots (low endurance)? And was it mass-produced like, say, the Ares Predator, or was the supply a little more limited than that?
stevebugge
Ah one of the great Shadowtalk quotes in FoF

"This has got to be BullDrek NOTHING drops in cost by 90% in just 3 years"

Neon Samurai (IIRC) commenting on the ARES MPIII costing only 150000 after the ARES MP cost 1500000 in the Street Sam Catalogue
Squinky
QUOTE (jervinator)
QUOTE (Squinky @ Dec 12 2005, 09:48 PM)
But...they've already made a man portable Laser back in SR2, and then in SR3 it was even more portable, in the form of a redline....

I know they did; I think you missed my point.
How much did it cost? Wasn't it rather large and heavy compared to more normal weaponry? With a limited number of shots (low endurance)? And was it mass-produced like, say, the Ares Predator, or was the supply a little more limited than that?

Oh yeah, it was pretty spendy at 75k for it, (prices probably have dropped a bit on it like all weapons too) but then again you are talking about and armored mech suit type thing, so putting a predator built into it is a little wonky. Heh.

Point being, the normal sized mp laser wasn't really that big, and the red-line was even smaller. Pistol sized even.
emo samurai
Dude... I just got an idea... I'll use the first Battlemech developed in Earth history as a plot point!!! The runners will have to fight it, or pilot it, if they're stealthy and awesome enough.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012