Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Character Creation
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Zolhex
(paraphrased for space) The book says on page 76:

Your character starts with knowledge skill points equal to your logic + your intuition times 3 for free. You can purchase additional knowledge points at 2 BP per knowledge point. Max knowledge points are = to 2 times your free points.

Moving on to page 106:

knowledge skills represent what a character knows. beginning knowledge skills are based on logic and intuition attributes and can be further modified with BP.

So question? (Logic is 3 Intuition is 3 there for you get 3 +3 x 3 = 18 free points)

If these points are not BP but actual skill points then I can take these skills at these ratings:

history 4
Seattle street gangs 4
security procedures 4
club music 4
Japanese 2

for a total of 18 free points. because as I read it these free points seem to be used on a one for one basis unlike BP which costs you 2 BP per skill point.

SO any thoughts or comments would be nice.
SL James
They're BP. Check out the Sample Characters later on.
Zolhex
the sample characters seem to be off as well at least that is what I have heard.
SL James
Dammit. I just noticed something else I have to fix in my Covert Ops Specialist. I was using the cost of Active Skills to buy extra KS/Language skill points.

Anyway, you may as well just use skill points and the literal reading of the text. However, the text also distinctly uses two different terms: points and rating. If you received free KS rating values, it'd be more in line with your idea. However, the use of points in the context suggests a shorthand for BP.
FanGirl
I thought that Knowledge points were effectively just like BP, except you can only spend them on Knowledge skills. Therefore, you trade 2 free points for each skill rank, or 1 free point for each specialization. Please wait a few minutes while I reread that section and confirm it either way.

EDIT: Wow, I think you're right. Looks like a bunch of my characters got stiffed in that regard...
SL James
Check out the example. It suggests you're right. The first example has 24 free knowledge skill points and allocates them as follows:

Ancient Egyptian Magic 5
Seattle Talismongers 4
Seattle Street Gangs 4
Seattle Safehouses 4
Seattle Syndicates 3
Ancient Mythologies 4

Her skill ratings total 24. So, yeah, go nuts.
Zolhex
@SL James No offence here guy I was just reading the text and it just didn't sound right. Now logicaly I would say they are like BP as that makes the most sense. Then again they may have worded it differently to try to get players to buy and use knowledge/language skills so who knows. I dropped a line to the offical SR questions email address we'll see what they have to say.
SL James
Dude. Reload.
Zolhex
sorry was typeing i'm slow at that lol.
the_dunner
As you guys have deduced, they're not build points, they're ranks of knowledge skills. The examples are correct, the descriptions of how to spend them are a little bit confusing. (I've seen this confusion pop up with a lot of folks when creating their first few characters.)
Glyph
What's confusing is that you get the free points, then you can spend some of your starting build points if you want more knowledge skills. The free points are straight up points, but subsequent ones cost 2 build points per point.
Cabral
I had to read it twice to make sure I had it right. It would've been simpler to say that you received (Logic+Intuition) x 6 build points only for knowledge skills.
laughingowl
QUOTE (Cabral)
I had to read it twice to make sure I had it right. It would've been simpler to say that you received (Logic+Intuition) x 6 build points only for knowledge skills.

Going from memory here, but don't think this would be quite right either....

don't skills (like attributes) cost extra for that last point (unlike 'ranks')

peace
SL James
What difference does it make? It wouldn't apply if you just gave your PC some KS at 6 using free points.
neoweasel
QUOTE (laughingowl)
QUOTE (Cabral @ Aug 25 2006, 03:43 AM)
I had to read it twice to make sure I had it right. It would've been simpler to say that you received (Logic+Intuition) x 6 build points only for knowledge skills.

Going from memory here, but don't think this would be quite right either....

don't skills (like attributes) cost extra for that last point (unlike 'ranks')

peace

No, they don't, unless the rule is in a totally crack-addled location (i.e. NOT in the section on character generation).
LilithTaveril
QUOTE (neoweasel @ Aug 25 2006, 05:14 AM)
QUOTE (laughingowl @ Aug 25 2006, 02:00 AM)
QUOTE (Cabral @ Aug 25 2006, 03:43 AM)
I had to read it twice to make sure I had it right. It would've been simpler to say that you received (Logic+Intuition) x 6 build points only for knowledge skills.

Going from memory here, but don't think this would be quite right either....

don't skills (like attributes) cost extra for that last point (unlike 'ranks')

peace

No, they don't, unless the rule is in a totally crack-addled location (i.e. NOT in the section on character generation).

It's on page 73, and they do cost extra. 10 BP for every rank except the last, which costs 25.

Edit: The above is an example of why not drinking your coffee before you post is a bad thing.
Teux
@Lilith - I think you misread the previous post.

The cost you are quoting from page 73 is the attribute cost, not the cost of active skills.

Active skills don't cost anything extra for the 6th point, but you are limited to having one skill at 6, or two skill at 5 maximum at character creation. (SR4, p. 75) Also, the build point chart on p. 88 seems to confirm this, since it lists the extra cost for bumping an attribute to 6, but does not list a similar cost for skills.

As for knowledge skills, the verbiage is a bit confusing. Maybe if it said something like "1 free point = 1 knowledge skill point" somewhere in that section, it would clear that up. As it reads now, it is difficult to separate build points, free knowledge skill points, and knowledge skill points...

LilithTaveril
QUOTE (Teux)
@Lilith - I think you misread the previous post.

The cost you are quoting from page 73 is the attribute cost, not the cost of active skills....

Note my edit.

QUOTE
As for knowledge skills, the verbiage is a bit confusing.  Maybe if it said something like "1 free point = 1 knowledge skill point" somewhere in that section, it would clear that up.  As it reads now, it is difficult to separate build points, free knowledge skill points, and knowledge skill points


Actually, it's very easy. Here, let me quote it to you.

QUOTE
Your character starts withm a number of Knowledge skill points equal to (Logic + Intuition) x 3. You may also purchase additional Knowledge skill points at a rate of 2 BP per point.


Basically, it's laying out the difference right there: One skill point does not equal one build point. If you check the table, it lists BP to SP conversions (including for Active Skills). The problem, of course, is that using just the table also can lead to confusion (in fact, for awhile, I thought it meant you started with free BP). You have to use those two sections, plus the Active Skills section, together. It's about like the Burst Fire fiasco I argued earlier.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012