Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Chemical Seal rating of a trashbag?
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Jason Farlander
So... if you were to cut holes in a heavy-duty trashbag for your head and arms, what chemseal rating would that give you? Would "reinforcing" the trash bag with thick(ish) plasting sheeting and duck tape help?

Since you can get a rating 7 chemseal on an armored vest with plates (somehow those plates make the vest more chemsealable...), and that basically means that most chemicals will not penetrate it, how would the plastic vest be any different?

This situation came up in my last game when the runners discovered that they security at their target facility used chem weapons, but they didnt have the time to get "proper" chemsealed armor (the run was sheduled to take place the next day). On the fly, I decided to give them an effective chemseal rating of +2... but now I'm wondering if that was reasonable.

I'm also interested in the other sorts of low-cost solutions to problems that others have come up with... so if you have an example of such a thing, I'd like to hear it.
Reaver
QUOTE (Jason Farlander)
So... if you were to cut holes in a heavy-duty trashbag for your head and arms, what chemseal rating would that give you? Would "reinforcing" the trash bag with thick(ish) plasting sheeting and duck tape help?

Since you can get a rating 7 chemseal on an armored vest with plates (somehow those plates make the vest more chemsealable...), and that basically means that most chemicals will not penetrate it, how would the plastic vest be any different?

This situation came up in my last game when the runners discovered that they security at their target facility used chem weapons, but they didnt have the time to get "proper" chemsealed armor (the run was sheduled to take place the next day). On the fly, I decided to give them an effective chemseal rating of +2... but now I'm wondering if that was reasonable.

I'm also interested in the other sorts of low-cost solutions to problems that others have come up with... so if you have an example of such a thing, I'd like to hear it.

I might give it a 3 or 4 (max) with some kind of successful skill check to make sure it was properly sealed. Of course, the right chemicals will eat right through the duct tape. biggrin.gif
spotlite
That is JUST the sort of thing my players would do. Fantastic. God I must never let them read this board....
Reaver
QUOTE (spotlite)
That is JUST the sort of thing my players would do. Fantastic. God I must never let them read this board....

I'll second that. biggrin.gif
RedmondLarry
Our team got rain suits and rubber boots at the hardware store. Only one of our characters got infected, and he's just a carrier. smile.gif
Tom Collins
Realistically, a trash bag wouldn't do you much good. It may help a little, but it'll be damn near immposible to seal properly and it's not going to keep vapors from leaking in like a true chemsuit would (of course, if vapors truly are a problem, they'd need respirators anyways). It may give them a minute or two to get their clothes off if the splash themselves with something, but thats about it. +2 sounds like a reasonable bonus to give them, for being creative if nothing else. I don't think I'd go above that though (unless they go out of their way to reinforce the bags, but Im not coming up with any way of doing it right now).
Austere Emancipator
I dunno how easily a "heavy duty trashbag" rips, but I'm guessing too easily when your life's on the line.

I've never given much thought to the Armor Modifications, including Chemical Seals. If you want a low-cost solution, get a rain suit (be sure to get one with a good hood) and rubber boots (as OurTeam already mentioned), a pile of light plastic/latex and cotton gloves (wearing them in 3 layers, plastic+cotton+plastic), and a gas mask. If breathing the stuff isn't an issue, you can go with full-face plastic hood -- transparent with breathing holes preferably in the back or near the neck, located so that they open to the space between the transparent hood and the rain suit, and the rain suit has separate openings some distance away, kept open somehow that you can still breath.

That shouldn't be too expensive (probably less than 100 nuyen without the gas mask) and, if you duct tape all the joints, should protect you quite well against splashes. I might give such a set-up up to 8 points of ChemSeal. Will be slightly uncomfortable in hot places, however.
boodah
woot! ill keep this in mind, Reav!

rotfl.gif
Zazen
QUOTE (Jason Farlander)
Would... duck tape help?

If your opposition is some kind of water fowl, sure. wink.gif
GoldenAri
[/QUOTE]I might give such a set-up up to 8 points of ChemSeal.[QUOTE]
Wow, your generous. I'd give maybe a 4 or 5 to that, but I'd require Armor B/R rolls. Those hard rain suits should work though with a little modification as you said. I'd probably give a +1 to movement based TNs. But yeah, 2 points of chemical protection seems fair under the circumstances.
Austere Emancipator
If correctly duct-taped, the person in question should have no openings on his body other than the breathing holes, which would require the liquid to travel in between the suits from around his face to behind his head/down his neck. Unless the chemical is extremely potent or capable of eating through that gear, the protection would be absolute.

Actually, it's so high because I was only thinking about liquids. Gases would be a different matter altogether, against those the set-up wouldn't be more than a 4 at best. With a gas mask it could get back up to 6 or 7, though.
Jason Farlander
QUOTE (Zazen)
QUOTE (Jason Farlander @ Jan 22 2004, 01:41 PM)
Would... duck tape help?

If your opposition is some kind of water fowl, sure. wink.gif

Actually, "Duck Tape" was the original name. Here is an explanation. If you want to read an overabundance of sources saying essentially the same exact thing, here is the Google search I used.
Panzergeist
Holy crap, that just gave me an idea! I was wondering what the chemical seal rating of a condom was, then it hit me: What about a chemical gland that secretes poison into your semen? You could be a hooker-assasin. Of course, a cyberware chemical tank would be better, since it could be turned off.
Tom Collins
Guys, realize that short of specifically designed suits, not much will offer you complete protection. I have to wear different gloves in lab when Im working depending on what Im working with, because one polymer will not protect me against everything. What works well against acids or bases may be suceptable to some organics. They used ralatively specialized materials and treatments in the hazard suits. Because of this, most stopgag measures just dont work well. Also realize that the pore sizes in your standard garbage bag may let vapors through like terry clothe. Whether or not they have to worry about vapors depends on what they are wearing. If its an aquaeous soln. of, say, HCl or KOH, I wouldn't worry. Phosgene on the other hand, would definately be bothersome (a small molecule that turns into HCl in your lungs is definately something that I highly doubt would be kept out by duct tape and you wouldn't want to breath in). Biohazards are something else entirely. Most bios are large molecules that probably wouldn't penetrate the plastic, but virii might.

I would say the +2 should be the maximum. If people are really interested, I might be able to dig up some hard facts, but Im rather busy so it may take a while.
Siege
Tom's insights notwithstanding, do you really want to entrust your safety to the ability of a converted garbage bag to repel chemicals, toxins and related things that go squish in the air?

-Siege
Herald of Verjigorm
QUOTE (Siege)
Tom's insights notwithstanding, do you really want to entrust your safety to the ability of a converted garbage bag to repel chemicals, toxins and related things that go squish in the air?

No, but it is a little better than nothing. If you have the option and information, go with the real safety gear. If you learn about the toxins too late, and only have a bunch of garbage bags and tape, it might make the difference.
Cain
I'd add a +1 for creativity. Realistically, even with duct tape, there's plenty of micropores for things to leak through. Trash bags also tear rather easily, from simple walking-around. (When I took my Christmas tree to the recycling place, I started with it in a heavy duty trashbag. When I got there, I had a tree with plastic bits on it.)
Crusher Bob
If the chemical agents don't have very low dosages, the amount that leaks through the garbage bag might not be enough to do the deed. If they are trying to avoid the squirtguns of death ™ then giveing them a +3 or +2 sounds fine. If they are trying to avoid some much better method of chemical delivery, they are probably out of luck.
Birdy
Dumb Question:

What do you need protection against?

I mean basic NBC gear still is a rubberized poncho and a gas<<<NBC mask. Giving you the choice between drowning in your sweat and dying by the chemical agent.

A lot of the (military) stuff can be stopped by heavy duty rubber trousers / jackets like the stuff worn by channel workers and a mask since it is a liquid (Most WWI chemical agents I.E, Teargas, Pepperspray)

If you seek protection against the WWII and later stuff (Tabun, Sarin, VX and the other nerve agents) you'll basically need a classic MOPP suit. You might (for short exposure) get away with mask, rubber poncho, waterproof boots (some mil. boots are actually) and a complete coverage of all skin.

With all milspec agents make sure you get rid of the stuff before undress.

Some milspec agents are multi-component stuff, some for clogging the mask-filter and some for killing you.


Birdy

Q: Why are those recruits performing constant NBC drill?
A: Don't know. Give me another of the signal cartridges. Must me multi-star red again since the last was white.
(Hint Multistar Red - NBC alert wink.gif Sadly, this happened IRL)

Austere Emancipator
Tom: Corrosive substances are another matter entirely. I don't think any of us was suggesting that these set-ups would be a significant defense against them. I was thinking about the Squirtguns of Death™, like Bob put it, when I was discussing protection against liquids, and maybe other similar attacks, like capsule rounds with generic nasties (Narcoject etc) inside. The suit I described should prove a pretty good defense against those kinds of threats.

Basically, what I typed in was a "Product Improved" version of the military NBC-protection mentioned by Birdy. With the gas mask, it should be more effective against standard gases than a basic military set-up, allowing for longer exposion (because there aren't any significant holes where the chemical might leak in).

QUOTE (Birdy)
Why are those recruits performing constant NBC drill?

We did it because our squad leaders were pricks. We never needed any other reasons...
Zazen
QUOTE (Jason Farlander)
Actually, "Duck Tape" was the original name. Here is an explanation.

"In Finland and Sweden, they refer to duct tape as “Jesus Tape.” "

I'm going to start calling it Jesus Tape from now on.
Austere Emancipator
'sright. Works miracles.
spotlite
QUOTE (Zazen)
QUOTE (Jason Farlander @ Jan 22 2004, 08:17 PM)
Actually, "Duck Tape" was the original name.  Here is an explanation.

"In Finland and Sweden, they refer to duct tape as “Jesus Tape.” "

I'm going to start calling it Jesus Tape from now on.

And here in the UK it gets called Gaffa Tape. Mainly because the stuff is comparitively expensive so the gaffer is the one who hands it out to people. Either than or because 'it does as good a job as the gaffer' I've never sussed out which. And that whole duck/duct thing could be a marketing ploy, because every roll of it I've ever seen has 'elephant tape' stencilled round the inside.

So which is it? If you think that it must be true cos its on the internet in multiple places, then i pity your reasoning faculties. Case in point - googlewhacking. Search for any of the well known googlewhacks now and you'll get a lits of sites which in turn list successful googlewhacks, thereby rendering them immediately NOT googlewhacks. don't trust the internet. Use it, but use it like you would intelligence gathering - it gives you a place to start, but it won't stand up in court. So it MIGHT be true that it started as duck tape. It might not, but answer me this - if a tree falls in the woods and there's no-one there to hear it - who gives a frag, really?

Here endeth the unnecessary threadjacking sermon...
Birdy
QUOTE (Austere Emancipator)
Tom: Corrosive substances are another matter entirely. I don't think any of us was suggesting that these set-ups would be a significant defense against them. I was thinking about the Squirtguns of Death™, like Bob put it, when I was discussing protection against liquids, and maybe other similar attacks, like capsule rounds with generic nasties (Narcoject etc) inside. The suit I described should prove a pretty good defense against those kinds of threats.

Basically, what I typed in was a "Product Improved" version of the military NBC-protection mentioned by Birdy. With the gas mask, it should be more effective against standard gases than a basic military set-up, allowing for longer exposion (because there aren't any significant holes where the chemical might leak in).

QUOTE (Birdy)
Why are those recruits performing constant NBC drill?

We did it because our squad leaders were pricks. We never needed any other reasons...

Well, we (bunch of Privates lead by a trigger-happy Staff Seargeant) where ordered to dispose some aged ammo and did so by using the firing range. Part of the stuff was 18mm signal ammo and we finished the day firing them of at the protective embankment overlooking the barracks training area. Some Grenny[1]-Recruits trained there and considered us part of the setup. Took everybody a while to realise what was happening. Them longer than us (What you thought we stopped - hey, they where Grenadiers!)[2]


As for using Duct Tape (Panzerband - Armortape is the german version) to improve protection, by all means! Taping shut the rubber trousers, attaching them to the boots/jacket all will help. Might be a tad difficult to get out of the cloth afterwards.[3]


Michael

Airborne is the equivalent to modern tourists. They fly in in cushy planes, stay just long enough to ruin the place and disappear without cleaning up (German Staff Sgt, 1988)



[1] Mechanized Infantry
[2] And we were light (Jäger)
[3] The word was that a Citroen 2CV that stopped at a piece of double sided tape wouldn't be able to drive off again.
Austere Emancipator
QUOTE (spotlite)
[I]f a tree falls in the woods and there's no-one there to hear it - who gives a frag, really?

The guy who owns the forest, if it's meant for use by industry. Perhaps the guy who owns the summer cottage the tree just fell on. Perhaps the guy whose electricity or phone lines were just cut off.

In the modern world, falling trees can have all kinds of negative side-effects even when no one is there to hear it fall. Unfortunately. And then there's all the animals and crap.

(Yes, I've got issues with the "falling tree, no one hears" thing.)

Does "gaffer" mean (among other things) the kind of person that puts together all the stage-stuff in live performances?
Fortune
QUOTE (Austere Emancipator)
Does "gaffer" mean (among other things) the kind of person that puts together all the stage-stuff in live performances?

Yes, which is where the tape gets (one of) it's name.
Austere Emancipator
Okay. Online dictionaries were less helpful than usual. frown.gif
Crusher Bob
I think it can also mean 'an older male relative' (dad, uncle, etc) or 'just any old guy'. The subtext is usually that they are pretty 'handy' with tools, or some similar 'hands on job' (car repair, painting, plumbing, whatever).
John Campbell
Gaffer's tape isn't the same thing as duct tape. It's a close relative, but is a couple of steps above even high-end duct tape in quality. It's much stronger and more durable than duct tape and has different adhesive that doesn't leave nearly as much residue when it's peeled up (it frequently gets used for taping down cables or marking positions in venues that get upset if you leave sticky goop in their rugs). And I've never seen gaffer's tape in the common duct-tape silver... closest I've seen it get is a flat light grey. It's usually black. Bright oranges and pinks are also fairly common for marking things.

I also suspect that the "duck tape" origin is an urban legend. It's got that feel to it. Snopes doesn't seem to have anything about it, though.
Austere Emancipator
The Finnish word roudarinteippi ("Gaffer's Tape") does mean just your basic duct tape, however.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012