Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Nosferatu magician with Alleviate Allergy spell
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2
TygerTyger
Does this mean what I think it means, that the Nosferatu would be immune to the effects of the sun (assuming three net successes) while this spell is sustained?? That seems a bit cheap.
Draco18s
ShadowRun's vampires* are sparkly vampires.

*And assorted related infected
Stahlseele
Depends, does it still say allergy or does it say weakness?
TygerTyger
QUOTE (Stahlseele @ Jan 7 2011, 06:52 PM) *
Depends, does it still say allergy or does it say weakness?


The weakness the Nos has is an allergy, so either would be effective, wouldn't it?

For the record though, the spell removes the negative effects of an allergy (reducing the severity of the allergy by one step per success).
Draco18s
Both entries are "allergy." Alleviate Allergy alleviates the Allergy (Sunlight, Severe).
WyldKnight
Allergy but I think any sane GM should house rule it into an actual weakness that can't be alleviated with a simple spell. I mean honestly it's just ridiculous.
pbangarth
QUOTE (Street Magic page 169)
...Every net hit reduces the allergy level by one (from Moderate to Mild, for example). The spell does not remove the allergy, only alleviate its effects....return at full force once the spell ends.

Sounds like a sparkly, daytime vampire to me. Make sure you have Counterspell with you in case you meet one of these, I guess.
Stahlseele
Helloo most underused game mechanics to annoy magic people with. BACKGROUND COUNT!
WyldKnight
Especially in the really bad neighborhoods where the general crime and grime would make it a festering sore on the astral.
Stahlseele
But of course, no GM will ever use this . .
Adarael
A nosferatu wants to quicken alleviate allergy on himself to walk around in sunlight? More power to him. That's what the spell is *for*, hell. Nosferatu ain't undead, they're just diseased. I don't see any reason a nos with that spell - i.e. any nos you'll ever meet - wouldn't be able to use it just like that.

In fact, there's an NPC in Blood in the Boardroom and Threats (I think) who does just that.
WyldKnight
Magic

Makes weaknesses null and void.
pbangarth
Stahlseele is right, though. People tend to underplay the drawbacks inherent in magic. In a case like this, one false step and it's game over.
Irion
QUOTE
Makes weaknesses null and void.

Close, but not completly.
Regeneration is still disabled.

For rule text:
QUOTE ("Street magic")
The
spell does not remove the allergy

QUOTE ("Core Book")
If the critter has an Allergy, the critter cannot
regenerate damage until the allergen’s presence is removed.


Hagga
Edit: Doublepost.
Hagga
However, that also means that if it dies during the day, as soon as the sun is down it gets a chance for a regen check.
WyldKnight
Screw that. If I drop a vampire I take its head to claim the bounty and burn the body with an incendiary grenade.
Starmage21
Assuming the vaMpire isn't aura masked in some way you might want to counterspell that alleviate allergy spell.

That said id allow regeneration to function while the spell has completely surpressed the side effects of the allergy. That gives good reasons for PC vamps to cast at high force and avoid combat in the day or invest heavily in a high force sustaining focus in case of background counts or unconsciousness.

That said, the spell has been playtested by many other than myself by now I assume. The Nosferatu actually proved UNDERPOWERED for a standard missions based game without uber cheese. Not that the character couldn't perform his job as a magician, its just that there were no points left over for a minor area of focus.
Sephiroth
QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Jan 7 2011, 09:23 PM) *
That said, the spell has been playtested by many other than myself by now I assume. The Nosferatu actually proved UNDERPOWERED for a standard missions based game without uber cheese. Not that the character couldn't perform his job as a magician, its just that there were no points left over for a minor area of focus.

Indeed. People sometimes forget when criticizing nosferatu that 250 BP is not really enough to make a decently rounded character, that their strengths in critter powers can be greatly affected by background count, and that, as a result of their general tendency as a species towards plotting, megalomania, sociopathy, murder, etc., a nosferatu PC whose nature is discovered by the authorities is potentially in very severe danger, more so than your regular shadowrunner in the same situation I mean.

Also, I personally think that allowing the Alleviate Allergy spell for nos PC's should be allowed, if only to lower the sunlight weakness to a mild allergy at most. If the rest of a team does not change to a nocturnal schedule to conform to the nos's, this leaves the nosferatu player in a somewhat problematic position in that he/she is essentially out of the game during IC daylight hours. As I myself have discovered in recent months, this can be especially problematic for nosferatu PC's in play-by-post games, although it is not altogether impossible to deal with.
Jareth Valar
QUOTE (Hagga @ Jan 7 2011, 07:58 PM) *
However, that also means that if it dies during the day, as soon as the sun is down it gets a chance for a regen check.

Not really, remember how Regen works now.
QUOTE
Certain types of damage cannot be regenerated from this power. Damage to the brain or spinal cord....cannot be healed this way. Likewise, magical damage....
and that s critter can still die if brought below their overflow. Even if you allow them a roll after sundown, or in a dark ally, or whatever, the amount of damage potentially done to a "suspected" vampire after it falls? Unlikely (i.e. Hand of God unlikely), IMHO.

Like mentioned earlier, take his head, and it's all over, forever.
Aerospider
QUOTE (Sephiroth @ Jan 8 2011, 08:23 AM) *
Indeed. People sometimes forget when criticizing nosferatu that 250 BP is not really enough to make a decently rounded character, that their strengths in critter powers can be greatly affected by background count, and that, as a result of their general tendency as a species towards plotting, megalomania, sociopathy, murder, etc., a nosferatu PC whose nature is discovered by the authorities is potentially in very severe danger, more so than your regular shadowrunner in the same situation I mean.

Also, I personally think that allowing the Alleviate Allergy spell for nos PC's should be allowed, if only to lower the sunlight weakness to a mild allergy at most. If the rest of a team does not change to a nocturnal schedule to conform to the nos's, this leaves the nosferatu player in a somewhat problematic position in that he/she is essentially out of the game during IC daylight hours. As I myself have discovered in recent months, this can be especially problematic for nosferatu PC's in play-by-post games, although it is not altogether impossible to deal with.

Is there anything inherently flawed in covering up every square inch of skin? Nosferatus should be wearing disguises as a matter of course anyway. I suppose one could rule that any amount of sunlight getting through his sunglasses is going to hurt like a bitch, but blacked-out glasses with a video feed isn't too out there, is it?
Neraph
I can remember starting threads very similar to this myself a year+ ago. Interesting how the world turns, eh?
TygerTyger
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 8 2011, 12:26 PM) *
I can remember starting threads very similar to this myself a year+ ago. Interesting how the world turns, eh?


*chuckles* And thus the student becomes the master. smile.gif

*bows to sensei*

I haven't played since 2nd Edition, so I am re-learning the entire world in a hurry - I really need to track down the more recent novels so that I can get a read on them and get a better feel for this new, shiny Sixth World.
Neraph
I'd like to get and read at least one SR novel. I think I've read a grand total of two cyberpunk books total. Well, not including the rulesbooks for SR, in which case I've read nearly every SR4 book now.
Sixgun_Sage
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 8 2011, 11:46 AM) *
I'd like to get and read at least one SR novel. I think I've read a grand total of two cyberpunk books total. Well, not including the rulesbooks for SR, in which case I've read nearly every SR4 book now.



It's not exactly cyberpunk but I would suggest Richard K. Morgan's Takeshi Kovacs novels, they got cited as source material in the Eclipse Phase books and I know I've used them as a basis for shadowruns before.
Stahlseele
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 8 2011, 05:46 PM) *
I'd like to get and read at least one SR novel. I think I've read a grand total of two cyberpunk books total. Well, not including the rulesbooks for SR, in which case I've read nearly every SR4 book now.

what's stopping you?
you should be able to find some of them O.o
Jekolmy
How many mages are running around just Seattle with an alleviate allergy spell up? Chances are in my game world at least there would be quite a few, even if the players never actually ran into them. That being said I don't think there is anyway to differentiate between an alleviate (pollution) vs an alleviate (sunlight) spell.
TygerTyger
QUOTE (Sixgun_Sage @ Jan 8 2011, 01:00 PM) *
It's not exactly cyberpunk but I would suggest Richard K. Morgan's Takeshi Kovacs novels, they got cited as source material in the Eclipse Phase books and I know I've used them as a basis for shadowruns before.



I love that series. Morgan instantly became one of my new favorite authors when I read his first Altered Carbon.
Glyph
I don't think it's horribly unbalancing. As someone pointed out, the spell doesn't change the fact that they can't regenerate in sunlight - all it does is negate some penalties, and the damage that the allergen normally causes. To do this, the nosferatu either has to sustain the spell (incurring those penalties), use a sustaining focus (expending magical resources that could have been used for something else), or quicken the spell (spending karma, and even with masking, wards and the magician's aura both become more problematic).
Gerzel
QUOTE (Draco18s @ Jan 7 2011, 05:50 PM) *
ShadowRun's vampires* are sparkly vampires.

*And assorted related infected



Uhm no.

The HMVV are far from Bram Stoker's vampires but the are certainly not sparkly.
KarmaInferno
The joke is that to be in the sunlight, they need to cast a spell on themselves as protection.

Which is presumably sparkly.




-k
Draco18s
QUOTE (KarmaInferno @ Jan 8 2011, 08:33 PM) *
The joke is that to be in the sunlight, they need to cast a spell on themselves as protection.

Which is presumably sparkly.


Nailed it.
Mordinvan
Just wondering why a Vamp wouldn't use a variant of the physical mask spell? Something which creates a fine layer of sunblocking matter over them, which shields them from the sun? Or a spell which totally blocks UV light, as I believe it was stated (much to my disagreement) that this was the part of sunlight which harmed them? It would be a 'very' limited version of the improved invisibility spell, and likely have a drain between improved and regular invisibility. While this still has the sustaining problems, since the vamp is no longer in contact with the allergen in any meaning sense, they should be able to use full regeneration.
Starmage21
This is why I have no problem allowing them to regenerate after reducing an allergy to nothing with Alleviate Allergy.
Neraph
You can't reduce the Allergy to nothing - you reduce it by one step per success, but you can't remove it.
Starmage21
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 9 2011, 02:34 PM) *
You can't reduce the Allergy to nothing - you reduce it by one step per success, but you can't remove it.


That is essentially what I mean. Casting Alleviate Allergy with a high enough force that all of the negative side effects of the allergen are alleviated. The allergy is not gone, but it's effects are.
KarmaInferno
QUOTE (Mordinvan @ Jan 9 2011, 07:28 AM) *
Just wondering why a Vamp wouldn't use a variant of the physical mask spell? Something which creates a fine layer of sunblocking matter over them, which shields them from the sun? Or a spell which totally blocks UV light, as I believe it was stated (much to my disagreement) that this was the part of sunlight which harmed them? It would be a 'very' limited version of the improved invisibility spell, and likely have a drain between improved and regular invisibility. While this still has the sustaining problems, since the vamp is no longer in contact with the allergen in any meaning sense, they should be able to use full regeneration.

Physical mask is an illusion. It's not actually changing your appearance, it just creates the illusion that it is.

Whatever spell you use, it would have to be either Health or Manipulation to actually protect you from sunlight.




-k
Mordinvan
QUOTE (KarmaInferno @ Jan 9 2011, 12:57 PM) *
Physical mask is an illusion. It's not actually changing your appearance, it just creates the illusion that it is.

Whatever spell you use, it would have to be either Health or Manipulation to actually protect you from sunlight.




-k

Physical illusion can bend, block, and create light, so they should also be able to blend/block a specific set of wavelengths.
Mordinvan
double post
Yerameyahu
It's really not clear what 'physical illusions' do, and to what. Magic is arbitrary, and such spells don't prevent you from seeing out.
Draco18s
While magic is arbitrary, it is possible (as in, not specifically impossible) to create a spell that blocks the "bad" sunlight like sunscreen blocks UV rays.
Yerameyahu
Right, sure. smile.gif But not as an illusion, presumably.
Draco18s
QUOTE (Yerameyahu @ Jan 9 2011, 11:52 PM) *
Right, sure. smile.gif But not as an illusion, presumably.


Health or Manipulation, IMO.
KarmaInferno
Right.

Illusions should remain illusions. There's too many spells that blur the distinction already.




-k
Thanee
QUOTE (WyldKnight @ Jan 7 2011, 11:57 PM) *
Allergy but I think any sane GM should house rule it into an actual weakness that can't be alleviated with a simple spell. I mean honestly it's just ridiculous.


Well, walls also do that. As does full body armor, I guess.

Don't see where this is such a big deal, really.

Bye
Thanee
Fringe
With the pollution in a typical metroplex (since the pollution allergy is a big deal), there might not be all that much direct sunlight anyway.

Love that smog! smile.gif

Also, there are quite a few ways people bend the rules with spells, not just the Alleviate Allergy spell. For one, I'm thinking of Increase Attribute on the drain attributes. Better casting through, well, casting. As others have mentioned above, though, having a sustained spell presents its own problems...sustaining it yourself, using a sustaining focus, or spending karma to quicken it, each of which presents an astral signature and creates its own problem for the caster (in terms of the -2 for sustaining, money and karma, or karma).
Neraph
QUOTE (Draco18s @ Jan 9 2011, 10:41 PM) *
While magic is arbitrary, it is possible (as in, not specifically impossible) to create a spell that blocks the "bad" sunlight like sunscreen blocks UV rays.

As I've stated before.... Improved Invisibility? It bends light around you, right?

QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Jan 9 2011, 01:12 PM) *
That is essentially what I mean. Casting Alleviate Allergy with a high enough force that all of the negative side effects of the allergen are alleviated. The allergy is not gone, but it's effects are.

Ok, maybe you don't understand my point.

Alleviate Allergy states that it "reduces the allergy level by one" and that it "does not remove the allergy, only alleviates its effects". As there is no level of allergy below Mild, you cannot lower its level below Mild. The absence of an allergy is not a level of allergy - it is a null set of allergy, a non-existance of it. This is a fair interpretation that still makes allergies dangerous, especially to those with Regeneration.
Draco18s
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 10 2011, 12:38 PM) *
As I've stated before.... Improved Invisibility? It bends light around you, right?


Except that you can still see. So its....a physical illusion and. Yeah.
Neraph
We've been over that before. I'm just saying that the spell description says that it bends light around you, so logic would dictate that sunlight would be bent around you - not touching you.

Alleviate Allergy is by far a better option. Or a Shadow spell at sufficient Force, but maneuvering in that darkness would be problematic. Or an Evo HEL suit with a polarized face mask. Or a horseman with a polarized windshield.

There're lots of options for making someone move around in full daylight without ever experiencing full daylight.
Dahrken
QUOTE (Neraph @ Jan 10 2011, 06:46 PM) *
We've been over that before. I'm just saying that the spell description says that it bends light around you, so logic would dictate that sunlight would be bent around you - not touching you

If no light touch you, this would make you functionaly blind...
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012