QUOTE (thorya @ Oct 17 2011, 11:37 PM)

I know that Perception is used for opposing Etiquette, but I still feel like social perception is fundamentally different than awareness of your surroundings.
Etiquette is a lot about how you're dressing, acting, etc. Those are actually related to noticing things. Since 4th ed SR doesn't do things like 1/2 perception + 1/2 etiquette I can see them breaking for perception. But I could see it the other way too.
QUOTE (thorya @ Oct 17 2011, 11:37 PM)

Also dislike leadership being opposed by your leadership. Could we use your team's leader's Leadership+ your willpower? Also, what does it mean for someone to use leadership on you? Is this for if you try to convince a lone star patrol to follow your orders because you're actually their lieutenant? (joking) It seems like it should be used by your Face to somehow benefit the rest of the team.
I suppose the lone star example could be a highly penalized con roll followed by a leadership roll. But I don't think leadership was handled the best.
QUOTE (Whipstitch @ Oct 18 2011, 12:13 AM)

I've always viewed Leadership as basically making an appeal to authority and thus it's a good bet whenever you're being honest but are not threatening anyone or trying to exchange favors. For example, locating the extraction target and saying "Come with me if you want to live" could totally be treated as either a Leadership or Intimidate check.
The way SR structures things I could see that also being con. But the distiction of which one it is should be clear based on the situation.
If you're making it clear that if they don't come with you than YOU'LL kill them, it'd be pure intimidation.
If it's basically a lie (not going with you would be safer) it'd be con. (and it'd have more penalties)
If you're telling the truth and this is a persuasive type thing, that would be leadership.
Since leadership has the "example" aspect as opposed to only the appeal to authority side, and because of the specializations, I rather use it as a catchall for things that aren't examples of conning, intimidation, or negotiation.
And I find that fits well with the modifiers. For example a firefighter, cop, other relevant authority figure should obviously get a bonus to a statement like that.
It's biggest use I find is with NPCs though. I play where NPCs aren't all fight to the death types. Older editions would often specify that if a given NPC or type of goon took a certain amount of damage they'd run; I liked that and still do it. So a leadership roll is used to try and rally the other gangers or whatever.
In this context the leadership vs leadership and rank vs rank thing makes sense, because the other guys want to retreat, and rank and leadership would play into that. It works well for power struggles too.
But I suppose in other settings it can be more awkward.