QUOTE (Draco18s @ Oct 16 2011, 09:42 AM)
So how would you run the NPCs spotting powerful spells in this situation:
PC is a bird shapeshifter, in birdform, flying 100 meters in the air, targets someone on the ground (bird can easily make any required perception checks, due to their enhanced vision).
Bird casts a F7 stunbolt (perception threshold: -1).
Who sees what?
I would give anyone within a reasonable area (Immediate Vicinity) automatic successes (Threshold -1) for both the caster and the target.
I would allow anyone else outside of that range, but not at a "Far" range (Close but still with Line of Sight/Effect) of the Caster/Target a roll, and if they did not Critically Glitch, They would notice (Threshold 0). Using the "Visibility" modifiers, of course.
Anyone at "Far" Range would Roll, and with a Success (Threshold 1) they would notice, again, Using the "Visibility" modifiers.
Anyone outside of that range would not get a roll to notice at all. They are outside of what I would call the detectable zone.
It is very arbitrary, yes, because those "Ranges" are going to vary, depending upon Situation and Circumstance.
Assuming that EVERYONBE in the City/World/Galaxy/Universe gets a roll, as
Irion talked about, is ludicrous and crazy. There is a GM to arbitrate such circumstances, and he should exercise that power in this, or similar, circumstances where the rules are left purposefully arbitrary, because Circumstance matters.