Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: High-Power Ammunition compability Question
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Nemo
According to the Description of the High-Power Ammunition in War! a stronger propellant is used. The Effect of the APDS Ammunition is made bei the projectil. Would it be liable by RAW to combine High-Power Ammunition with APDS Ammunition to get High-Power APDS Ammunition?
Yerameyahu
RAW, there are no rules for combining any ammo, AFAIK.

God, imagine the Avail, anyway: Hi-P are 20F, APDS is already 16F.
Mäx
Nope.
Witch makes High power chambering one of the biggest smug baits in the game.
As really all it does eat up mod slots and restrict you to ammo that isn't even that good, except for being cheap.
Yerameyahu
It's almost like it's for regular military who don't care about that, not shadowrunners at all… nyahnyah.gif
almost normal
QUOTE (Yerameyahu @ Apr 30 2012, 12:41 PM) *
It's almost like it's for regular military who don't care about that, not shadowrunners at all… nyahnyah.gif


Yeah. It's why I don't like Ex or its big brother much. 33% more power in exchange for using a point of edge every few times you're in combat.
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (Yerameyahu @ Apr 30 2012, 11:37 AM) *
RAW, there are no rules for combining any ammo, AFAIK.

God, imagine the Avail, anyway: Hi-P are 20F, APDS is already 16F.



But that is one way to go about it. 36F, and 150 Nuyen/10 Shots.
Personally, I think HP Rounds are pretty damned good already, but others may have differing opinions.
A HighPowered Ruger Super Warhawk is 8p, -3... WooHoo... smile.gif
Tanegar
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Apr 30 2012, 03:47 PM) *
A HighPowered Ruger Super Warhawk is 8p, -3... WooHoo... smile.gif

Sweet Cthulhu's naughty tentacles, that's a sniper rifle that fits in a holster.
Yerameyahu
But oh no, you can't load your hand cannon with S&S, or flechette, or capsule. wink.gif Cuz apparently you'd want to?
_Pax._
Really, this shoud be a gun-only modification, and NOT an ammunition type. It should simply double the price of ammunition used with that gun, and stack it's benefits with those of the ammunition.

Said benefits should probably be smaller to balance, it, but ... *shrug* ...
UmaroVI
It's more than high powered ammo really suffers in comparison to APF ammo, which has 1 less AP and 20% less range....but doesn't have that -2 to hit that HP gets. Heck, HP is barely better than APDS (+2/-1 with -2 to hit vs 0/-4 with no hit penalty), and you don't need to mod your gun to use APDS.
Mäx
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Apr 30 2012, 11:47 PM) *
A HighPowered Ruger Super Warhawk is 8p, -3... WooHoo... smile.gif

On the other hand just loading it with AP Fletchette rounds makes it 8P -2AP and goes against impact armor witch for most human targets is 1-3 points slower, making it same or better effective AP.
Also doesn't require modding the gun.
QUOTE (_Pax._ @ May 1 2012, 03:54 AM) *
Really, this shoud be a gun-only modification, and NOT an ammunition type. It should simply double the price of ammunition used with that gun, and stack it's benefits with those of the ammunition.

Said benefits should probably be smaller to balance, it, but ... *shrug* ...

I agree, except i don't see any reason to douple the ammo cost, considering that light pistol and sniper rifle ammo costs the same too.
Just drop to the benefit to +1 damage and it's in around the same ballpark of benefit, depending on what ammo is loaded in the gun.
_Pax._
QUOTE (Mäx @ May 1 2012, 05:13 AM) *
On the other hand just loading it with AP Fletchette rounds makes it 8P -2AP and goes against impact armor witch for most human targets is 1-3 points slower, making it same or better effective AP.
Also doesn't require modding the gun.

Flechette round are AP+5, not AP-2.

A Heavy Pistol is 5P, AP-1. Against someone wearing an Armor vest (6/4), the result is 5P versus 5 armor.

Mod it for High Power ammunition, and it becomes 7P, AP-2. Same target, nowit's 7P versus 4 armor.

Load it with standard Flechette instead, and it becomes 8P, AP+4 (versus Impact). Same target, and you're looking at 8P and ... 8 armor.

...

Wher High-Power REALLY fails, is against AP Flechette. That same gun becomes 7P, AP-1 ... and still goes up against Impact armor, so it's only facing 3 armor now! Sure, it's twice the price of already expensive HP rounds .... but APFL is the ammunition, IMO.
Mäx
QUOTE (_Pax._ @ May 1 2012, 12:23 PM) *
Lots of rambling

Please reread my post very slowly and this time try not to miss anything.
Medicineman
QUOTE
Flechette round are AP+5, not AP-2.

Yes but AP Flechette (from War !) is DV +2 AP 0 (Ok AVail 18V and 16 ¥ per Shot)

with quit a different Dance
Medicineman
Nemo
Thank you for the answers.

Then it will be a houserule.
Umidori
For those who missed it, the -2 AP is from the Ruger Super Warhawk, not the AP Flechette ammo...

nyahnyah.gif

~Umidori
Neraph
QUOTE (almost normal @ Apr 30 2012, 03:16 PM) *
Yeah. It's why I don't like Ex or its big brother much. 33% more power in exchange for using a point of edge every few times you're in combat.

What dicepool do you have where you glitch that frequently? Also, does your mage not know how to summon a spirit with Guard?
almost normal
QUOTE (Neraph @ May 1 2012, 01:06 PM) *
What dicepool do you have where you glitch that frequently? Also, does your mage not know how to summon a spirit with Guard?


You misunderstand, I was lamenting the infrequency of the glitch. Let's make some wild assumptions and say combat lasts 5 turns, you've got 3 passes. If you do nothing but shoot, that's 30 shots. I said "every few times', let's assume that's 4, so you're taking 120 shots, let's smooth that over to 100.

Yeah. 100 rolls of the combat dice pool seem like enough to glitch, wouldn't you say?

Lastly, if our mage wasted his spirit on using Guard, while I'll applaud his effort to self-balance, he's probably doing combat wrong anyway.
Neraph
QUOTE (almost normal @ May 1 2012, 12:24 PM) *
You misunderstand, I was lamenting the infrequency of the glitch. Let's make some wild assumptions and say combat lasts 5 turns, you've got 3 passes. If you do nothing but shoot, that's 30 shots. I said "every few times', let's assume that's 4, so you're taking 120 shots, let's smooth that over to 100.

Yeah. 100 rolls of the combat dice pool seem like enough to glitch, wouldn't you say?

Lastly, if our mage wasted his spirit on using Guard, while I'll applaud his effort to self-balance, he's probably doing combat wrong anyway.

How does 30 shots turn into 120 shots because every fourth you may glitch? Isn't that supposed to be division, not multiplication? Why is your combat lasting 5 turns? The longest combat I've ever been in was 5 CT, and that was against a Prime Runner Team of ex-military SpecOps (one of just about all archetypes).

"Waste" a spirit on Guard? You know Guard protects you from all glitches, right? It's easily one of the better Powers for sheer usefulness; and additionally, you'd only be "wasting" one service, not a whole spirit. Hell, for 500 nuyen.gif and one karma you can get a Long-Term Bound Force 1 Spirit to give Guard to the summoning mage for a year. Can't beat that.
almost normal
QUOTE (Neraph @ May 2 2012, 08:39 AM) *
How does 30 shots turn into 120 shots because every fourth you may glitch? Isn't that supposed to be division, not multiplication? Why is your combat lasting 5 turns? The longest combat I've ever been in was 5 CT, and that was against a Prime Runner Team of ex-military SpecOps (one of just about all archetypes).



You're failing at reading comprehension, and it's aggravating to deal with. As I'm currently drinking iced coffee, and my girlfriend woke me up with a fresh pork roll and cheese bagel, I can handle it.

30 shots a turn turns into 120 shots, because I said every every few combat encounters, which I then expanded upon to say four combat encounters. I'm not sure in which universe of math you'd divide 30 by 4, but in this one, and conveniently in the SR universe as well, we multiply. Why is our combat lasting 5 turns? Hopefully because we've got a good GM who decided to make combat fun, interesting, and dynamic; alternatively, it's because my group and myself suck at combat, and the only one doing combat "right", is you.
Yerameyahu
smile.gif Neraph, didn't you learn your lesson? Don't waste your time on this nonsense (… you have other nonsense, after all!).
almost normal
QUOTE (Yerameyahu @ May 2 2012, 10:12 AM) *
smile.gif Neraph, didn't you learn your lesson? Don't waste your time on this nonsense (… you have other nonsense, after all!).


Obvious ass is obvious. smile.gif
thorya
QUOTE (almost normal @ May 2 2012, 11:13 AM) *
Obvious ass is obvious. smile.gif



QUOTE (almost normal @ Mar 26 2012, 09:27 PM)
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein)

Deep Breath SnowRaven. Just say No to feeding the Troll...


Seriously. I figured

QUOTE
It's laughable. I laugh! HA! HAHAHA!


would have given it away, if not, the testicle-removing entry earlier. I was just having a bit of fun, I apologize if anyone's feelings got hurt.


Yep, admitted troll is obvious.
almost normal
You still sound butthurt.
thorya
QUOTE (almost normal @ May 2 2012, 11:39 AM) *
You still sound butthurt.


Obvious Troll is obvious. smile.gif
almost normal
So you bring up a thread that's over a month old because... Nevermind. Your butthurt trolling isn't worth the effort to respond to. Stick to the topic, or take your whining to PMs.
Redjack
QUOTE (TOS)
1. Personal attacks, flaming, trolling, and baiting are prohibited. This includes any form of racism, sexism or religious intolerance.

Don't respond to flames, report them.

BTW: Reporting an issue, then turning your flame on does not give you immunity; rather it serves to piss off the mods.
KarmaInferno
I would observe that if you are attempting to make a reasoned argument about a subject, there are a number of behaviors, buzz words, and overtones that probably feel good to toss into what you're writing, but in reality actually serve only to weaken your argument.

It's because the inclusion of such words and phrases triggers an emotional reaction rather than a logical one. From that point onwards, the discussion starts becoming less about the actual subject and more about the wording of people's posts.

"Butthurt" is a relevant example. I have never ever heard anyone use that term and have the argument stay on topic. There's really no good reason to use it except to be insulting and dismissive. Therefore any reaction to it is going to be emotion-based and probably way off-topic.

You might have an excellent point to make elsewhere in your post, but it won't matter if everyone else in the conversation can't get past the thought, "Wow, that guy's being an ass."

I suppose the best advice is "Don't post angry". If you're frustrated or angry or even just strongly annoyed about a forum post, you know what? Don't respond. It's just a forum post. Continuing the conversation will likely only result in you getting MORE annoyed or frustrated. It's not worth the stress. If nothing else, come back later when things have cooled off.



-k
thorya
You're right Redjack. Sorry.
Neraph
QUOTE (almost normal @ May 1 2012, 01:24 PM) *
You misunderstand, I was lamenting the infrequency of the glitch. Let's make some wild assumptions and say combat lasts 5 turns, you've got 3 passes. If you do nothing but shoot, that's 30 shots. I said "every few times', let's assume that's 4, so you're taking 120 shots, let's smooth that over to 100.

Yeah. 100 rolls of the combat dice pool seem like enough to glitch, wouldn't you say?

Lastly, if our mage wasted his spirit on using Guard, while I'll applaud his effort to self-balance, he's probably doing combat wrong anyway.



QUOTE (almost normal @ May 2 2012, 09:55 AM) *
You're failing at reading comprehension, and it's aggravating to deal with. As I'm currently drinking iced coffee, and my girlfriend woke me up with a fresh pork roll and cheese bagel, I can handle it.

30 shots a turn turns into 120 shots, because I said every every few combat encounters, which I then expanded upon to say four combat encounters. I'm not sure in which universe of math you'd divide 30 by 4, but in this one, and conveniently in the SR universe as well, we multiply. Why is our combat lasting 5 turns? Hopefully because we've got a good GM who decided to make combat fun, interesting, and dynamic; alternatively, it's because my group and myself suck at combat, and the only one doing combat "right", is you.

Ok, so when you said "every few times" you actually said "every few combat encounters?" I'm sorry that you misstated what you actually meant then. The universe I divide 40 by 4 is the one in which "every few times" refers to the actual gun shots in the sentence preceding that statement, as is done in most of the English-speaking world - you seemed to intend "every few times" to mean "every few times you are in combat," not "every few shots out of the 30 I just said." Lastly, it's nice that you admit I'm better at combat than you are. I take da props where's I can gets da props.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012