Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Howling Shadows
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Prime Mover
In the wild overnight. Pun intended.
http://www.drivethrurpg.com/product/183920...src=slider_view

Very happy with ToC, Drakes, Techno critters, Astral Denizens, Cyber Critters and tons more.
Sengir
The artwork previews certainly looked good
Tecumseh
Nice. Anyone have a DriveThruRPG affiliate code they want me to use?
Sengir
QUOTE (Tecumseh @ May 25 2016, 06:49 PM) *
Nice. Anyone have a DriveThruRPG affiliate code they want me to use?

I took the liberty of turning your question into a suggestion
LurkerOutThere
Just hope you don't want prices and availability for them there critters.
Sengir
QUOTE (LurkerOutThere @ May 26 2016, 11:48 AM) *
Just hope you don't want prices and availability for them there critters.

Personally never used those, but quite a few people apparently did. And of course the "reasoning" for the removal is just classic JMH.

You know what has listed prices and Availability? Cybertooth tigers and junkyard dogs ("this biodrone is specialized for area
denial and manhunting"). But not hellhounds, because "Corps capture and breed their own. And are not anxious to sell them so that more people can have hellhounds".


On the plus side, it still makes a good monster manual, especially the various astral creepiness looks like fun for the aspiring sadist GM biggrin.gif
hermit
That's just your typical, not thought out at all, last minute JMH ghost change that sours an otherwise decent product because he has something to push that he thinks is a good idea. Especially if cyber critters have prices and availabilities. Cybertooth tigers with lasers on their heads? No problem! But don't you DARE want a kitty or a puppy. That's just too unbalanced for JMH. Can't have that. Getting kitties has to be, like, super hard.
Fabe
QUOTE (hermit @ May 27 2016, 09:23 AM) *
That's just your typical, not thought out at all, last minute JMH ghost change that sours an otherwise decent product because he has something to push that he thinks is a good idea. Especially if cyber critters have prices and availabilities. Cybertooth tigers with lasers on their heads? No problem! But don't you DARE want a kitty or a puppy. That's just too unbalanced for JMH. Can't have that. Getting kitties has to be, like, super hard.

yeah how hard could it be to come up with prices and stats for every breed of dog and cat out there? its not like you can get pets from different places for different prices.
hermit
There's one in every crowd. Yeah, sure, I could fix that with house rules and such. The question isn't whether that's possible, the question is why I should have to after paying $25 for a rules book.
Sengir
QUOTE (Fabe @ May 27 2016, 06:40 PM) *
its not like you can get pets guns from different places for different prices.

So obviously, books full of guns are out, too wink.gif

OK, seriously: When it comes to cetacea, juggernauts, astral critters and so forth, I'm fully with Mr. Hardy -- acquiring a blue whale should be a bit more involved than picking the model of your choice out of a list and making a dice roll. But that does not extend to all critters. Common pets and security critters should indeed be available from a catalog.


I guess what really pisses me off about that Twitter exchange is that I've been criticizing the limitations of the price/availability system and the idea of separate entries for left and right socks for some time now. But now the guy who is responsible for that system has stumbled upon the fact that the price/avail system models various things rather poorly and that some costs could just be eyeballed or rolled into lifestyle, and his reaction is to cop out and just not give stats...
Sascha Morlok
BTW nice to know you need a special authorization by S-K to study Fenrir wolfs in Germany. Last time I checked the AGS wasn't a subsidiary of Saeder-Krupp, but I might be wrong.
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ May 28 2016, 05:01 PM) *
BTW nice to know you need a special authorization by S-K to study Fenrir wolfs in Germany. Last time I checked the AGS wasn't a subsidiary of Saeder-Krupp, but I might be wrong.

Google "Stingray NDA"...
hermit
QUOTE
Google "Stingray NDA"...

Which is relevant how, exactly? Aside from the fact that in the fields of IP rights and corporate legislation (as well as countless others), the US and Germany (which is a Nordic/Benelux hybrid legally) don't have much in common, how do a protected IP (software) and a natural ressource (an animal) compare in the slightest? It's not like Fenris wolves were conceived by SK. They're wild animals, much like regular wolves.
Sascha Morlok
QUOTE
Market Panic, p. 159

Later that year Germany got a new chancellor, and
to everyone’s surprise the old corporate-friendly administration
wasn’t reelected. To Saeder-Krupp’s (and especially
Lofwyr’s) displeasure, the conservative candidate
Anikka Beloit won, the last remaining heir to the Beloit
legacy. Her slogan is “Meeting corporations on eye level,”
and as you would expect from someone with that
view, she cut off the privileged access S-K had to the
government in the past
.



¯\_(ツ)_/¯
hermit
Well. That may just not have filtered down to the authors of Howling Shadows.
Mantis
Why are mundane animal speeds so off? An elephant sure doesn't run at 72 meters/3 seconds (86 km/hour) in real life. I assume a typo there but the bear is too slow as is the giraffe. A quick google search shows most of these animal speeds are off. Same was true of Running Wild for 4th ed. It isn't that difficult to get these speeds so why just make up numbers?
I'd give it a pass for paracritters since, you know, magic but they actually seem pretty reasonable for the most part.
Sengir
QUOTE (hermit @ May 29 2016, 01:23 AM) *
Which is relevant how, exactly?

It shows how even in the real world, where conventional governments have something to say, these governments nevertheless allow a company to make decisions which would normally be up to the state -- and follow through with it to the point of dropping persecutions when the alternative would be against that agreement.

Compared to that, granting a company the last word on who can study and keep a certain species seems like petty stuff, especially considering that the power balance between S-K and the AGS is a bit different than between Harris and the US.
Sascha Morlok
QUOTE (Sengir @ May 29 2016, 09:54 PM) *
Compared to that, granting a company the last word on who can study and keep a certain species seems like petty stuff, especially considering that the power balance between S-K and the AGS is a bit different than between Harris and the US.


You haven't read my quote, haven't you? And even before that, the AGS wasn't an S-K subsidiary.
hermit
Besides, that's like granting a company the right to say who gets to collect wild mushrooms, or fish cod. That is WAY above the use of proprietary software in terms of invasiveness and reach. That's nowhere near petty.
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ May 29 2016, 10:41 PM) *
You haven't read my quote, haven't you?

I indeed must have missed the quote stating that somebody shot down the Z-O and threw the Passau treaties into the wreckage. All I can see is a quote saying that S-K no longer enjoys "privileged access", which as long as the world is still ruled by the Big 10 only means that Big L no longer enjoys preferential treatment over the other 9.

QUOTE (hermit @ May 29 2016, 11:02 PM) *
Besides, that's like granting a company the right to say who gets to collect wild mushrooms, or fish cod.

Collecting mushrooms can be subject to government restrictions, fishing and hunting nearly universally is. Even collecting discarded feathers can be heavily restricted. The Swiss still have a salt monopoly, in many countries fermenting or distilling alcohol is only allowed for state-designated businesses, and so on and so forth...
And the trouble with the Stingray NDAs is not about the "use of proprietary software". It's about the government signing a gag clause relating to basically everything about that software, and bending over backwards to serve it, even at the price of dropping persecutions or telling local law enforcement to engage in parallel construction.

So, governments in the restrict or monopolize access to natural resources for various reasons, and governments let corporations have a significant say in sovereign duties. But in a future where megacorps are more powerful than national governments, the very same thing suddenly becomes unrealistic? Yeah, sure...
MrGlee
I imagine the wolf thing is similar to an American concept. Some companies have patent on certain modified seeds, and no matter how they get on a farmer's land(say, wind blowing them off of an exposed truck bed), if they haven't licensed them out to you, will sue the shit out of you. This seems like a similar concept, we own the legal rights to this strain of wolf in Germany, so if you mess with it we take legal action.
Sendaz
So the question is is SK trying to enforce protective status to the Fenrir Wolves because Goldsnout has warm, fuzzy feelings for the animals that frolic in his region or are they just trying to protect their local genepool since the wolves respresent an asset to be harvested and trained for security work?
Sascha Morlok
In Running Wild (which also says that the Wolfs also live in Scandinavia and Eastern Europa) S-K owns a critter farm for them (besides the wild wilds living without interference by S-K). And I guess this is what the author is referring to. What a pity it doesn't read that way.

Last time I checked BRA and the Passau Treaty just grant Corporations extraterritoriality (in exchange for taxes), not fully sovereignty over a country.
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ May 30 2016, 04:02 PM) *
Last time I checked BRA and the Passau Treaty just grant Corporations extraterritoriality (in exchange for taxes), not fully sovereignty over a country.

Let me guess, you also believe that Honduras or Guatemala used to be sovereign nations because there was no treaty explicitly stating that their governments were just lackeys or corporations?


The Big 10 are the superpowers of the 6th world, rivaled only by each other in terms of economic power, military force projection, and cultural soft power. Nation states are nothing but the leftovers after everybody who could staked out their own extraterritorial claim. So if S-K wants to have a monopoly on holding the few remaining fenrirs in Germany, chances are they'll get their way.

------

And now for something different:
QUOTE
Amazonian laws are formulated with the core principle of equal rights towards pretty much all life forms. Whereas any sane city will thank you for killing devil rats, feral dogs and all other creatures that can pose a threat to human life, Amazonia doesn’t see things that way. Any living creature has as much right to exist as any other. In Amazonia, neighborhood ponds may be home to, say, alligator. And nobody is going to ask them to move. “Pest control” is called “murder” over there.

So Hualpa and all the dragons, shifters, and naga in Amazonia are vegetarians? biggrin.gif
JanessaVR
QUOTE (Sengir @ May 31 2016, 10:45 AM) *
And now for something different:

"Amazonian laws are formulated with the core principle of equal rights towards pretty much all life forms. Whereas any sane city will thank you for killing devil rats, feral dogs and all other creatures that can pose a threat to human life, Amazonia doesn’t see things that way. Any living creature has as much right to exist as any other. In Amazonia, neighborhood ponds may be home to, say, alligator. And nobody is going to ask them to move. “Pest control” is called “murder” over there."

So Hualpa and all the dragons, shifters, and naga in Amazonia are vegetarians? biggrin.gif

As true an example of Political Correctness Gone Mad as I've ever seen.

Admittedly, my idea of pest control in the Sixth World includes not only the spell Slaughter Devil Rats, but Slaughter Ghouls as well.

Gotta keep the vermin population down.
Sendaz
Don't forget the Muggle Muzzles. nyahnyah.gif
JanessaVR
QUOTE (Sendaz @ May 31 2016, 11:18 AM) *
Don't forget the Muggle Muzzles. nyahnyah.gif

Only if they get uppity.

Someone has to fetch me tea. wink.gif
Sengir
QUOTE (JanessaVR @ May 31 2016, 09:02 PM) *
As true an example of Political Correctness Gone Mad as I've ever seen.

More a case of somebody trying to create such an example but not really thinking through how it fits in the story...
Sascha Morlok
QUOTE (Sengir @ May 31 2016, 08:45 PM) *
Let me guess, you also believe that Honduras or Guatemala used to be sovereign nations because there was no treaty explicitly stating that their governments were just lackeys or corporations?

The Big 10 are the superpowers of the 6th world, rivaled only by each other in terms of economic power, military force projection, and cultural soft power. Nation states are nothing but the leftovers after everybody who could staked out their own extraterritorial claim. So if S-K wants to have a monopoly on holding the few remaining fenrirs in Germany, chances are they'll get their way.


No, I don`t think they are sovereign Nations, as they where annexed by Aztlan. And Europe isn`t North America. Governments are generally stronger here (even in SR). Nonetheless I know the Big 10 are the major powers in the world. But they aren`t the only powers in the world. And again, the author refers to a S-K critter farm, not the general "patent" on every Fenrir Wolf on this planet. He just missed to write it that way.

But hey, I can`t tell you how to play the game. If you want S-K to onw a patent on them, you are free to do so. But may keep in mind, it`S not supposed to be that way.
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ Jun 1 2016, 03:07 PM) *
No, I don`t think they are sovereign Nations, as they where annexed by Aztlan.

Which together with the past tense might have given you pause -- maybe I wasn't talking Shadowrun?

Hint: Look up the etymology of the term "banana republic". It's a bit of history one should be aware of, even when not trying to write cyberpunk stories

QUOTE
But hey, I can`t tell you how to play the game. If you want S-K to onw a patent on them, you are free to do so. But may keep in mind, it`S not supposed to be that way.

Remind me, who was arguing against what's written in the book, again?



------

And I love those "runner spirits", even though the "Metaplane of Cyberpunk" (not the actual name) is kinda weird.
hermit
QUOTE
you also believe that Honduras or Guatemala used to be sovereign nations because there was no treaty explicitly stating that their governments were just lackeys or corporations?

Maybe you should read that yourself. These states weren't subsidiaries to Dole or United Fruit, but shackled by debt held by the US government and subject to CIA interventions in the McCarthy era because terrorists communists, not corporate mercenaries. For those, I'd recommend a look at the war against Boko Haram and the Biafra war. Also, anything in Africa Cogema/Areva were involved in might be what you're looking for.

Kudos to the Blackjack reference, Howling Wild writers, btw.
Sengir
QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 1 2016, 11:14 PM) *
Maybe you should read that yourself. These states weren't subsidiaries to Dole or United Fruit

Uh yes, that's the entire point: Sascha insists that the Big 10 cannot control governments unless those countries have not been formally designated as "subsidiaries" (which is more a financial term anyway) of the corp(s). I point out cases where countries were at the whim of powerful corporations, without there being a formal treaty stating that the branches of government are United Fruit, United Fruit, and United Fruit.
Sascha Morlok
I used the term "subsidiary" towards a country (Germany) sarcastically, to exaggerate the statement, that some people think S-K "rules" Europe and especially Germany. That isn't nor wasn't the case. Nonetheless the idea always comes up every once in a while. Yes, S-K has influence over several governments, but more because of their economic impotence and monopoly of certain key infrastructures (Energy, Water, Matrix, etc.).

I just find it hard to belive that S-K put so much effort into such a small thing like making all this lawey work for Germany (and obviously for ScanU and "Eastern Europe"), to "patent" something they haven't created, that was just "there" and fighting of every other corp, magical group, guy with money, to claim the same, because nobody would have a good point in claiming something for them self, that was made by nature... so everybody would have the same good points "It's mine because I say so"... well, na... not my type of logic.
lokii
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ Jun 2 2016, 12:36 PM) *
because of their economic impotence
Sascha, Sascha. First argueing against S-Ks awesome power over all German Fenrir wolves and now this Freudian slip. In secret you hate Saeder-Krupp, don't you! biggrin.gif
Sascha Morlok
QUOTE (lokii @ Jun 2 2016, 01:38 PM) *
Sascha, Sascha. First argueing against S-Ks awesome power over all German Fenrir wolves and now this Freudian slip. In secret you hate Saeder-Krupp, don't you! biggrin.gif


I'm arguing against "I'm putting much effort in this tiny unimportant thing, so it belongs to me, because... I said so", I'm not arguing against an S-K "advise" to governments certain "guidelines" as the Grey Eminence in the Game. Nonetheless corps have to follow national and international law. And patenting someone you haven't created is definitely something no government would allow.

And no, I love S-K, especially because you probably have the best working and living conditions as an employee wink.gif
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ Jun 2 2016, 12:36 PM) *
I used the term "subsidiary" towards a country (Germany) sarcastically, to exaggerate the statement, that some people think S-K "rules" Europe and especially Germany.

Yes, because "the cyberpunk RPG" tends to follow certain genre conventions, like megacorporations becoming states and giving Fukuyama the finger.

QUOTE
I just find it hard to belive that S-K put so much effort into such a small thing like making all this lawey work for Germany (and obviously for ScanU and "Eastern Europe")

Where exactly does it say that S-K has the thumb on fenrirs everywhere? Just as a reminder, here is the quote which got you so worked up, emphasis added: "I had to get a special authorization from S-K to do my research on the fenrirs of Germany"

As for "all this lawey work", fenrir wolves are already a protected species, what is so difficult about asking for an exemption (in the name of science or to continue their successful breeding programme) for your company?


QUOTE
to "patent" something they haven't created, that was just "there" and fighting of every other corp, magical group, guy with money, to claim the same, because nobody would have a good point in claiming something for them self, that was made by nature... so everybody would have the same good points "It's mine because I say so"... well, na... not my type of logic.

Oh no, the evil corporations want to monopolize access to natural resources instead of giving everybody fair and equal access to everything, and a warm meal twice a day while they're at it.

Are you sure you are not confusing Shadowrun with another universe?
Sascha Morlok
Funfact: Patents are world wide. So if S-K would monopolize Fenrir wolfs, they would do that automatically in on other places too (and I can literally think of ScanU saying "Yeah, how about no."). And this brings me back to the point that the quote in question is actually referring to the critter farm S-K actually owns (Running Wild, p. 143), but fails to mention that Fenrirs also live in other places and outside said critter farm(s) and further more implies that S-K owns sem all (even these outside the farm(s)).

Interestingly to not is, that Running Wild mention in the same sentence that the German government put Fenrirs under a natural protection program, completely independent of S-Ks programs. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Sengir
QUOTE (Sascha Morlok @ Jun 3 2016, 07:28 AM) *
Funfact: Patents are world wide.

Fun fact: You're wrong. Not that it matters, because where exactly was I talking about patents?

----------
Dzoo-noo-quas have a new skill, which seems to be used for astrally perceiving cute animals: Aaawnsing biggrin.gif

And in the expanded description of Energy Drain:
In addition to the lost point, victims suffer 1 box of damage for each point loss. For the critters in this book, that damage is Stun and may be healed normally. Victims drained of age, though, show the effects of aging, which cannot be reversed.
The last sentence seems redundant, or is this supposed to imply that the aging is represented by non-healing Stun?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012