Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: murder
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Nyxll
It is a given that money can buy freedom. It even happens today. But what do you do when the purpotrator is a dragon?

Dragons murder people all the time. Yet there is no punishment. They commit haenous acts of devastation, and no one does anything or even wants too. World governments should have the power to bring dragons down. Is this an oversite? Are dragons just above the law. Are charges ever brought fourth?
Nikoli
Well, the problem mainly stems from this. How exactly do you suppose a dragon is taken into custody if it doesn't feel like going?
How do yo umake it pay the fines?
How do you make it show up to court?
Apparantly nothing short of a very powerful immortal elf or another great form dragon is powerful enough to match claws with one. Makes it rather difficult to enforce the laws. Just think of them as walking Z-Zones
Ed_209a
I think the hardest part of killing a great dragon is getting LOS to it with the appropriate equipment.

I feel that a flight of jets with anti-ship missiles could make short work of any dragon.

A dragon is tough when you compare it to a person, car or even tank, but shoot a harpoon or tomahawk at it...
Jrayjoker
Unless they are citizens of a jurisdiction. Then you can have a warrant for their arrest and approach them cautiously. After your next envoy is eaten you can revoke citizenship and start seizing property (at least on paper).
Vertaxis666
Most Dragons don't have a SIN.

Those beings without a SIN legally don't exist and aren't protected by the law.

How do you charge someone with murder if they don't exist let alone prosecute them?
Nyxll
Everything starts with a precedent. If they are given rights and priveledges of metahumans, then they should be subject to their law.

You can do many things. Go after them in corporate court. Take their publically known assets. Make them an enemy of the public with a bounty on them. Sooner or later someone will get lucky. With the social and economic changes of 206+ something would play out.

This is one of the problems that bugged me about immortal elves. They are above everyone, completely invulnerable. Anyhow for 10-20 million, a few teams will take the run. once they are dead ... assets can be seized to recoup costs, (with a slight profit)

after a while after a few dragons get snuffed, they might get the hint.
Nyxll
QUOTE

Most Dragons don't have a SIN.

Those beings without a SIN legally don't exist and aren't protected by the law.

How do you charge someone with murder if they don't exist let alone prosecute them?


Are you kidding me? Most runners do not have SINs. When they get caught they are just are not set free because they do not have a SIN. There are rules for prosecuting someone without a SIN.


QUOTE
Unless they are citizens of a jurisdiction. Then you can have a warrant for their arrest and approach them cautiously. After your next envoy is eaten you can revoke citizenship and start seizing property (at least on paper).


So what you are saying is I can go to mexico and kill people, and just walk away because I am not a citizen there?
Velocity
Betcha Dunkie had a SIN. Betcha Lofwyr does too. Granted, they're exceptional. Nevertheless, Nyxll is quite right: regardless of an individual's legal status, a nation will take steps to prosecute and punish violent criminals within their jurisdiction. Whether the alleged criminals possess legal identities or not is moot.

Regarding a dragon's power, well... a government (or corp) would step very lightly and probably try to work out some sort of "arrangement" before moving to strict interdiction and punishment.
Bearclaw
QUOTE (Ed_209a)
I think the hardest part of killing a great dragon is getting LOS to it with the appropriate equipment.

I feel that a flight of jets with anti-ship missiles could make short work of any dragon.

A dragon is tough when you compare it to a person, car or even tank, but shoot a harpoon or tomahawk at it...

Only if he was asleep.
Great dragons aren't terrible because of their physical abilities, they're terrible because of their magical abilities. You could send a team of jets after Lofwyr if you want. Repeated force 25 barriers will take care of any missle or plane. Plus there's the fact that if he wants to, he can just stop being there. You're talking about an individual creature who can match the great ghost dance for power and has thousands of years of practice. Do you really think that if it only took a couple of missles, he'd still be alive? Or Hestaby?
hyzmarca
Adult Dragons and Free Spirits have been known to own non-extraterritorial property. They have rights, just not citizenship. Even the SINless have rights. It is simply easier to violate them.

Adult dragons wouldn't be that difficult to bring to justice. Free Spirits would be more difficult, but they can be bound and banished. Great Dragons are another story. Most GDs are avoid blatently flaunting metahuman laws. Those that do would provide a challange for some militaries. However, they can still be killed with the proper application of military force. It just requires a little bit more effort than usual.

Assets are another story. Assets can be seized with little difficulty. Non-extrateritorial assets only require a court order. Extrateritorial assets require than and some diplomacy. Unless the Great Dragon liquidates everything into a single certified credstick and personally sits of it, any government can force a dragon to pay a fine.
Backgammon
QUOTE (Nyxll)
Everything starts with a precedent. If they are given rights and priveledges of metahumans, then they should be subject to their law.

You can do many things. Go after them in corporate court. Take their publically known assets. Make them an enemy of the public with a bounty on them. Sooner or later someone will get lucky. With the social and economic changes of 206+ something would play out.

This is one of the problems that bugged me about immortal elves. They are above everyone, completely invulnerable. Anyhow for 10-20 million, a few teams will take the run. once they are dead ... assets can be seized to recoup costs, (with a slight profit)

after a while after a few dragons get snuffed, they might get the hint.

You want to declare war on the dragons? You do not understand how powerful dragons are.

1) "Governements should take a firm stand". Who is this "governement" you speak of? The "governement" that had a dragon as president, or the one that has one sitting on the Council of Princes? See the problem? Dragons rule the world. That's all there is to it. No "governement" is going to declare war on them and their assets, since all those governements have dragon influence somewhere in them.

2) A single GD can level a city. Teheran no longer exists because they thought Dragons sucked. Dragons have no reason to be hostile because the populations "accepts" them in society, sorta. They get to play their power games and stuff. If the population suddently stands up and says No to dragons, there is no reason why dragons would not start massively killing everything that stands. I'm not saying they'd win, but the world would be in ashes after that particular war.

3) The other governement: Corporate Court. SK, the most powerful mega corp, is the plaything of a dragon. Aztechnology is also, sorta. They won't move against dagons, same as #1.

Need more convincing?
hyzmarca
QUOTE (Backgammon)
QUOTE (Nyxll @ Aug 4 2005, 01:23 PM)
Everything starts with a precedent.  If they are given rights and priveledges of metahumans, then they should be subject to their law.

You can do many things.  Go after them in corporate court.  Take their publically known assets.  Make them an enemy of the public with a bounty on them.  Sooner or later someone will get lucky.  With the social and economic changes of 206+  something would play out.

This is one of the problems that bugged me about immortal elves.  They are above everyone, completely invulnerable.  Anyhow for 10-20 million, a few teams will take the run.  once they are dead ... assets can be seized to recoup costs, (with a slight profit)

after a while after a few dragons get snuffed, they might get the hint.

You want to declare war on the dragons? You do not understand how powerful dragons are.

1) "Governements should take a firm stand". Who is this "governement" you speak of? The "governement" that had a dragon as president, or the one that has one sitting on the Council of Princes? See the problem? Dragons rule the world. That's all there is to it. No "governement" is going to declare war on them and their assets, since all those governements have dragon influence somewhere in them.

2) A single GD can level a city. Teheran no longer exists because they thought Dragons sucked. Dragons have no reason to be hostile because the populations "accepts" them in society, sorta. They get to play their power games and stuff. If the population suddently stands up and says No to dragons, there is no reason why dragons would not start massively killing everything that stands. I'm not saying they'd win, but the world would be in ashes after that particular war.

3) The other governement: Corporate Court. SK, the most powerful mega corp, is the plaything of a dragon. Aztechnology is also, sorta. They won't move against dagons, same as #1.

Need more convincing?

The thing is that Dragons don't like each other very much. If a random GD levels a SK facility will Lofwyr go out of his way to protect that dragon. Frag no. He'll go out of his way to make that dragon dead.

There is no dragon union to collectivly bragain for the race. It is every dragon for itself. When their interests coincide they may work together. When they don't, they don't care what happens to each other. When their interests oppose each other then they do not pull punches.

FrostyNSO
I always figured some GD's were afforded the status of individual nations. Ghostwalker should be at least since he has his own little kingdom in Denver.

If a nation (great dragon) determines that it is in their best interest to "war" upon their neighbors to gain some political advantage, well that is something nations can legally do.

ShadowDragon8685
Ignoring the topic of the legality of warfare...


A Greater Dragon should be treated as, I think, a Superpower. They are slayable, but it's going to take great luck, or great skill, not to mention a great deal of slaughter.


In other words, not worth it, unless the GD assassinated your premier.
FrostyNSO
QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 4 2005, 08:21 PM)
Ignoring the topic of the legality of warfare...

Whoops, Sorry. nyahnyah.gif

edit: I think the point the original poster was interested in, is that the GD could go ahead and assassinate your premier (if doing so helped it somehow), and basically get away with it.

I've got something of a chip on my shoulder for this sort of thing. To me, part of SR is that there are some people who are above the law (and there's nothing you can do about it). However: Often, those who think they're above the law end up falling down and being crushed by it. For some reason this never seems to happen to the GD's and IE's unless another is involved.

Maybe it just stems from me not liking any individual of that scale of power pulling the strings in my world...It's like, why even bother anymore?
ShadowDragon8685
I dunno. Depends on the premier in question.

I mean, you knock off the premier of, say, uganda or something (I know Uganda no longer exists in 206x+,) and no, they won't be able to do something.


You whack the prez of the UCAS, and it's another matter.
FrostyNSO
Not the way it's represented in SR...

"Oh sure, go ahead, Denver's yours now!"

:touched upon in my edit above:
DrJest
QUOTE
This is one of the problems that bugged me about immortal elves. They are above everyone, completely invulnerable.


Yes and no. Most of the ones we know of have wormed their way into positions of major political power, and have used that power to skew the rules in their favour (most obvious eg, The Two Tirs... hmm... sounds like a book in there somewhere...). Those few that haven't taken that route (eg, Harlequin, at least to the best of my knowledge) live like professional ghosts, much in the same way that the top figures in organised crime or professional (as opposed to ideological) terror activities do - sure you could do stuff to them, but you have to find them first.
hyzmarca
QUOTE (FrostyNSO @ Aug 4 2005, 08:31 PM)
Not the way it's represented in SR...

"Oh sure, go ahead, Denver's yours now!"

:touched upon in my edit above:

Considering that Ghostwalker is probably the most powerful living Dragon in terms of raw magical strength and that he had the support of the Draco Foundation and a small army of spirits, turning over Denver wasn't the most unwise decision. It is just one city. What does one city matter in the grand sceme of a nation. Diddly squat, that's what. Let him have Denver. It is less costly than an all out war would be.

Besides, the UCAS government likes abandoning cities. Just look at Chicago.

Now, if he were to start invading other cities, then there would be an all out war and Ghostwalker would lose.
Herald of Verjigorm
Denver wasn't a city. It was representative regions of 5 nations that really wanted to kill each other but knew that whoever made the first move would lose the most. Some representative shows up with a nice little set of conditions on how not to be attacked by a great dragon who will be showing up soon. Interesting, the only criteria are "don't represent Aztlan" and "don't shoot at the dragon." You'd almost have to be an idiot to not accept those terms. Then, once Aztlan was removed (who the other groups hated even more than everyone who is left), the dragon demands to be in charge and offers chunks of the former Aztlan resources as rewards to those who play nice with him.

The only real question is whether Aztlan would've been smacked down if it had been CAS that was the perpetual antagonist in all the meetings and Aztlan had been civil. To restate that hypothetical question for those who haven't read about the council meetings pre-Ghostwalker, "was the decision to crush Aztlan property decided because they had the highest public rejection in those with power or was it determined more from other reasons?"
FrostyNSO
QUOTE (hyzmarca)
Considering that Ghostwalker is probably the most powerful living Dragon in terms of raw magical strength and that he had the support of the Draco Foundation and a small army of spirits, turning over Denver wasn't the most unwise decision. It is just one city. What does one city matter in the grand sceme of a nation. Diddly squat, that's what. Let him have Denver. It is less costly than an all out war would be.

Thank you, Mr. Chamberlain.
Velocity
One city has tremendous symbolic value. It sets a hell of a precedent, although arguably the Great Ghost Dance did it first. Or maybe the American Revolution did. Or the Gauls did. Whatever.

The point is, I have to question the assertion that the surrendering of Denver didn't matter in the grand scheme of things.
Critias
Yeah. One city's no big deal.

Heck, we should'a given New York to the terrorists!
Cynic project
I would say that the high level people in any of the AAA's or maybe even AA could kill citazen of said AAA. I mean Misster Knight makes it legal for him to kill, and then then kills some on who is a citazen in his nation. Who is going to stop him?
hyzmarca
QUOTE (Critias)
Yeah. One city's no big deal.

Heck, we should'a given New York to the terrorists!

If the terrorists asked politely and promised not to let the big bad Injuns don't invade and deport all white people continent back to Europe then it would have been a wise decision, indeed.
Kyuhan
Ghostwalker's cool IMO.
Adarael
QUOTE
A Greater Dragon should be treated as, I think, a Superpower.


I grossly disagree with this assessment. Currently the only superpowers in the world are the United States, Russia and China. Many people will even dispute China and Russia as having relevancy to the word 'superpower.' GD's shouldn't even be given as much consideration as say, the Netherlands, with regards to their power. Why, you ask?

Well, let's put it this way. We can assume that any reasonably developed sixth world nation has at least one mobile platform that can fire either cruise missiles, railguns, or both. A great dragon will be totally toasted by these. "But heavens!" some have said, "They have GREAT magic power!" True, but they can only react to so much at one time. An attack squadron of the 2060 equivalent of Eurofighter Typhoons or F-16s will make extremely short work of any GD, based purely on their speed, maximum strike range, and ability to launch many, many missiles/railgun shots. This is why Hualpa, Mujaji, et cetera, didn't simply waltz into the Yucatan and single-handedly wipe out entire regiments. Sure, they did a lot of damage... but they didn't do it by themselves, nor did they do it like an armored, invulnerable giant. And now for a specific rebuttal:

QUOTE
Repeated force 25 barriers will take care of any missle or plane.


Not when there are between 8-20 missiles, moving between mach 0.8 and 1.5. Possibly even as high as mach 2 - 3.5, depending on if Shadowrun cruise missiles have evolved out of things like the D-21 drone originally designed for the SR-71. Remember, many great dragons *do* work within the boundaries of the rules to an extent. You can't cast a force 6M Naval barrier when you don't have an action, and you certainly can't cast it when you don't know you'll need that action to avoid getting hit. Actually, I don't think you can cast a naval-class barrier at all, but that doesn't mean it couldn't happen. To take down a single, solitary, powerful being you hit it fast enough that it just can't react to all the threats at once.

So why hasn't a GD ever been killed like this?

Well, that's simple. Like Great Dragons, attack squadrons of military fighter aircraft are plot devices, and if the authors don't think the plot should move that way, it won't. Which is where we encounter problem 2 with 'Wax the GD with missiles.'

Canon makes it very clear that the GDs have massive hordes of resources which they've used to build allies, contacts, influence, spy networks, et cetera, so that they're never caught unawares by ordinary people. And that any national or corporate threat that crops up they can merely buy or threaten out of existence. Denver is a prime example of how this could work. Sure, Ghostwalker bullied the city into accepting him as ruler, but anyone who did so stood to gain a massive economic and political prize. Likewise, while it may have been extremely rude of Surrurg to blow up that EuroAir flight, I'm fairly certain any international inquiries into the matter were squelched by favors and donations to those that might do the inquiring.

In short, I figure the GDs are just like any other extremely powerful figure in Shadowrun: totally mortal, once you plant the C4 on their face or achieve a lock-on with your supersonic cruise missile. The problem is getting to that point. The GDs have *wonderful* publicity working for them, especially in the 'you can't possibly ever harm us' department.
Nikoli
You forget, the text on GD's states they are never taken unaware and are prepared for all threats from mundane sources. That means before you fire that naval gun, the GD knew you were planning on doing so and roughly when, so yes, there is a barrier in place (more likely around the gun so you remove it as a threat) when you decide to fire.
SL James
QUOTE (hyzmarca)
QUOTE (Critias @ Aug 5 2005, 12:49 AM)
Yeah.  One city's no big deal.

Heck, we should'a given New York to the terrorists!

If the terrorists asked politely and promised not to let the big bad Injuns don't invade and deport all white people continent back to Europe then it would have been a wise decision, indeed.

At what point in his attacks on Denver did Ghostwalker ask politely?
arcady
QUOTE (Vertaxis666)
Those beings without a SIN legally don't exist and aren't protected by the law.

How do you charge someone with murder if they don't exist let alone prosecute them?

You don't need ID to get in trouble, you need it to avoid trouble.

Illegal aliens are arrested all the time today and processed through the criminal justice system. They face greater hardships than a citizen or resident alien as their status has forced them totake measures that make good legal representation hard to afford (if there's one thing you can't pay under the table no matter how much money you have - its the lawyer who shows up in court with you - too much tracking of their financials for them to be able to take the pay, even their time can be make part of a court record with ease - and supena's for a defense lawyers billing hours is a popular prosecution tactics to use on lawyers who represent socially deviant clients).


How do you take a dragon down? Sieze all of his financial assets - everything (s)he has tied up in investments, banks, and elsewhere. You can then put a hold on any money (s)he tried to move into or out of your jurisdiction.

Presumming the dragon is wealthy and well invested, this will hurt. They are now forced to work through the underground economy. When that happens, you arrest every non-dragon agent they use to move and otherwise manipulate that money. Presuming of course you lack the man power to go after them directly.

At this point the easiest option for the dragon is to simply take flight for a new home.
ShadowDragon8685
Yet, you neglect one factor, Arcady.

Pride. Dragons are prideful SOBs. And if it's the kind of dragon that has a "Greater" attached to the front of it's race, chances are it can do YOU a whole hell of a lot more hurt than you can do it. Don't believe it?

Go ask the people who live in Teherhan.
arcady
-shrug- you can have all the pride you want, but when nobody else is willing to deal with your stocks and your investments for fear -they- will get arrested, you're washed out.

When your money wimply will not move into and out of market's because the banking software has stop-order holds on it, you can't invest, can't withdraw funds, can't deposit, can't do anything with it.

All the might in the world can't stop that - physical power is useless against it. There are no 'people' to target to take your frustrations out on over it.
ShadowDragon8685
Arcady, sure there are.

The government institutions that initiated the hold. This would be like freezing the assets of a Superpower, and thinking they won't retaliate with physical force.
Nikoli
I see Arcady's plan working until the dragon narrows down who is in charge and can rectify their predicament and that person having a sudden change of heart when the dragon astrally projects and possesses them long enough to make sure it doesn't happen again.
ShadowDragon8685
Or that... maybe I play that other game too much, but I prefer crusading dragons laying waste and wreaking utter havoc on those who torque them off. smile.gif
arcady
Physical power has nothing on the weight of bureaucracy, endless miles of paperwork, redtape that has no end user who is responsible / authorized, and even a simple line of code in the financial system software blocking out a line of users from access.

The mafia has tried it all before, and the only solution they've ever managed is the payoff over time of large numbers of people - which always fails to undo the system, but can instead keep the system away in the first place.

When the enemy has no actual face, there is no face to target, and that's why simply financially locking someone out of the system is an ideal solution. There is no one person to intimidate.
hyzmarca
QUOTE (arcady @ Aug 5 2005, 02:16 PM)
Physical power has nothing on the weight of bureaucracy, endless miles of paperwork, redtape that has no end user who is responsible / authorized, and even a simple line of code in the financial system software blocking out a line of users from access.

The mafia has tried it all before, and the only solution they've ever managed is the payoff over time of large numbers of people - which always fails to undo the system, but can instead keep the system away in the first place.

When the enemy has no actual face, there is no face to target, and that's why simply financially locking someone out of the system is an ideal solution. There is no one person to intimidate.

You can never sieze all of a GD's assets. Even if you take every single penny they they have collected in the Sixth World they still have gaimungous Fourth World trasure hordes to fall back on. Lawyer? I believe that the Sixth World still has public defenders. Forcing the governmen tthat is prosucuting you to pay for your legal defense while you live in luxury is the ultimate kick in the pants.

Howveer, there is something more important to consider. You can't fight the system, but you can become the system. In many cases, GD's are the system, as has been pointed out. The most afulant of GD's are simply too politically important to go after.

Also, finiancial attacks go both ways. Governments don't have limitless resources. They have a limited amount of funds to work with. It isn't difficult for a massivie finicial power to substantially reduce the funds that a government has to work with simply be hoarding savings bonds and cashing them all in at the right time.

If the bureaucrats don't get paid then the bureaucrats don't work.Without bureaucrats there is no bureaucracy
Nikoli
Not to mention, what is the average intelligence of a GD? like 12 or so? Do you really want to put up your dream team of leagle beagles against that? It's be like Corky trying to prosecute Will Hunting it's just not gonna happen.
toturi
Not if my dream team consists of otakus (past or present) and their fairy godfather AI (what is the average Intelligence of an AI?). If suddenly, the dragon's SIN got altered (tsk tsk a criminal SIN, Mr Lowfyr?) and all his funds got "misappropriated", how is he going to do anything. Hell, the government could just as easily maintain that anyone without a SIN is not entitled to any legal defense, not every country has metahuman rights.
ShadowDragon8685
If you try to screw a Greater Dragon, you just wind up screwing yourself.
hyzmarca
QUOTE (toturi)
Not if my dream team consists of otakus (past or present) and their fairy godfather AI (what is the average Intelligence of an AI?). If suddenly, the dragon's SIN got altered (tsk tsk a criminal SIN, Mr Lowfyr?) and all his funds got "misappropriated", how is he going to do anything. Hell, the government could just as easily maintain that anyone without a SIN is not entitled to any legal defense, not every country has metahuman rights.

So, we are back to a Great Dragon can be taken down by an Ultimate NPC.

Exactly. Everyone would agree on that.

If all of Mr Lowfyr's funds got misaproperiated he could always fall back on the paper currency, gold bullion, real estate, priceless 4th world artifacts, objects of obscene magical power, and ect. that he has stached away in his many lairs.

However, any government will notice that Mr. Lowfyr is the head of a AAA. This means that he possesses soverign immunity and can't be charged with any crime for that reason. International law, and all.


The only way to take down a great dragon is with overwhealming military force. It is doable and it has been done in the past. I know some dragons have been killed by militaries in the 6th World. I'm not sure if any of them were great. In the 4th World, however the Theran military was able to kill the Loremaster of the time. Granted, Thera had more Mojo than the average soverign entity in the 6th world, but the lower mana levels restrict dragon magic, too.
Snow_Fox
QUOTE (Ed_209a)
I think the hardest part of killing a great dragon is getting LOS to it with the appropriate equipment.

I feel that a flight of jets with anti-ship missiles could make short work of any dragon.


A squadron of bombers with military grade lazers flattened a schloss but didn't scratch Alamias. The thing is most dragons wouldn't dirty their talons with murder in a public place. They would use followers to do it, who could be later disavowed.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012