Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Full Body Cyborgs?
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2
Daddy's Little Ninja
the new Augmentations book lists "full body cyborgs" in it's options. does this seem like a logical development for SR OR is it trying to tap into the Ghost in the Shell market with way the comet surge seemed to be pushing other anime borders?
Aaron
I know that the subject of full-body conversions in Shadowrun have been around since 1989, at least in the circles I've been around. I'm pretty sure that's pre-GitS.
Rotbart van Dainig
Actually, GitS seems to have had it's first run in May 1989... Cybertechnology should have been released later.
Moon-Hawk
It goes like this:
Shadowrun: We have cyberlimbs.
Some player out there: Then I want a cyber-everything!

Where there are cyberlimbs, there will be full 'borgs. smile.gif
Starmage21
QUOTE (Moon-Hawk)
It goes like this:
Shadowrun: We have cyberlimbs.
Some player out there: Then I want a cyber-everything!

Where there are cyberlimbs, there will be full 'borgs. smile.gif

pardon my rifts terms, but full-conversion cyborgs (a human brain inside a 100% machine body) are just plain cool. Especially considering the fact that the brain could survive about 300 years whereas our other biological support systems fail long before that(in less than 100 years usually).

Also, a body comprised entirely of machinery has allure because people tend to think of machines as being able to do everything a human can do(physically), but faster, stronger, and more precise.

Cyberpunk: 2020 (and V3) have had full-conversion 'borgs for a long time. Since they dont have the essence problem at all. Considering how much essence you lose just to have 4 cyberlimbs and a cybertorso, a full-conversion cyborg in shadowrun is likely a cyberzombie at best.

Personally, if it were available, I'd go full-conversion without ever having regrets.
Ryu
The technological development took pretty long actually - with DNI the true barrier for developing jarheads was broken decades before 2070. I just hope the link between brain and mind will not be broken.
Jaid
QUOTE (Starmage21)
Considering how much essence you lose just to have 4 cyberlimbs and a cybertorso, a full-conversion cyborg in shadowrun is likely a cyberzombie at best.

Personally, if it were available, I'd go full-conversion without ever having regrets.

actually, if you just have alpha in each type of cyberlimb (and the two cybershells) it comes up below 6 essence cost. if you also have the right qualities, that can go even lower.

you are, however, correct about it not being cheap.
hobgoblin
QUOTE (Starmage21)
Cyberpunk: 2020 (and V3) have had full-conversion 'borgs for a long time. Since they dont have the essence problem at all. Considering how much essence you lose just to have 4 cyberlimbs and a cybertorso, a full-conversion cyborg in shadowrun is likely a cyberzombie at best.

well there was other risks in 2020, namely going cyberpsycho...

but in v3 that concept is fully gone. hell, now you have a altcult where its expect that when a child reach adulthood, (s)he gets to choose a body. now thats a rite of passage! eek.gif
Ol' Scratch
Yes. Ghost in the Machine was the first mention, ever, of cyborgs and people transfering their minds into robots. Anime was the first at everything. Why, I think anime even invented the wheel and the light bulb.

What the hell?
Casper
QUOTE (Doctor Funkenstein)
Yes. Ghost in the Machine was the first mention, ever, of cyborgs and people transfering their minds into robots. Anime was the first at everything. Why, I think anime even invented the wheel and the light bulb.

What the hell?

Meh.


Buster
The Chinese invented cyborgs in 200 B.C. right before they invented spaghetti and the fork.

The Qin dynasty had an incredibly well-funded R&D program.
Moon-Hawk
QUOTE (Buster)
The Chinese invented cyborgs in 200 B.C. right before they invented spaghetti and the fork.

The Qin dynasty had an incredibly well-funded R&D program.

Dude, that's such BS. They've found evidence of cyborgs inside egyption tombs that predate the chinese cyborgs by almost 2000 years. You think they had unmodified humans lifting those big f-ing bricks to build the pyramids? biggrin.gif
bishop186
QUOTE (Moon-Hawk)
Dude, that's such BS. They've found evidence of cyborgs inside egyption tombs that predate the chinese cyborgs by almost 2000 years. You think they had unmodified humans lifting those big f-ing bricks to build the pyramids? biggrin.gif

Ah, but you forget about the Anglos. It was in fact the English who first had use of cyborgs, which they used to heft those large rocks around for Stonehenge. Surely you don't really think that they moved the suckers around on logs. In fact, recent archeological discoveries have proven the use of cybernetic parts when they uncovered "Copernicus," the mummified corpse of an ancient cybered male.
Adarael
Stonehenge IS a full borg.
Cadmus
Your all wrong, resent Proof has shown what we all knew. thousands of years ago the Irish had a civilization far in advance of our own, and shadowrun...and anime nyahnyah.gif

Though with out reason it collapsed, oh about the same time it seems they discovered alcohol. its just really weird.



((its true famly guy said so smile.gif ))

Big D
Those are just copycats. Atlantis had full cyborg bodies with no essence cost.
Naysayer
Which Atlantis?
As there are about a dozen or so places right now claiming to be the one.
The one I've been to, an island by the name of Santorini, even had proof, in the form of a glossy leaflet that they handed to tourists at the port.
Apparently, that place was once called Thera.
And they totally did Delta-Grade Cybermantic Surgery without evil blood-magic for only three fiffy.
And they invented Elfbian Catgirl Ninja Assassins.
And pizza-flavoured, caffeinated water.
Anime, though, they want nuffin to do with.

And I so gotta get my Paypal running so I can get Augmentation, not so much for the Fullborgs (though that's so 80's Robocop-ish and I am totally happy to finally see that in SR after all these years) but mainly because I read that there's some stuff that makes Cyberlimbs actually *gasp* useable...

Zolhex
QUOTE (Naysayer @ Aug 24 2007, 08:29 PM)
Which Atlantis?
As there are about a dozen or so places right now claiming to be the one.

There is only one Atlantis it is 10's of thousands of years old and not too long ago we found out where it was and how to get to it.

Although travel to the Pegasus Galaxy is limited to a few specialists and military personnel for now one can hope they will soon allow others to visit.

For now though they do have a live video journal type thing on the Sci-Fi network on Fridays.
mfb
SR's full-body cyborgs are very different from GitS. they appear more to be a continuation of plotlines introduced earlier in the metaplot than an attempt to recreate the Major in SR.
Dancer
GitS 'borgs are purely digital entities. SR 'full conversions' are still meat, they've just been pared down as much as possible.
Kazum
QUOTE (Starmage21)

pardon my rifts terms, but full-conversion cyborgs (a human brain inside a 100% machine body) are just plain cool. Especially considering the fact that the brain could survive about 300 years whereas our other biological support systems fail long before that(in less than 100 years usually).



Have you never heard of age-related mental-deseases like parkinson, altzheimer, or plain getting senile ?

I think that about no brain will be 100% functional for about 300 years...
Starmage21
QUOTE (Kazum)
QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Aug 24 2007, 09:40 AM)

pardon my rifts terms, but full-conversion cyborgs (a human brain inside a 100% machine body) are just plain cool. Especially considering the fact that the brain could survive about 300 years whereas our other biological support systems fail long before that(in less than 100 years usually).



Have you never heard of age-related mental-deseases like parkinson, altzheimer, or plain getting senile ?

I think that about no brain will be 100% functional for about 300 years...

Senility is not necessarily linked to age, and neither is parkinsons or alzheimer's. In the latter two, they can be detected long before the full effects are ever felt. Perhaps, in the age of magic and nanotechnology, can be cured as well.
darthmord
QUOTE (Kazum)
QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Aug 24 2007, 09:40 AM)

pardon my rifts terms, but full-conversion cyborgs (a human brain inside a 100% machine body) are just plain cool. Especially considering the fact that the brain could survive about 300 years whereas our other biological support systems fail long before that(in less than 100 years usually).



Have you never heard of age-related mental-deseases like parkinson, altzheimer, or plain getting senile ?

I think that about no brain will be 100% functional for about 300 years...

One of the books in the fluff commentary has a note about brains in a jar jogging some old memory... Dune comes to mind and the name was Dune related.

Those brains had been going for a VERY long time.
Snow_Fox
I think DLN means are they copying the popular anime instead coming up with something new. I think they probably were encouraged by the popularity of the anime but if you see the development form limbs, to full body and skull to cymbermancy you can see a logical progression.
toturi
QUOTE (Casazil)
There is only one Atlantis it is 10's of thousands of years old and not too long ago we found out where it was and how to get to it.

Although travel to the Pegasus Galaxy is limited to a few specialists and military personnel for now one can hope they will soon allow others to visit.

For now though they do have a live video journal type thing on the Sci-Fi network on Fridays.

rollin.gif
the_dunner
QUOTE (darthmord)
One of the books in the fluff commentary has a note about brains in a jar jogging some old memory... Dune comes to mind and the name was Dune related.

While I can see why you'd say that, I can promise Dune was not the reference the author intended.

I can also point out that I've never actually has seen GitS. As others have pointed out, there are other older sources for material on cyborgs. (I'm pretty sure that Deathlok is the first one that I distinctly remember reading about, which'd be around 1977 or so in a Marvel Two-in-One.)
Draconis
Bah, I never get the obsession with speculating who came up with what meme.

Of course Shirow Masamune didn't come up with the idea of full conversion borgs. He is a hard core technophile and did advance the idea by leaps and bounds however. Check out the manga to see how indepth he can get.

Adarael
Seconded. The appendixes, footnotes, and whatnot are pure gold. Even if I prefer the characterization of Kusanagi and Batou in GitS 2 and SAC better.

(HAWT BISEXUAL FULL BORG KILLER ZOMG! I deal with enough of that in RPGs without Shirow doubling up on me, thanks.)
l33tpenguin
QUOTE (Snow_Fox)
I think DLN means are they copying the popular anime instead coming up with something new. I think they probably were encouraged by the popularity of the anime but if you see the development form limbs, to full body and skull to cymbermancy you can see a logical progression.

Its hardly copying the popular anime, when almost anything touched in anime has already been done before. To claim that they are copying from a specific anime source is rather daft. I can't think of much, if anything, that anime has truly come up with on its own that hasn't already been done in fiction somewhere else.
Draconis
QUOTE (Adarael)
Seconded. The appendixes, footnotes, and whatnot are pure gold. Even if I prefer the characterization of Kusanagi and Batou in GitS 2 and SAC better.

(HAWT BISEXUAL FULL BORG KILLER ZOMG! I deal with enough of that in RPGs without Shirow doubling up on me, thanks.)

Dude, Tachikoma's and Fuchikoma's crack me up. They're damn funny.
So much so I went out tonight and bought some Infinity and AT-43 miniatures
for my wife, she plays our Rigger. So now she's going to put some AIs in those drones
and have them back us up. GiTS FTW.

Infinity drones 1

Infinity drone 2

Infinity drones 3

This one I said she can call a Metal....Gear. Heh.

AT-43 drone
PBTHHHHT
nice miniatures, I remember looking at some of that stuff a while ago, it's nice to see them really flesh out the miniature lines... oh man, those things look sweeeet.
Adarael
That AT-43 is wonderful! Man, it's like something outa Gasaraki, but beat to hell.
Big D
Actually, the first thing that comes to my mind when thinking of "brains in a jar" is Futurama. Crossing this with the Equinox thread, can you imagine, 5,000 years in the future, a band of heros stumbling across and having to put up with Harlequin's head in a jar?
knasser
QUOTE (Big D)
Actually, the first thing that comes to my mind when thinking of "brains in a jar" is Futurama. Crossing this with the Equinox thread, can you imagine, 5,000 years in the future, a band of heros stumbling across and having to put up with Harlequin's head in a jar?


"Oh, I_______, ain't got no_ body! Doo be do!"
Draconis
QUOTE (Big D @ Aug 27 2007, 05:00 AM)
Actually, the first thing that comes to my mind when thinking of "brains in a jar" is Futurama.  Crossing this with the Equinox thread, can you imagine, 5,000 years in the future, a band of heros stumbling across and having to put up with Harlequin's head in a jar?

Man if I had H's head in a jar I'd drop kick it out an airlock. I loathe IEs.
Naysayer
QUOTE (l33tpenguin)
QUOTE (l33tpenguin @ Aug 26 2007, 08:08 PM)

Its hardly copying the popular anime, when almost anything touched in anime has already been done before.  To claim that they are copying from a specific anime source is rather daft.  I can't think of much, if anything, that anime has truly come up with on its own that hasn't already been done in fiction somewhere else.



Hmm, the staple "insert space tentacle into various body cavities" comes to mind...
knasser
QUOTE (Naysayer)
QUOTE (l33tpenguin)
QUOTE (l33tpenguin @ Aug 26 2007, 08:08 PM)

Its hardly copying the popular anime, when almost anything touched in anime has already been done before.  To claim that they are copying from a specific anime source is rather daft.  I can't think of much, if anything, that anime has truly come up with on its own that hasn't already been done in fiction somewhere else.



Hmm, the staple "insert space tentacle into various body cavities" comes to mind...


I think Hyzmarca converted that to Shadowrun a while ago.

Link

(You have been warned).

-K.
Fortune
QUOTE (knasser)
QUOTE (Naysayer @ Aug 27 2007, 02:08 PM)
QUOTE (l33tpenguin)
I can't think of much, if anything, that anime has truly come up with on its own that hasn't already been done in fiction somewhere else.

Hmm, the staple "insert space tentacle into various body cavities" comes to mind...


I think Hyzmarca converted that to Shadowrun a while ago.

The question was what original thing has Anime contributed to fiction. wink.gif
Big D
Catgirls?
Jaid
QUOTE (Fortune)
QUOTE (knasser @ Aug 28 2007, 12:37 AM)
QUOTE (Naysayer @ Aug 27 2007, 02:08 PM)
QUOTE (l33tpenguin)
I can't think of much, if anything, that anime has truly come up with on its own that hasn't already been done in fiction somewhere else.

Hmm, the staple "insert space tentacle into various body cavities" comes to mind...


I think Hyzmarca converted that to Shadowrun a while ago.

The question was what original thing has Anime contributed to fiction. wink.gif

transformable mecha?

(i'm actually completely uncertain of that.... but if it didn't introduce the concept, it at least seems to be responsible for making it well known)

as far as cat-girls though, i'm afraid egyptian priests beat anime to that... although their version was probably a little less approachable, being a goddess and all...
X-Kalibur
QUOTE (knasser)
QUOTE (Big D @ Aug 27 2007, 05:00 AM)
Actually, the first thing that comes to my mind when thinking of "brains in a jar" is Futurama.  Crossing this with the Equinox thread, can you imagine, 5,000 years in the future, a band of heros stumbling across and having to put up with Harlequin's head in a jar?


"Oh, I_______, ain't got no_ body! Doo be do!"

Abbey somebody... Abbey... Normal.
Whipstitch
Are you saying that I put an abnormal brain into a seven and a half foot long, fifty-four inch wide GORILLA?!
Big D
And thus, the first CZ was created...

"Wasn't your hump on the other side?"
Large Mike
"No it wasn't. Now walk this way."
Big D
...

Bzzzt. "What hump?"
Crusher Bob
QUOTE (Fortune)
The question was what original thing has Anime contributed to fiction. wink.gif

Actually the idea of a robot with a pilot (as opposed to a self motivating robot) appears to be original to anime. (Mazinger Z, by Go Nagai)
Ol' Scratch
QUOTE (Crusher Bob)
Actually the idea of a robot with a pilot (as opposed to a self motivating robot) appears to be original to anime. (Mazinger Z, by Go Nagai)

Guess you never saw or read War of the Worlds, huh?. Only thing anime did was give 'em a name.
Crusher Bob
The Martian Tripods were not anthropomorphic. The previous anthro robots (The Iron Man, The Day the Earth Stood Still, Giant Robo, etc) were all self motivated.
Ol' Scratch
Perhaps you should be more clear in your posts, then. You said nothing about androids (robots != androids), let alone anthropomorphics.

And for the record, Iron Man was created in 1963 and proved to be far more popular than anything anime had to offer at the time. Mazinger Z wasn't around until the 70's.
hobgoblin
what seems to be a trend lately is that the "mecha" has a mind of its own, but is subservient to the pilot, that connects into the mecha in a kind of symbiosis. the mind is often not expected to be sentient, but is "awakened" by strong emotions from the pilot.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012