Jason Farlander
Feb 8 2004, 01:46 AM
Shadow:
Check out SR3, right before the section where they have a member of each race talking about being that particular race. I cant give you an exact page number (I dont have my books with me right now), but I read it quite recently. If I get access to my books before you post again agreeing with me, I'll get those page numbers and quotes to ya.
Fortune
Feb 8 2004, 02:30 AM
QUOTE (moosegod) |
Any human can change into anything. It's less and less common that metatypes are having children of another type, but it still occurs. SR3 says as much. |
No. Orcs and trolls (and associated variants) are the only metahumans who can goblinize. Elves and dwarves are born as elves and dwarves. This has always been the case in Shadowrun canon. I don't know what version of SR3 you have, but if you disagree could you please provide a quote to back up your assertation that humans can and do goblinize into elves and dwarves?
Fortune
Feb 8 2004, 02:33 AM
Shadow: Jason is right on this one. Although it is exceedingly rare, it is possible for metahumans to have children of a totally different race.
Wu Jen
Feb 8 2004, 05:53 AM
Well that's new then. Old SR2 stuff only orks and trolls goblinized. No dwarf's or elves goblinized they are born that way.
Elf - born
Dwarf - born
Ork - born or gob
Troll - born or gob
Elves and dwarf can be born from human parents but mostly from a mix of human elf/dwarf.
Never heard of a human giving birth to a ork or troll. Imagine the birthing difficulties. They usually give birth to a human that will goblinize though.
Just the old stuff talking here dont know about comet or new stuff.
Fortune
Feb 8 2004, 06:33 AM
QUOTE (Wu Jen) |
Well that's new then. Old SR2 stuff only orks and trolls goblinized. No dwarf's or elves goblinized they are born that way.
Elf - born Dwarf - born Ork - born or gob Troll - born or gob |
What's new? That is exactly what I said above.
QUOTE |
Elves and dwarf can be born from human parents but mostly from a mix of human elf/dwarf.
Never heard of a human giving birth to a ork or troll. Imagine the birthing difficulties. They usually give birth to a human that will goblinize though. |
Ever heard of C-sections?
QUOTE |
Just the old stuff talking here dont know about comet or new stuff. |
None of this is from YotC or what-have-you. It is all detailed in the BBB, and even older books.
Jason Farlander
Feb 8 2004, 08:04 PM
Check out SR3, pg 47, under the "can we have babies together?" heading.
Furthermore, note that "Goblinization" is listed as a 10 point SURGE effect in YoTC. I don't know about the rest of you, but that makes it seem, to me, as if Goblinization was particularly rare even during the peak of SURGE , and not something that happens with any significant frequency otherwise.
If anyone knows of any canon references to Goblinization occuring outside of the original Goblinization wave in 2021 (and a few years thereafter) and the SURGE wave in 2061, I'd like to hear them.
moosegod
Feb 8 2004, 09:09 PM
I apologize. I mis-remembered.
Glyph
Feb 8 2004, 11:26 PM
There's a problem with explaining ork and troll mental penalties as being due to racism or poor living conditions. An ork or troll growing up in a loving family with an excellent education still has those mental penalties. The only explanation that makes sense to me it the biomedical one - more testosterone, shorter time before puberty, slightly different brain chemistry, etc. And you can still use the Bonus Attribute Edge to make an ork or troll with high mental Attributes. I often make those kind of characters, to have an "atypical" ork or troll.
I also have a problem with any Edge that negates ork or troll mental penalties. The problem is that orks and trolls already have net Attribute bonuses of +3 and +4, respectively. Without the Attribute penalties, those become + 5 and + 9! To be honest, if I am making an ork street sam, he is already likelier to have a 4+ Charisma than the human is, simply because he has 33 points that I can allocate instead of 30. An ork or troll with no Attribute penalties would be overpowered - I could see allowing such an Edge, if the ork or troll had to pay for such improved mental Attributes by accepting lower physical Attribute bonuses.
Siege
Feb 8 2004, 11:33 PM
You mean like "Exceptional Attribute?"

Humor aside, Glyph's point is a good one -- a character should not be permitted to dispense with a race's drawbacks with a single Edge that outweighs the return.
I.E. a +2 Edge that negates some 7 points of bonus attributes.
-Siege
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please
click here.