However it doesn't say the entire meal has to be the required diet, only that "Critters with this weakness have to include something strange or exotic in their diets."
Except for a daily dose now being the default, I read that as the same "depends on the critter" as in the 4th BBB. It was only in RC (or maybe RW) that the exact requirements for Infected were specified. Run Fasta! didn't say anything on the matter, so as usual I'd supplement uncertainties with old rules
There are just so many things Run Faster does not cover that it should. But we will keep it on here rather than go into my shapeshifter rant. Except for a daily dose now being the default, I read that as the same "depends on the critter" as in the 4th BBB. It was only in RC (or maybe RW) that the exact requirements for Infected were specified. Run Fasta! didn't say anything on the matter, so as usual I'd supplement uncertainties with old rules
It is a good point that we don't know what the exact amount required is, but if you only need one meal of it to survive it would not be unreasonable to assume that the meal should largely be made up of the required element.
RAI vs RAW I know, mea culpa.....
Plus MijRaj also pointed out on the other forum that even if it IS one meal made up of the required element, with daily consumption being 2-4 lbs for an average human that one meal out of the total that has to be metahuman is just under a third of that, allowing that 2-4 lbs probably counts for 3 meals a day plus limited snacking.
So assuming 2lbs of various meats and ghoul caps in total to keep body and tainted soul together, it would only require just under 0.67 lbs of metahuman a day to meet the requirement with the rest being filled in other meats.
Compare this to the older editions 1% per week requirement, with a 180lb ghoul needing 1.8lbs of metahuman over the week.
Which gives us a requirement of about 0.26 lbs a day on average so there is not actually as great a difference between the two values as it might initially appear.
QUOTE
And no matter what the actual percentage of body weight is, it should be calculated from the "natural" weight of the meat. AFAIK meat does not significantly lose calories when drying it, and whatever those mysterious aura traces which ghouls require are, they are probably not some homeopathic "water memory"
Yes, let's not discuss 'water memory' as that raises disturbing questions that the water gurus never seem to like trying to answer.
Looking back I have to agree Jerky should be treated as concentrated magic goodness for figuring how much a ghould needs to eat.
So if a ghoul had a 0.67lb daily requirement from my math above that would equal 0.23lbs of troll jerky (assuming 65% weight loss through drying) to make it through the day.
QUOTE
Interesting point: Since the Dietary Requirement is magical, is it influenced by how "unnatural" something is, similar to how Object Resistance affects other magic? In other words, is there a difference between troll jerky prepared by a hermit in the woods according to a secret process passed down the family since the dawn of time, and freeze-dried troll in a vacuum pack (Best before 2575. Warranty void in case of metaplanar invasion or if exposed to more than two nuclear exchanges)?
Dunno, depends on the "water memory" of what water is left after you open it.
Just kidding
Freeze drying and Vac Bagging the meat should certainly keep the meat pretty much intact for a good long time.
How this might reflect in the trace essence with the meat? No idea, but we can give Patrick Goodman some more nightmares by asking.
*just has to check to see how far out the restraining order is for now and which copcorp is enforcing it this week*
I think since the bit the ghouls need is sort of 'magical', even if really on the low end of the mana spectrum, at my table I would allow it but still call a 1 month (lunar cycle) limit on it for fulfilling the dietary requirement.
So they could eat it afterwards as it is still raw meat, but it would lack that special something after the one month mark and thus leave you with a grumbling need for something fresher just for some sort of limit on it and semi-mystical associations.
I want to give ghouls options, not a way to completely circumnavigate their conditional needs.
Having a ghoul sitting on a bunker full of FrostyBobsPacks™ so that they do not have to hunt metahumans or not even make special arrangements for someone else to round up the eats for them for the next 5 years really doesn't sit well with me and makes it just that much harder to sell the idea to others.