/social commentary on
White male youth might like emulating black male youth, but it is a social construct that does not last a lifetime. Now the same could be said for orc poser, that some stupid elf is rebelling and therefore spends a few years trying to look like an orc. But, still any real orcs the poser meets will want to beat the crap out of them.. to me at least. Also, currently in the US, the black population might be mainly lower economically, that is far different than alot of the hate that is directed at the muslim community currently. White/christian-->black is alot more socially acceptable than white/christian--->muslim/arab. Which is where i think elf-->orc is.
/social commentary off
The only saving grace i see the troll having right now is that he will get his hits in. the elf will hit him and get more successes, but will not knock the troll out, so the troll will at least get a chance to deal damage. And reach of 1, really is nothing... maybe every point of reach gives you 2 dice, because in a fight between 2 equally skill fighters 3 att and 3 skill, a sword should make a hell of a difference. now it will only come up 1 out of every 3 fights.
Still need to play with the game more before any final determination.
I will only say, 40 points for being a troll.. from a min/max standpoint to have any kind of effective shadowrunning character.. well don't bother. *because it can be better done elsewhere and cheaper*