Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Priority vs. Points
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3
Kagetenshi
QUOTE (Chodav)
What's the average starting age of most million-nuyen characters? Where did the money come from? Who did they sell their soul to? How many enemies do they have? Why are they living in a rundown tenement when they could have afforded so much more?

Some people take the time to think up answers to these questions, but how many munchkins have you met who took the million and acted like it was nothing unusual?

It varies. There are a lot of answers. There are a lot of REASONABLE answers.
Plus, if you're running the Shadows because you want to make a difference, and I hand you a million nuyen, you're either going to spend that on stuff to help you run or you weren't really intent on making a difference in the first place.

QUOTE
Exact specifics of where the money comes from aside, I stand by my assertion that anyone with a million nuyen has no reason to accept a job shaking up a Barrens gang for 10,000 and all the BTL's they can carry away from the smoking ruin of the gang's headquarters . . .


But they don't have a million nuyen. They have a million nuyen worth of stuff. If most of that stuff is inside their body, it isn't going to keep them from starving when their actual cash reserve starts running low. Nor will it buy them a fake ID when the Star starts looking for them.

~J
Fortune
You'll note that the category is called 'Resources', and not 'Nuyen'.

The character may never have seen even a tenth of that million ¥, but might have been paid in cyber, or acquired things in other nefarious ways. The category also includes Contacts, which really have nothing to do with money, but are a very important resource.

I'll agree that most people that have 1,000,000¥ in their hand at any one time would probably not pursue a shadowrunning carreer (but some still would), but that is not the way the Resource category works.
Chodav
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
Plus, if you're running the Shadows because you want to make a difference, and I hand you a million nuyen, you're either going to spend that on stuff to help you run or you weren't really intent on making a difference in the first place.

If most of that stuff is inside their body . . .

True - someone with heroic urges might take the million and run (pun intended). That's a reasonable explanation, which is what I was suggesting many million-nuyen characters don't have. (From a factory and spray-painted in flesh tones - now that was funny!)

If most of that stuff is inside their body, how did it get there? Who paid? Again, it's a background issue. I'm not saying that million-nuyen characters are ridiculous so much as the munchkins who often play them are.

Now, contacts . . . Oh, my, think of how many you could buy with a million . . .
RedmondLarry
Contacts ..... my first Face character listed Contacts as "one of each". Yes, he started with high resources.
Azryl
The same argument could be said of taking 50 skill points, its a rare 20 year old that's world class in anything. Its all in the background. I personally make my characters a little older to make room for the years of experience that helped them gain the skill knowledge, the million nuyen, or whatever.
Ol' Scratch
QUOTE (Chodav)
Exact specifics of where the money comes from aside, I stand by my assertion that anyone with a million nuyen has no reason to accept a job shaking up a Barrens gang for 10,000 and all the BTL's they can carry away from the smoking ruin of the gang's headquarters . . .

Even assuming a character with a million nuyen in Resources were a millionaire (and as others have pointed out, that simply isn't the case 99% of the time), the chance to earn a cool 10,000 nuyen plus the profit from the gods-only-know-how-many BTL chips for a few hours work is tempting.
Kagetenshi
Most munchkins just go with the stock "oh, he was a corporate assassin who vanished, paying a decker to delete all records of his existence."
Which isn't a bad example for maybe a handful of actual runners over the course of the Shadowrun world. It's once you start getting the numbers of these into the hundreds from all the munchy players out there that it gets silly.

~J
RedmondLarry
After the first handful disappeared, the corp made another handful and sent them after the first handful. They disappeared too. And so on. wink.gif
Siege
QUOTE (Doctor Funkenstein)
QUOTE (Chodav @ Dec 2 2003, 07:36 PM)
Exact specifics of where the money comes from aside, I stand by my assertion that anyone with a million nuyen has no reason to accept a job shaking up a Barrens gang for 10,000 and all the BTL's they can carry away from the smoking ruin of the gang's headquarters . . .

Even assuming a character with a million nuyen in Resources were a millionaire (and as others have pointed out, that simply isn't the case 99% of the time), the chance to earn a cool 10,000 nuyen plus the profit from the gods-only-know-how-many BTL chips for a few hours work is tempting.

It's a little less tempting when you realize all it takes is one lucky burst to ruin your day, maybe your week if it's APDS. grinbig.gif

-Siege
Kagetenshi
If you're an experienced runner and they're really a gang, it's free money. If they have APDS, you go back to the J and demand medical costs plus additional compensation because no basic gangbusting run should involve APDS rounds.

~J
Siege
QUOTE (Kagetenshi @ Dec 3 2003, 02:11 AM)
If you're an experienced runner and they're really a gang, it's free money. If they have APDS, you go back to the J and demand medical costs plus additional compensation because no basic gangbusting run should involve APDS rounds.

~J

True, true -- there's always gonna be that one silly little fragger with a full mag that he inherited from his brother on his deathbed just in case. grinbig.gif

He's got that one Ingram labeled "Just in case", ingraved in gold and silver with custom grips and that slightly hinky smartlink that doesn't work unless ya bang it just so...

-Siege

Edit: If you have thousands of corporate assassins disappearing into the shadows, I suspect low-rent thugs will be investing in "anti-corporate assassin" magical items. grinbig.gif
6thDragon
In the campaigns I find myself in, players often take the million nuyen with little to no explanation. I've played two characters with the one million nuyen option. My backgrounds:
1. Former Urban Brawler who was expelled from the league for fixing games for the Yakuza. sleepy.gif
2. Former Witness Protection specialist who gave a few of them up for the money. Now he has a big hunted flaw, but lots of cyber. cyber.gif
Chodav
QUOTE (Azryl)
I personally make my characters a little older to make room for the years of experience . . .

I personally do the same - I think the youngest of all the ones I've made was 25.

Sorry, Azryl, I didn't mean to hijack your thread and take it into "explain the money" country. I'm kind of surprised that of all the things I said in my post about the point-based system, that's the only one that generated comment. You'd think that someone would have jumped my case for saying I hate trolls and they would cost 12 in my campaign . . .
Kagetenshi
You stated that you hated trolls. You didn't say you hated trolls and they had no reason to exist, or you hated trolls and thought they were unbalanced, or you hated trolls and everyone who plays trolls is a munchkin. You merely made a statement of opinion. What were we going to say? You lie! You really love trolls and think everyone should be one!
My characters vary in age, but are typically in their late 20s.

~J
Azryl
Ok i'll jump on your case smile.gif nothing beats a troll with double digit body and stregth, dikoted kantana, and wire reflexes 3 biggrin.gif
Fortune
QUOTE (Azryl @ Dec 3 2003, 01:41 PM)
...nothing beats a troll with double digit body and stregth, dikoted kantana, and wire reflexes 3

Sure there is! A troll with double digit body and strength, dikoted claymore, and wired reflexes 3. biggrin.gif
Kagetenshi
Dikoted telephone pole. You get another point or two of Reach that way.

~J
Ol' Scratch
Pfft. Troll + Ranger-X Bow = No Chance To Survive.
Chodav
QUOTE (Azryl)
Ok i'll jump on your case smile.gif nothing beats a troll with double digit body and stregth, dikoted kantana, and wire reflexes 3 biggrin.gif

I hate players like you . . . wink.gif
Kagetenshi
Psht. A troll with a ranger-X only deals about as much damage as an assault cannon, only starts at M, and doesn't have the 2.4 km range.

~J
Tanka
QUOTE (Chodav @ Dec 2 2003, 08:36 PM)
True, but anyone who can accumulate a million nuyen over a relatively short period of time has no need to run the shadows with the rest of us...

Not true. They got it somewhere, whether it be by needing the edge, so they saved up/stole it/earned it somehow. They might've gotten it from a chop-shop they hit recently, or they might've gotten it as a present from their chummers. Just because you start with 1,000,000 nuyen.gif does not mean the character has had a total of 1,000,000 nuyen.gif in possession throughout his entire life.

You do know the average amount of money it takes to raise one child from birth to 18 is approximately $1,000,000? Do you have that much in stuff? No! It's used on food, clothing, life needs, and other things like toys. The average includes gifts given to the child.

What makes a 'runner so different? That must also mean a Full Mage with Sorcery 6 (Which is pretty damn good) shouldn't be on the streets, because he could obviously be teaching at MIT&T.

Oh, and, who says they saved up the 1,000,000 nuyen.gif straight? It comes in bits and pieces, then goes in chunks for lifestyle, living expenses, and SOTA.

Edit: Same Troll, but with a Dikoted No-dachi. biggrin.gif
Glyph
I think there are lots of runners who got their 'ware from a corporation or organized crime organization. I do think the old "They think he's dead/they're hunting him" thing gets old. There are plenty of good reasons they could be running the shadows, though. Maybe, like the former company man archetype, they realized what they were doing, got disgusted with it, and quit - but with no money and no prospects for legitimate work, they do what they used to do, only now they do it so they can retire and get out of the business altogether. Maybe they were former employees who were let go after a screw-up, or after they were made a scapegoat, or after the stresses of the job burned them out.

The company doesn't have to hunt down every single last employee! But I imagine that cybered corporate types have a high risk of burn-out, or screwing up and being fired, and so on, and the company probably chews people up and spits them out. They would arrive in the shadows with most of their money being withheld by the company to pay for their 'ware, with few options available to them other than running.

And remember that the company has economies of scale and cyber-facilities and personnel that they are paying whether they use them or not - the character is not as big of an "investment" to them, although they probably do screen the candidates thoroughly, and get a good number of years of hard use out of them before tossing them to the curb. I'm mentioning this because a lot of people seem to think that anyone with a lot of cyberware has to be either hunted by his/her former employer, or owned by his/her benefactors.

With mages, it's even easier to justify, since spellpoints, like contacts, are an abstract form of resources, and foci could easily be spoils of war or a gift from their mentor.
Ol' Scratch
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
Psht. A troll with a ranger-X only deals about as much damage as an assault cannon, only starts at M, and doesn't have the 2.4 km range.

Not true at all. Regular dikoted tipped-arrows on a troll with a not-even-twinked-out Strength of 15 (Strength 9 + Bonus Attribute + Muscle Augmentation 4) do 20S damage alone. Heaven forbid the troll is an adept, which is most likely the case if they're using a bow. And the range is quite formidable, too.
Kagetenshi
But Dikote quickly makes the PAC the more cost-effective option, unless the GM houserules that you can batch-coat the arrows.

~J
Dende
I'm sorry did you say Not twinked Str of 15...

Lets see...I could forgive the 9...possibly even 10, but 15...please. Unless you aren't assuming starting char...Unless you are talking 50+ karma into the game...anything above a 10 is just wrong. Hell even then a 10 is "best in the world...world renouned" abillity. Sure you could through in cyberware and extra adept boosts...But honestly... in a normal game why try to do that if you aren't twinking?
Ol' Scratch
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
But Dikote quickly makes the PAC the more cost-effective option, unless the GM houserules that you can batch-coat the arrows.

~J

Dikoting doesn't do much for a PAC; it's already at Deadly damage. At most, it gets +1 Power. Whooptido.

The Ranger is also silent and SA if memory serves.
Fortune
QUOTE (Dende)
I'm sorry did you say Not twinked Str of 15...

This is a troll we're talking about. Doesn't seem that twinked to me, and can easily be done with a character straight out of chargen.
Fortune
QUOTE (Doctor Funkenstein)
Dikoting doesn't do much for a PAC; it's already at Deadly damage.  At most, it gets +1 Power.  Whooptido.

I believe that he's saying if you add Dikote™ to your arrows, that makes the cost of the PAC seem reasonable in comparison. I don't think he meant to actually use Dikote™ on the PAC or it ammunition.
Kagetenshi
Fortune has it right.

~J
Ol' Scratch
Oops, sorry. For some reason I completely missed the "cost-effective" part. <smacks self> Even without Dikote, the Ranger is a superior weapon for a runner, mostly because it's far more legal, stealthy, and rapid fire. I'd rather do two stealthy 19M base wounds than one booming 18D base one that tells everyone within fifty city blocks exactly where I am. smile.gif
Tanka
So use Silence! biggrin.gif
Zolhex
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
Psht. A troll with a ranger-X only deals about as much damage as an assault cannon, only starts at M

Unless you dikote the arrows biggrin.gif Also to add insult to injury try this one:

A Resourses, 1,000,000, muscle aug./toner 4, suprathyroid + what ever else you want.

B Adept, improved ability projectile 4-6, improved attribute str. 1-3

C Troll, nuff said!

D Attributes, cha. 1=3, intell. 1=3, quick. 1=2, str. 6=2, body 6=1, will. 3=3, 7 points left. Ok so this makes the stero typical slow, dumb, & ugly troll who cares. "Yo sludge kill it" "Ok you da boss"!

E Skills, Projectile weapons 6 pulled bows 7 then add some stealth, etiquette, unarmed combat, car?, negotiations? what ever does not matter it's a troll killing machine.
Tanka
Looks like one of my Nameless Trolls!

I had way too many of those... Way too many...
Fortune
QUOTE (Doctor Funkenstein)
...and rapid fire. I'd rather do two stealthy 19M base wounds than one booming 18D base one that tells everyone within fifty city blocks exactly where I am.

Don't you need to use a 'Ready Weapon' action whenever you use a bow? Wouldn't that make the rates-of-fire relatively similar?
Ol' Scratch
Like I said, it was likely an adept who was weilding it. Namely, an adept with Quick-Draw.
Cain
Back to the resources question: Look, let's take a starting decker who's built his own deck, and coded his own programs. He could easily have the equivalent of a million nuyen in hardware, but he's never come anywhere near that much cash.

Take a rigger who's got a level 2 or 3 contact with a vehicle facility. His backstory is that he built and designed his drones from scratch, salvaging parts from a junkyard. One or two maxed-out vehicles can easily be equal to a million nyuen; but the character never actually had a million in cash.
Fortune
QUOTE (Doctor Funkenstein)
Like I said, it was likely an adept who was weilding it. Namely, an adept with Quick-Draw.

Fair enough.

Does the Quick Draw Edge actually double a bow's rat-of-fire for an Adept according to canon?
Kagetenshi
Quick-draw removes the ready weapon action necessary, so it's arguable that you could continually quick-draw. I'm not sure I'd allow it, but it's canon.

As for the bow being stealthy, it doesn't need to be stealthy when you have a 2+ kilometer head start smile.gif

~J
Glyph
I don't see any problem with using Quick Draw that way. Keep in mind that they do have to make a Quickness test each time (usually not that difficult). But if you couldn't use Quick Draw that way, there wouldn't be much point to taking it.
Lilt
Jeesus... This thread sprung-up over night.

My 2000000.02 nuyen.gif :

It's possible to create characters worth 135 BPs using the priorities system.

Wether that's imbalanced or not depends on wether or not you think the points system charges the right amount for magic.

You could just as easily say that the points system is imbalanced as it makes sammies, riggers, and deckers more powerful. The priorities system, after all, is the base character creation system from the book.

I think you should just let the players use the system they want. If they want to use the priorities system while the standard you are using is a high-point point-based then allow them to take some free edges or something
Lilt
Oh yes, and my additions to the troll discussions: Trolls are probably just as well using No-Dachis as they are Katanas. The +1 TN mod they get for wielding a 2 handed weapon single-handedly is more than cancelled by the increased reach from the no-dachi (-1 tn to you and +1 tn to opponents).

The other factor is the power of the attacks. Assuming you're Dikoting both weapons; The No-Dachi does Str+2D while the katana does Str+4S. While I think we can agree that any (not-toll melee bunny) metahuman in combat with a trollish melee bunny would die, an armoured vehicle is another matter. It boils down to the fact that a katana can hurt a vehicle with 1 more point of armour (9 points of armour for a good strength troll) compared to the No-Dachi's (8 points for the same troll).
Zazen
QUOTE (Lilt)
The +1 TN mod they get for wielding a 2 handed weapon single-handedly is more than cancelled by the increased reach from the no-dachi (-1 tn to you and +1 tn to opponents).

Note that reach provides a TN bonus OR a penalty to your opponent, not both at the same time!
Kurukami
I thought you could split the total up any way you wanted? Not to mention that trolls have a natural reach of 1, and the no-dachi grants (I think) 2, making a troll combat monster armed in that manner particularly icky.
Lilt
Ah. Ok. I was getting this confused with friends in melee (where both the majority gets a plus and the minority gets a minus).
nezumi
Don't forget ladies and gents, for melee and I believe bows you default to strength. If your strength is greater than 11 or 12, its to your advantage to default. I think I said this in another thread, I got a troll to 28 strength straight out of chargen, the only rule broken was I allowed cultured bioware (and I think I can eliminate that without losing strength). That means 28 dice on my 28S shot and I can still use a smart link : )
Kagetenshi
Cultured bioware at chargen is not breaking a rule.
How'd you do this again?

~J
Lilt
Impressive... I must remember that. You get on average 5 successes (same as a skill 6 character would without pool) but it actually scales slightly better as you add the first +5 of TN mods. It does, however become impossible (by the defaulting rules) to shoot something if you have a +6 mod. (That's why you aim...)
Azryl
I have to say that is very impressive, nezumi.
gknoy
QUOTE (Chodav)
True, but anyone who can accumulate a million nuyen over a relatively short period of time has no need to run the shadows with the rest of us.

It's not necessarily that they accumulated a million Nu and then went on a shopping spree. In the case of a sammie archetype, or whatnot, perhaps they started out as a merc, and got their first Smartlink installed, and maybe a set of spurs... then after a few missions, they were feeling outclassed by their older comrades, and used their bonus to get some vision augs (say, retinal mods) ... Later on, after a particularly nasty ambush that he and his team barely survived, our merc said, "you know, gotta get me some Wired Reflexes to keep up...", and got a loan from the unit to pay for it (taken out of his next year's paycheck ...).

As you can see, they've been paying for their wares with blood and sweat -- upgrading their cyber in order to keep up with the SOTA, so to speak, of their martial life. They probably have never had more than 10,000 nuyen in the bank at any given time, even. Their contacts might be old merc buddies, and their weapons might be unit surplus -- e.g., after he's left the unit to go solo, the unit decides to upgrade all their AK-98's to Ares Alphas, and offers him a good deal on some of the older arms.

That's always how I've seen the Resources. (Not that I've ever wanted to take the Mil, lol - heck, as a mundane human I usually have trouble spending 90k, since I don't want wired and MBW up the wazoo smile.gif)

Just my two cents =D
Sphynx
QUOTE (nezumi)
Don't forget ladies and gents, for melee and I believe bows you default to strength. If your strength is greater than 11 or 12, its to your advantage to default. I think I said this in another thread, I got a troll to 28 strength straight out of chargen, the only rule broken was I allowed cultured bioware (and I think I can eliminate that without losing strength). That means 28 dice on my 28S shot and I can still use a smart link : )

I can tell you from experience that defaulting (for bows at least) to that many dice is definitely not 'better off' than a good skill. For 1, no dice pool. Also, that +4 is HUGE, even with a smartlink (which most GMs will only allow for the RangeFinder bonus) unless your target is standing perfectly still, arms spread wide open in close range (which is actually quite far with a Str 28).

Maybe we just play a bit more difficult of a game, but the 'average' TN for us is 6 to 8 before adjusting for a smartlink. That's a base TN of 10 to 12 for 'defaulting to attribute' and will garnish about 2 to 4 successes total.

Neither person moving, short range, no light modifiers, I couldn't see it being better, 28 dice with a TN of 4 (base) -2 (SmartLink), +4 (Defaulting) = 6, that's still only 4 successes.

Think I'll stick to skill which only requires about 27 karma to get (a specialization) to 12 (or 18 as an Adept), add in combat pool, and not suffer a +4 TN for defaulting, and keep that 28 strength. nyahnyah.gif

Sphynx
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012