QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 11 2010, 10:23 AM)
I disagree. Most totems also have an emotional core - vanity with Cat, stubborn loyalty with Dog, tough love with Bear, aloof arrogance with Eagle.
-- Passions are similar to Mentor Spirits but more powerful, as a single Passion controls the purvue of multiple mentors. Passions can also grant what I guess would map to adept powers to their followers.
QUOTE
Also, totems used to grant magic before SR4 screwed things up. Not as the only way there is to magic, but as one way. Furthermore, there are the more abstract Idols of Europe (which are basically states of mind/emotions the mind then builds an Avatar for). While agreeably not the same, Totems work quite along the same line as Passions did - enough to give someone an idea of what a Passion roughly is.
-- Yup, they fit in easily with the Shadowrun 4e design space either as mentor spirits/paragons being aspects of them, or as meta-mentors (with a higher BP cost and more "goodies" attached).
-- That of course doesn't explain why they are so hush-hush in Shadowrun ... OMG NINJA ELF ASSASSINS AT THE DOOR BRB
QUOTE
Given that Passions seem like extra powerful spirits, there might be a way. Not strictly by canon, though, only by extrapolation (especially with dragons, who are half spirit in nature anyway).
-- I don't see it happening. Noone became a Passion in Earthdawn that I'm aware of, and there were a LOT of magical beasties and people back then (hell, almost everyone was an Adept at least, in Shadowrun terms).
-- Ascending to become a more generalized guardian spirit sure. It's arguable that the mentor spirits are really external things at all though.