Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Whatever Happened to Captain Chaos?
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
Tachi
QUOTE (LurkerOutThere @ Jun 9 2010, 09:42 AM) *
If you go back you will see I mentioned nothing about wanting magic out of SR, I gave examples of modern and scifi stories but you also can't tell anything about mystical mystery or discovery because the answers are already known, as long as SR is chained to ED the big story is always going to be: the horrors come back everything that can't hide dies or the horrors get beat back.

Honestly the best thing for the game line would be to have the horror's come back in the next couple years a major conflict comes of it and ultimately the horrors are pushed back to their portals and a large WMD is flushed into said portal ending the threat forever, then SR storytelling can move forward.


I can see your point, but having that 'Sword of Damocles' hanging there seems to give my games a bit of tension that I like. Even with it being pushed back by the events after Dunk's suicide, it makes me feel like the entire drama of the Sixth World is like a massive live-fire exercise/brutal proving ground for the real action to come... eventually. And I like it. But that's just in my game. As we all know YMMV.
Draco18s
QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 9 2010, 03:45 PM) *
I can see your point, but having that 'Sword of Damocles' hanging there seems to give my games a bit of tension that I like. Even with it being pushed back by the events after Dunk's suicide, it makes me feel like the entire drama of the Sixth World is like a massive live-fire exercise/brutal proving ground for the real action to come... eventually. And I like it. But that's just in my game. As we all know YMMV.


Or even that all you do is in vain, because in the end we're all doomed anyway.

Or that your actions are actually hastening that doom, whether you know it or not.

It's like the biggest foreshadowing ever (and even though we know something's going to happen, we don't know what or when).
sabs
I wonder why the dragons decided not to warn meta-humanity this time.

They warned meta-humanity in the 4th World (Earthdawn) so why not now?
Did Thera leave such a bad taste in their mouth that they decided this time around they're not going to help. Perhaps that's Lung vs D's big argument.

Abstruse
QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 9 2010, 02:45 PM) *
I can see your point, but having that 'Sword of Damocles' hanging there seems to give my games a bit of tension that I like. Even with it being pushed back by the events after Dunk's suicide, it makes me feel like the entire drama of the Sixth World is like a massive live-fire exercise/brutal proving ground for the real action to come... eventually. And I like it. But that's just in my game. As we all know YMMV.

I also like being able to let a little Lovecraftian nightmare slip through from time to time to harass my players.

Also, props for the Dresden reference.
Matsci
QUOTE (Udoshi @ Jun 8 2010, 11:23 AM) *
Did the writers actually do anything with that, aside from that one story piece in the core book? Game, set, match i think it was?


From Corp Guide

QUOTE
> And technos can find them, sometimes. BTW, thanks Netcat.
> Kia

> Just remember that when I need a babysitter.
> Netcat

> Hey, did I just hear Slamm-0! faint? wink.gif
> Pistons


QUOTE
> fed53384 localtime_u (ffbf57ec, fedc2DEUS86c, 3, 7efefeff, 849200, ff00) + 14 f2d845c __1cKCRspoolMsPAINLOSSRIPBRAINgF-spool6M_v_ (884fd8, 885064, fDffEffUffSf, 20, 852590, 885024) + 44 Ƒl_wNOSAVEMYBABYNOSAVEMYBABYek<EGj^D_ďjyڃ*__[_1__˙8=_gjbb3A]3q_U
> Netcat

> Netcat, if you cant keep your techno morning sickness out of my files, Im locking your account.
> FastJack

> Sorry. It comes on fast. Ill log in AR from now on.
> Netcat

> FastJack, could you leave this one in the file? Its a fascinating specimen of the effects of pregnancy on technomancers.
> Butch
Matsci
Whoh....

Double Post
hobgoblin
ah, butch is a street doc, figures.
Udoshi
Matski - haha. Thanks, man.
ravensmuse
Aw, how adorable wink.gif
Bull
All I know is, Slamm-O! shouldn't ask Bull to babysit. The fact that Bull's own kids (well, most of them, sort of) made it past their teen years is something of a miracle.

Bull
Draco18s
QUOTE (sabs @ Jun 9 2010, 04:04 PM) *
I wonder why the dragons decided not to warn meta-humanity this time.


Because its not coming for a good thousand years or more.

And they have, in a way. "No Blood Magic" is basically a way of saying that blood magic is bad, blood magic being one of those things that hastens the arrival of the horrors.
hermit
QUOTE
I do not see why I am required to play another game to get elements that are represented as part of the game setting.

Just ot be clear: You are perfectly allowed to cut out magic, the Horrors, or anything of SR in your private game (much like I do with several PC options). But if you want to take the core of the metaplot out and lobby for it to be done canonically? play something else.

And, as has been pointed out, the Horrors were around in adventures that came out before anyone ever wrote the header for the first proposal for EarthDawn (Other than Harlekin, too, like Bottled Demon). Tir Tairngire as a place where Immortal Elves run the show was around immediatly. Invae were the topic of the very first short in the very first fiction book published for SR.

ED was decided to be the 4th world during it's initial development, and it was written to include 4th world legacy stuff that already existed in SR at that point. If anything, SR forced the Horrors, Invae, Immortal Elves and Dragons of Awesome onto ED. NOT vice versa.

This is an integral part of the setting metaplot. Don'T like it? Ignore it, cut it from your own personal canon. As stated, many do, myself included. Just don't claim it is all somehow the fault of tying Shadowrun to Earthdawn in some hack job. Because that's just wrong.
Aristotle
I have about 95% of Shadowrun from 1e on, and this thread is both making me want to reread ALL of it as well as run a bunch of it again too. Dangit.

And as far as I'm concerned that excerpt from Untethered Life is exactly how things went down in my Shadowrun.
Hagga
QUOTE (Draco18s @ Jun 10 2010, 01:31 AM) *
Because its not coming for a good thousand years or more.

And they have, in a way. "No Blood Magic" is basically a way of saying that blood magic is bad, blood magic being one of those things that hastens the arrival of the horrors.

I can't decide if the black great eastern running Aztech is nuts or corrupted.
Abstruse
QUOTE (Aristotle @ Jun 9 2010, 06:46 PM) *
I have about 95% of Shadowrun from 1e on, and this thread is both making me want to reread ALL of it as well as run a bunch of it again too. Dangit.

Let me know if you do 4e conversions of the early adventures. I'm starting on some of them, but it'd be nice to pool efforts.
Draco18s
QUOTE (Hagga @ Jun 9 2010, 08:26 PM) *
I can't decide if the black great eastern running Aztech is nuts or corrupted.


Maybe a little of both.
Grinder
QUOTE (Matsci @ Jun 10 2010, 12:02 AM) *
> FastJack, could you leave this one in the file? Its a fascinating specimen of the effects of pregnancy on technomancers.
> Butch


We need a puke emoticon. What a waste of wordcount. ohplease.gif
Lansdren
QUOTE (Grinder @ Jun 10 2010, 01:54 PM) *
We need a puke emoticon. What a waste of wordcount. ohplease.gif


Opinions will vary.


I thought it was a funny comment and not a waste. In my mind it gives abit more personality to it.
hermit
I wondered why there is none a long time back. It's such a staple emote.

And I also agree. The whole netcat/Slamm-o LURVE story gets a tad too much coverage. This is novel stuff, so it might just want to get it's novel.
Grinder
QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 10 2010, 03:01 PM) *
And I also agree. The whole netcat/Slamm-o LURVE story gets a tad too much coverage. This is novel stuff, so it might just want to get it's novel.


Yep, both characters have become an annoyance all too sudden.
otakusensei
QUOTE (Grinder @ Jun 10 2010, 09:10 AM) *
Yep, both characters have become an annoyance all too sudden.

I find them to be a happy little diversion and an element of humanity in a gritty setting.
LurkerOutThere
QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 10 2010, 07:01 AM) *
I wondered why there is none a long time back. It's such a staple emote.

And I also agree. The whole netcat/Slamm-o LURVE story gets a tad too much coverage. This is novel stuff, so it might just want to get it's novel.


On this we agree.
Hagga
QUOTE (Draco18s @ Jun 10 2010, 01:31 AM) *
Because its not coming for a good thousand years or more.

And they have, in a way. "No Blood Magic" is basically a way of saying that blood magic is bad, blood magic being one of those things that hastens the arrival of the horrors.

3500 or so. I remember seeing a figure stating 7000 years in an older book. Or was that 2500? And blood magic just helps to raise the general mana level, which closes the abyss that lets them through. Or possibly acts as a locator beacon for them to make a blind leap, I've read both. (In bad SR fiction. But I repeat myself.)
Draco18s
QUOTE (Hagga @ Jun 10 2010, 08:59 AM) *
3500 or so. I remember seeing a figure stating 7000 years in an older book. Or was that 2500? And blood magic just helps to raise the general mana level, which closes the abyss that lets them through. Or possibly acts as a locator beacon for them to make a blind leap, I've read both. (In bad SR fiction. But I repeat myself.)


A longcount is about 5000 years, so 2500.

And my understanding is that blood magic builds a bridge from this side to the other. It doesn't raise the mana level in general or really sorta go "HEY GUYS!" but it does make it easier for the jump to happen.
sabs
This explains EarthDawn where blood magic was rampant. Everyone used it.
Dr.Rockso
QUOTE (otakusensei @ Jun 10 2010, 09:48 AM) *
I find them to be a happy little diversion and an element of humanity in a gritty setting.

I dunno, I predict a tragic ending to the pregnancy thing. A bit disconcerting that she's projecting PAINLOSSRIPBRAIN and NOSAVEMYBABYNOSAVEMYBABY into the matrix without much control.
Ancient History
If you want pain, remember that elven pregnancies last something like 50 weeks - she's preggers for a year.
graywulfe
QUOTE (otakusensei @ Jun 10 2010, 08:48 AM) *
I find them to be a happy little diversion and an element of humanity in a gritty setting.


I agree whole-heartedly. Frankly, aside from Game, set match, the total word count of their recent hijinks totals less than half a page across all the current books. That's really not a lot of material, and as far as I'm concerned completely appropriate material at that.

Graywulfe
shadd4d
QUOTE (Dr.Rockso @ Jun 8 2010, 04:18 PM) *
As far as I know Netcat is worried as well. No one seems to know. Will likely get resolved in an upcoming book.


Personally, I hope its resolution is as follows (what follows is pure speculation): we get a dead letter document from Puck outlining what happened to Pax and her group. It might be too much to ask, but I'd like to see it in a Threats-type book, akin to the first Threats book. Something that takes the ideas of magical threats or the dissonance and puts a group and a face to a concept.

Don
hobgoblin
heh, i wonder if the message will be that pax is very much alive, and living a queens life in geneva.
hermit
Yes, she must be. As a Techno, she is just too much made of win to be stoped in any way. I wonder why noone drops a shitload of scrambler RFID onto Geneva and goes in exterminating everyone with a headache with extreme prejudice.
Tachi
QUOTE (Abstruse @ Jun 9 2010, 03:04 PM) *
I also like being able to let a little Lovecraftian nightmare slip through from time to time to harass my players.

Ohhh... Eldritch... wink.gif

QUOTE
Also, props for the Dresden reference.

I assume you're refering to the Dresden Files? I've never actually read those books, so, I'm not sure what reference you're refering to... But, I'll take the props anyway and just figure I was a genius while I wasn't looking. biggrin.gif
Abstruse
QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 10 2010, 10:27 PM) *
I assume you're refering to the Dresden Files? I've never actually read those books, so, I'm not sure what reference you're refering to... But, I'll take the props anyway and just figure I was a genius while I wasn't looking. biggrin.gif

I thought 'Sword of Damocles' was Doom of Damocles which is a final probation of a wizard in the Dresden universe. I was also drunk when I mixed it up nyahnyah.gif

And if you're a Shadowrun fan, check out the Dresden novels. Book 1 is good, Book 2 is better, Book 3 will blow your mind. One of the cover quotes on the newest book describes them as "Buffy the Vampire Slayer starring Phillip Marlowe"...best example ever.
Tachi
QUOTE (Abstruse @ Jun 10 2010, 10:48 PM) *
I thought 'Sword of Damocles' was Doom of Damocles which is a final probation of a wizard in the Dresden universe. I was also drunk when I mixed it up

Check out my Sig. After the fifth -or so- time I posted here for six hours straight completely shitfaced, I decided I'd beter start warning people. Now, when the regulars see the first word underlined, they usually tune me out... Which amuses me to no end and encourages me to be absurd. spin.gif (Not drunk yet tonight, but working on it, 151 is my friend.)

QUOTE
And if you're a Shadowrun fan, check out the Dresden novels. Book 1 is good, Book 2 is better, Book 3 will blow your mind. One of the cover quotes on the newest book describes them as "Buffy the Vampire Slayer starring Phillip Marlowe"...best example ever.

I'm not a fan of Buffy, but I just may do that. Cheers.
Abstruse
QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 10 2010, 11:05 PM) *
Check out my Sig. After the fifth -or so- time I posted here for six hours straight completely shitfaced, I decided I'd beter start warning people. Now, when the regulars see the first word underlined, they usually tune me out... Which amuses me to no end and encourages me to be absurd. spin.gif (Not drunk yet tonight, but working on it, 151 is my friend.)

I'm not a fan of Buffy, but I just may do that. Cheers.

The "Buffy" reference is more because it's contemporary fantasy. If you like Shadowrun, you'll like the Dresden books.

And honestly, I tend to be more coherent in writing when I'm on my second vodka...
Lansdren
I will also suggest the dresden stuff for additional reading material.


My mage once described himself to a NaN Shaman as being from the Dresden school of Boom




I'm easily influenced
Tzeentch
QUOTE (Abstruse @ Jun 8 2010, 07:54 PM) *
That was one of my favorite things from the Tir Tairnegire book where someone mentions the Passions and Laughing Man basically starts ROFLing over the fact that the guy, pretty much repeating something weird he overheard randomly, signed his own death warrant for speaking about it in public.

-- Ugh that was a perfect example of Harlequin playing the "HUR HUR SEKRETZ" game.

Tir Tairngire, p. 69 (one of the rare references to Passions in Shadowrun)
QUOTE
>>>>>[These shamans do not follow animal forms, or even symbolic personifications. They follow form. They follow truth. They follow Passion.]<<<<<
- Walker (09:48:40/4-10-54)

>>>>>[hehehhheeeehhheeeeehhheeee ehehe hee heeheh hehehe hhehehehe . Walker, I suspect you are a walking dead man. I'll send flowers.]<<<<<<
- The Laughing Man (08:39:36/4-11-54)


-- My 4e rules-fu is shaky, but Passions would seem to be rather easy to create as a magical tradition (hmm, might have to break down and get the new Earthdawn edition ...)
Lansdren
For the uninformed can I have a explination on the passions please
hermit
Gods. Totems that can manifest (and do occasionally, and then they die). Ascended mortals, maybe. Weird shit.

Vernya may be one. Spider of the Secrets of Power was one. Harlequin may qualify eventually, too, having his own metaplane already. Same with Dunkelzahn.

I agree, they might make nice traditions. But they worked morelike a Paragon anyone can use in ED. Of course, all ED characters were awakened by default.
Lansdren
QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 11 2010, 10:48 AM) *
Gods. Totems that can manifest (and do occasionally, and then they die). Ascended mortals, maybe. Weird shit.

Vernya may be one. Spider of the Secrets of Power was one. Harlequin may qualify eventually, too, having his own metaplane already. Same with Dunkelzahn.

I agree, they might make nice traditions. But they worked morelike a Paragon anyone can use in ED. Of course, all ED characters were awakened by default.



Interesting,

Could be a fun way of stopping the horrors for a few mins if we raise up Harlequin to godling and send him off to fight and give him that big battle to the death kind of ending
hermit
QUOTE
Could be a fun way of stopping the horrors for a few mins

Yeah. A couple passions in a country called Vasgothia thought so once. Turns out they almost succeeded - but only almost. They're all dead now.

If anything would rise to passion level, though, it needs reverance. Dunkelzahn is perfectly set up to be a passion.

Oh, Thayla might have been a near-passion too (and is also dead). However, since her name is still known, unlike the vasgothian passions' names which turned to mystical clues and garblespeak that turns you mad when attempting to read, she might not have been a full blown passion yet.

Actually, since it came up once ... maybe Dunkelzahn, in time, will become a kind of Horror Ward passion.
Tzeentch
QUOTE (hermit @ Jun 11 2010, 09:48 AM) *
Gods. Totems that can manifest. Ascended mortals, maybe. Weird shit.

-- They were a bit more abstract than that in Earthdawn. They are incarnations of basic emotions and ideas (Totems of Love, Vengeance, Skill, etc. I suppose) who supposedly granted the gift of magic to Name-givers (sapient races).
-- Mechanically they would operate (somewhat amusingly IMO) sort of like a massively powerful free spirit who can maintain a crapload of spirit packs with their quaestors (beings who follow their mandates). Each one has quirky little abilities they can bestow.
QUOTE
Vernya may be one. Spider of the Secrets of Power was one. Harlequin may qualify eventually, too, having his own metaplane already. Same with Dunkelzahn.

-- Passions were primordial things. I don't recall that there was any way to ascend to their level. They existed outside of the normal spirit organization, but were not immune to the warping influence of the Horrors (hence the three "Mad Passions").

-- The reason for their suppression in Shadowrun might have to do with A) Horror-taint, B) Hidden source of power (dubious is canon), or C) Metahuman emotions are so uncontrolled the Passions are dangerous to contact.
hermit
QUOTE
They were a bit more abstract than that in Earthdawn. They are incarnations of basic emotions and ideas (Totems of Love, Vengeance, Skill, etc. I suppose) who supposedly granted the gift of magic to Name-givers (sapient races).

I disagree. Most totems also have an emotional core - vanity with Cat, stubborn loyalty with Dog, tough love with Bear, aloof arrogance with Eagle. Also, totems used to grant magic before SR4 screwed things up. Not as the only way there is to magic, but as one way. Furthermore, there are the more abstract Idols of Europe (which are basically states of mind/emotions the mind then builds an Avatar for). While agreeably not the same, Totems work quite along the same line as Passions did - enough to give someone an idea of what a Passion roughly is.

QUOTE
Mechanically they would operate (somewhat amusingly IMO) sort of like a massively powerful free spirit who can maintain a crapload of spirit packs with their quaestors (beings who follow their mandates). Each one has quirky little abilities they can bestow.

Huh. THAT meshes very well with SR4's Paragons.

QUOTE
Passions were primordial things. I don't recall that there was any way to ascend to their level. They existed outside of the normal spirit organization, but were not immune to the warping influence of the Horrors (hence the three "Mad Passions").

Given that Passions seem like extra powerful spirits, there might be a way. Not strictly by canon, though, only by extrapolation (especially with dragons, who are half spirit in nature anyway).
Sengir
QUOTE (Ancient History @ Jun 10 2010, 02:47 PM) *
If you want pain, remember that elven pregnancies last something like 50 weeks - she's preggers for a year.

A clever bit of evolution - the year-long pregnancy prepares the prospective father for having to deal with a decade-long puberty biggrin.gif
Draco18s
QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 11 2010, 12:05 AM) *
Check out my Sig. After the fifth -or so- time I posted here for six hours straight completely shitfaced, I decided I'd beter start warning people. Now, when the regulars see the first word underlined, they usually tune me out... Which amuses me to no end and encourages me to be absurd. spin.gif (Not drunk yet tonight, but working on it, 151 is my friend.)


Curiously, your post about the Sword of Damocles isn't underlined (I checked).

QUOTE (Tachi @ Jun 9 2010, 03:45 PM) *
I can see your point, but having that 'Sword of Damocles' hanging there seems to give my games a bit of tension that I like. Even with it being pushed back by the events after Dunk's suicide, it makes me feel like the entire drama of the Sixth World is like a massive live-fire exercise/brutal proving ground for the real action to come... eventually. And I like it. But that's just in my game. As we all know YMMV.

Dwight
QUOTE (graywulfe @ Jun 9 2010, 02:12 PM) *
You have put everything I love about the IE's and GD's in this game in the best words I've seen.


... and everything I loath about them. I don't play RPGs to be furniture and backdrop to GMPCs doing r33t shit.
otakusensei
QUOTE (Dwight @ Jun 11 2010, 10:50 AM) *
... and everything I loath about them. I don't play RPGs to be furniture and backdrop to GMPCs doing r33t shit.

If you have a GM that has Ghostwalker and Harlequin following the players around or calling then up to go to go on a beer run for them, you might want to have a talk with him.
hermit
QUOTE
... and everything I loath about them. I don't play RPGs to be furniture and backdrop to GMPCs doing r33t shit.

Then don't?
Brazilian_Shinobi
While I do Like Harlequin, I would have prefered that all the "Immortal Elves" were not Immortal, they were only powerful enough to cas a spell on themselves and put themselves to sleep JUST like the Dragons did. And not like Highlanders who spent the next few millenia waiting for Magic come up again and learned (and taught?) all the cool tricks humanity developed during the low time.
LurkerOutThere
QUOTE (Brazilian_Shinobi @ Jun 11 2010, 11:33 AM) *
While I do Like Harlequin, I would have prefered that all the "Immortal Elves" were not Immortal, they were only powerful enough to cas a spell on themselves and put themselves to sleep JUST like the Dragons did. And not like Highlanders who spent the next few millenia waiting for Magic come up again and learned (and taught?) all the cool tricks humanity developed during the low time.


Pretty much this, immortal characters that secretly run the world and were present at all major events is a silly plot to build a ten minutes into the future world with as it tends to blot over many other things.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012