Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Do SR characters PAY for things?
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
Thorguild
Character generation gets you a character decked out in the equipment you purchased. But once you've done that and formed a group, why do characters pay for things afterwards? (BTW I only own the SR4 book and Street Magic. This may be dealt with in other books.)

Let's say that you don't mess where you sleep: you pay for your Lifestyle with the cleanest nuyen you have access to. Nobody wants a midnight raid. Beyond that, you need gear. Comlinks, weapons, software, vehicles, clothing, etc.

The team Face and Hacker sit down one night over beer and Thai food and start making notes. They decide that once every 4 months they will make a "shopping trip" Run for the team. The goals are: #1 - Minimum risk. #2 - No, really - MINIMUM RISK! #3 Not paying for much.

Almost everything can be delivered to your door in 2070. Amazon.com has been replaced by the billion other Amazon.com's.

The Face goes to an office building and negotiates with the owner to rent an unused space near the docking bay for a week. He's disguised, of course, with a disposable ID, and has a good story about being an out-of-town salesperson who needs a meeting room and will set up some props delivered from his home office. When he's in he has a professional cleaning service come in and give the entry way to the office a thorough sprucing up. IKEA instant reception area and some generic TAGs with logos on the walls. Total cost: 1000 nuyen. (GM says "Ha! 3000!" Players grumble.) Total cost: 3000 nuyen.

Meanwhile the Hacker does some research. A Fulfillment Center is a giant warehouse that has an amazing system of robotics inside. The purpose of this marvel is to rapidly put boxes full of stuff onto waiting trucks. These trucks then take all the boxes and deliver them to ADHD customers who want everything delivered before they ordered it. It's a moderately tough hack, but not more difficult than a hardened research facility. It takes a little doing, and includes having the face bribing an OSHA official to "borrow" his ID while he takes a look inside. The Hacker pours over the data gathered on the "safety inspection", and gets a nice overview of the model of robot he needs to hack.

A tech has been hired, or conscripted from within the team. He builds a Faraday cage in the back room of the office and gets a TAG eraser handy.

On the second day the Face shows up at the office and prepares the entry way with danishes and fresh flowers, and name TAGS for a bunch of people who will never actually arrive. This is the most dangerous assignment of the Run.

The Hacker hacks. 86,000 nuyen of equipment is boxed and labeled for immediate delivery. It's going to the team's office. The Hacker makes the system think it's a load of fancy paper totaling 250 nuyen.

In 2070 "immediate delivery" means immediate. A truck is ID'd as going near this location and the boxes are automatically loaded by robot onto it. The delivery truck courteously and constantly informs the "customer" of its location as it nears the building, and the Face is ready when it arrives. He waves his ID and invoice number at the delivery bot/guy and authorizes the 250 payment, and a nice tip. "Just set it over there", he says, waving a hand at an empty corner. He's busy, after all. The delivery guy/bot leaves; he's busy too.

The Face hand-trucks the stuff into the Faraday cage and TAG erases everything. The off-site Hacker has been using some surveillance drones to case the area. Are there cops? If yes, a disposable comlink outside the Faraday cage beeps "Way Down Upon The Swanee River" and the Face books it. If no, the comlink plays elevator muzik.

When he's done making the TAG's safe he hand-trucks the stuff to a waiting delivery van he rented ("RENT me by the HOUR!") the night before. The Hacker tells the van to drive, slow and steady, and sends one of his drones after it. The Face gets some industrial Lysol/solvent spray and hoses down everything in the small office. It takes 10 minutes and the smell doesn't have time to escape the doors out into the rest of the building. He consults his comlink checklist to get everything he was supposed to bring, and drops the disposable comlink into a small glass of acid. It'll be gone by the time he's a block away.

The Face leaves and walks or drives away while the Hacker's other drone scans for tails. After ensuring that the Face is safe, it leaves and follows the rented delivery van.

The delivery van goes to an industrial park and drives around for a few minutes to let the second drone catch up, and both drones take a last look for anyone tailing the van. When safe, the van stops and the rest of the team transfers the stuff to their own vehicles. Lastly, they clean the van.

The van drives back to the rental place. The team and the Face drive back to base. Everyone enjoys their radically-discounted items.

This was fun to write! Certainly things could go wrong on this Run, but is there anything structurally wrong about the plan? What keeps teams from doing this all the time? Maybe they need to spoof records for the licenses afterwards, and file off serial numbers.

I suppose the GM could handwave and say that all Fulfillment Centers are hardened better than anything else the players will ever encounter, but that seems a bit mean.

Thorguild




Yerameyahu
I assume it's the same reason they do anything: they're medium fish, not big fish. They can't afford to annoy people constantly, and if the rules appear to allow various 'zero-risk' options (super-facing, traceless hacking, whatever), that's just a shortcoming of the rules to describe the game world.
almost normal
Shadowrun is about being a deniable asset. You're a tool. If you're good, no one knows about you. If you're *really* good, the rich and powerful types know about you and want to use your services. It's stated in several places that if a corp gets hit by runners, they're not as concerned with the runners as they are the hiring agent. Part of what keeps you safe is not acting on your own accord.

When you start pulling things like the above, you're acting on your own interests. There is no other agent to go after. When you become enough of a pain in the ass, you're eliminated in the most nuyen efficient manner possible.
Speed Wraith
You could do a lot of spoofing and get a lot for free, especially spoofing a lifestyle. But large-scale fraud is going to be noticed, and probably pretty quickly once just one daily inventory notices a funny discrepancy in the weights of products on the shelves and counts of units. You could pull a trick like this to get a single shipment of something and then head for the hills, but it wouldn't go unnoticed long-term.

Besides, anything worth buying isn't going to be found at Amazon. You're going to need to call up your guy on the docks and find out when he can smuggle you that case of APDS wink.gif
Pendaric
In a word, convenience. One, who wants to work all the time? Two, "50% of the human race are middle men and don't take kindly to being cut out."
Fatum
The most obvious issue with the plan is this: most stuff runners want is F, and they're not sending F-rated stuff over mail delivery. Even R-rated stuff may require the actual buyer showing up and providing the license, if you're buying it legally.
Otherwise, Unwired has the rules for "hacking a lifestyle" - that is, hacking enough delivery vehicles, orders etc to get yourself a nice cozy lifestyle; which is essentially what you can do with the setup described.
ShadowDragon8685
It's not a bad idea, just don't drek where you eat. You probably want to do this only rarely (try once quarterly,) preferably not in the same city you live in.


As for getting the attention of big boys: If there's no evidence, there's no evidence. Can't hunt down people you can't find and don't even know the identities of. But if you screw the pooch, this kind of shenanigan will get someone after you.


As regards being able to buy only unrestricted items freely: This is true. However, you can always barter; find high-value, portable stuff that you don't need a license for that's going to sell well in the Shadows. For instance: Rating 6 Response modules for commlinks cost 8,000 nuyen.gif and are Availability 16... And just 16. Not R, not F. Signal units are 3,000 nuyen.gif an the same Availability.

So spoof your way into taking possession of a shitload of Fairlight Calibans with Rating 6 Response and Signal unit upgrades; while you're at it, get Common Use, System, and Firewall upgrades at Rating 6 as well.

Each one of them, without any Restricted or Forbidden gear (IE, completely and totally legal) will be worth 29,200 nuyen.gif if you were paying for it legit. Each will be Response, System, Signal, and Firewall 6, and have Analyze, Browse, Command, Edit, Encrypt, and Reality Filter pre-loaded at Rating 6.

And they're all also going to be small and portable, and you can easily spoof the warehouse into giving you the stuff. You'll be able to easily hock those in the Shadows for 8,760 nuyen.gif each (more if you're willing to take more time, emphasizing the fact that they are all clean,) money with which you can buy new stuff - or trade straight across. For instance, I imagine that the Ancients would probably be very willing to make trade in kind if you're offering boxes of Rating 6 commlinks that just need some IC for them to equip the troops.
Thorguild
QUOTE (Pendaric @ Aug 29 2012, 10:44 AM) *
In a word, convenience. One, who wants to work all the time? Two, "50% of the human race are middle men and don't take kindly to being cut out."


Not sure I follow you there on point one. You are doing 3 days of work and getting gear to last you for several months. That's the real reason most people get into crime: they are lazy. They think it'll be easier than working for the money.

As to point two: Sure, no one likes being stolen from. I'm just not sure how they CAN prevent a scam like this. In fact, it's happened in real life. During the real estate bust of the early 90's office rental business was bad. Owners were giving five year leases with the first six months free. They also gave bonuses to the renters so that they could make improvements to the offices. And not small bonuses either. Sometimes they showed up on the 7th month to collect rent to find empty offices.

Oops.

Most real crime and criminals get busted because they get stupid or lazy.

Thorguild
almost normal
QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 29 2012, 12:12 PM) *
As for getting the attention of big boys: If there's no evidence, there's no evidence. Can't hunt down people you can't find and don't even know the identities of.


There's always evidence. It's whether or not the cost of a technomancer's resonance search plus the cost of the hit squad will equal the amount of money the company expects to lose again.
Mäx
QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 29 2012, 07:12 PM) *
As for getting the attention of big boys: If there's no evidence, there's no evidence. Can't hunt down people you can't find and don't even know the identities of.

The problem is that the matrix never ever forgets anything.
Speed Wraith
QUOTE (Mäx @ Aug 29 2012, 12:10 PM) *
The problem is that the matrix never ever forgets anything.


Even when it does, a Resonance Realm search can help it remember...
TeknoDragon
Nice idea... up until someone glitches a roll.
Fatum
Only dead men glitch.
Warlordtheft
Sometimes a glitch just happens. That being said, the problem here is that you run into someone figuring out who you are and tracing it back to you. Would they care to spend resources on 2K nuyen's worth of merchandise. Probably not. But you start getting into the 10K+ range there will be an investigation--which may lead to a bad end.
Fatum
Mathematically speaking, glitching on a pool of six dice is rather improbable, glitching on a pool of eight or more is all but impossible in its unlikeness.

Oh, and sure if you get non-subtle about it, you're getting caught. That's why I think it's better to represent the benefits available to an enterprising runner with Hacking the Lifestyle, instead of devoting separate runs to it.
ShadowDragon8685
QUOTE (Warlordtheft @ Aug 29 2012, 04:05 PM) *
Sometimes a glitch just happens. That being said, the problem here is that you run into someone figuring out who you are and tracing it back to you. Would they care to spend resources on 2,000K nuyen's worth of merchandise. Probably not. But you start getting into the 10K+ range there will be an investigation--which may lead to a bad end.


Investigation, yes.

Spending a hundred grand to hire a technomancer to bullshit whatever data might possibly link those runners out of the digital aether?

Only if you make a habit of ripping off one particular company.
_Pax._
QUOTE (Thorguild @ Aug 29 2012, 10:46 AM) *
The Face goes to an office building and negotiates with the owner to rent an unused space near the docking bay for a week. He's disguised, of course, with a disposable ID, and has a good story about being an out-of-town salesperson who needs a meeting room and will set up some props delivered from his home office. When he's in he has a professional cleaning service come in and give the entry way to the office a thorough sprucing up. IKEA instant reception area and some generic TAGs with logos on the walls. Total cost: 1000 nuyen. (GM says "Ha! 3000!" Players grumble.) Total cost: 3000 nuyen.

Something to keep in mind: assuming this is an office building that even dos such short-term rentals, you can also be absolutely sure that there are cameras watching the loading bay, and the corridors - because as sure as the sun rises in the east, the building owner provides general security.

Further, even 3K nuyen is lowballing the price of this. I wouldn't dare try that with less than an R2 or R3 Fake SIN, and that's 2K to 3K right there. And a fake ID is not something you're going to be stealing ... nor is it at all easy to make one yourself. Not impossible, but not easy either.

QUOTE
Meanwhile the Hacker does some research. A Fulfillment Center is a giant warehouse that has an amazing system of robotics inside. The purpose of this marvel is to rapidly put boxes full of stuff onto waiting trucks. These trucks then take all the boxes and deliver them to ADHD customers who want everything delivered before they ordered it. It's a moderately tough hack, but not more difficult than a hardened research facility. It takes a little doing, and includes having the face bribing an OSHA official to "borrow" his ID while he takes a look inside. The Hacker pours over the data gathered on the "safety inspection", and gets a nice overview of the model of robot he needs to hack.

It's a hack that is going to leave evidence it was done. That's absolutely unavoidable; until the delivery is complete, you can't erase the access logs that make the delivery even be attempted. And by the time the delivery has happened, those access logs have certainly been backed up to at least a dozen places.

It's also a much harder hack, I think, than you are expecting. I mean, seriously, you think those fulfillment centers have never been hacked before? You think they haven't decided to raise the bar significantly, on future hackers?

Oh, and that OSHA bribe? You're asking someone to be left swinging in the wind for your theft, and possibly face revocation of his SIN. That bribe, therefor, is not going to be cheap.

QUOTE
Faraday cage

Faraday cage: 100 nuyen.gif per cubic meter. Let's assume this "back room" is, oh, 4m by 5m by 3m. Sixty cubic meters, or, 6,000 nuyen.gif

QUOTE
The Hacker hacks. 86,000 nuyen of equipment is boxed and labeled for immediate delivery. It's going to the team's office. The Hacker makes the system think it's a load of fancy paper totaling 250 nuyen.

Full stop. If the system "thinks it's fancy paper", and you make that happen before the order is boxed and trucked? Then what you get will BE fancy paper. And even when it's on teh truck, even when the truck is en route ... internal error-checking routines may say "oops we boxed the wrong stuff, don't deliver those boxes ... and promptly box up some fancy paper, and put it on a truck all by it's lonesome to get it delivered within the promised window.

Which would rather be a problem for you, wouldn't it?

QUOTE
In 2070 "immediate delivery" means immediate. A truck is ID'd as going near this location and the boxes are automatically loaded by robot onto it. The delivery truck courteously and constantly informs the "customer" of its location as it nears the building, and the Face is ready when it arrives. He waves his ID and invoice number at the delivery bot/guy and authorizes the 250 payment, and a nice tip. "Just set it over there", he says, waving a hand at an empty corner. He's busy, after all. The delivery guy/bot leaves; he's busy too.

This is part of why the Fake SIN needs to be R3 or R4. The delivery drone is going to want a bimetric signature - a thumbprint, say - and is going to check against the fake SIN. It may only be an R2 or R3 scanner, but even so, if you try to cheap out with an R1 SIN, you stand too great a chance of being caught.

And if you get caught, it WILL still make the delivery - while sending out a Panic Button alert to local law enforcement.

QUOTE
The Face hand-trucks the stuff into the Faraday cage and TAG erases everything. When he's done making the TAG's safe he hand-trucks the stuff to a waiting delivery van he rented ("RENT me by the HOUR!") the night before.

Except the security RFIDs embedded under the mailing labels, and/or inside ten or fifteen of every box's 200+ styrofoam packing peanuts, are flat out immune to Tag Erasers.

The rental truck means another check against that fake SIN he's using - probably with a higher rating than the delivery drone, too. Not to mention, a hefty deposit (probably 10% the cost of the vehicle, maybe more), and of course, the rental fee. Oh, and more data trail toworry about. Meanwhile, this loading is on the cameras int eh hallway, and in the docking bay. Someone from teh building's security contractor might wonder why the same boxes are going right back OUT, within minutes of having been delivered - and they remember the delivery because they had to clear the drone to enter the site in the first place.

There may also be physical eyes on all of this, in the form of workers in or around the loading dock. Who might also wonder who gets X delivered, then immediately loads it onto a cheap by-the-hour rental truck.

QUOTE
The van drives back to the rental place. The team and the Face drive back to base. Everyone enjoys their radically-discounted items.

... and noone shows up to collect the deposit? OOPS.

And here's the fun part: you forgot to wipe the rental truck's node. It has an exact GPS record of everywhere it went - and it's whole route, and who ordered it to follow that route.

The rental van's AccessID was recorded by the loading dock security node(s) at the office building. You never spoofed it, changed it, or otherwise gimmicked it. So when the delivery company tracks down that a very expensive order was delivered to that building - and that is never a question of "if", it's only a question of "when" - they will know that the peson who signed for it (with a now determined to be forged SIN) loaded it onto that truck. They go to the rental agency, and get the truck's route records for that hour. Now they know where you made the transfer to the team's own vehicle.

Worse: they have camera records of the entire team, most of whom you did not specify were disguised. And the team's vehicle(s), with their AccessIDs (hope you paid to install spoof chips and morphing license plates!!). They can then go to the city, and possibly track your team's subsequent movements, at least some of them, via the city's traffic-monitoring network.

...

Once, yeah, I can see a team pulling this off. Twice, not so easily. Three or more times, and you're probably an"ongoing investigation" by some full detectives. Five or mroe times, and the local constabulary has probably convened a task force to catch you.

QUOTE
I suppose the GM could handwave and say that all Fulfillment Centers are hardened better than anything else the players will ever encounter, but that seems a bit mean.

Hardened at least as well as a local Bank office, for sure.

Honestly, if your hacker is able to pull this kind of stuff off, he might be better off just trying to forge certified credsticks, and using those to actually buy the desired gear.
Yerameyahu
QUOTE
Only if you make a habit of ripping off one particular company.
Isn't this exactly what they're talking about, though?
StealthSigma
QUOTE (Warlordtheft @ Aug 29 2012, 04:05 PM) *
Sometimes a glitch just happens. That being said, the problem here is that you run into someone figuring out who you are and tracing it back to you. Would they care to spend resources on 2,000K nuyen's worth of merchandise. Probably not. But you start getting into the 10K+ range there will be an investigation--which may lead to a bad end.


You have a dangling K at the end of your 2,000. As written you say they won't investigate 2,000,000 nuyen worth of merchandise but they will investigate 10,000 nuyen worth.
ShadowDragon8685
QUOTE (_Pax._ @ Aug 29 2012, 04:25 PM) *
Something to keep in mind: assuming this is an office building that even dos such short-term rentals, you can also be absolutely sure that there are cameras watching the loading bay, and the corridors - because as sure as the sun rises in the east, the building owner provides general security.


This just adds another hack, to make sure the building security records nothing untoward. Not that big a deal.

QUOTE
Further, even 3K nuyen is lowballing the price of this. I wouldn't dare try that with less than an R2 or R3 Fake SIN, and that's 2K to 3K right there. And a fake ID is not something you're going to be stealing ... nor is it at all easy to make one yourself. Not impossible, but not easy either.


This is Shadowrun. Making outlay to pull off a heist for profit is the name of the game.

QUOTE
It's a hack that is going to leave evidence it was done. That's absolutely unavoidable; until the delivery is complete, you can't erase the access logs that make the delivery even be attempted. And by the time the delivery has happened, those access logs have certainly been backed up to at least a dozen places.


This is a simple fix. While you have all this access to the delivery facility, insert a command in its backup structure that tells it to leave the bits where it says what you're sending to yourself out of the backed-up logs.

QUOTE
It's also a much harder hack, I think, than you are expecting. I mean, seriously, you think those fulfillment centers have never been hacked before? You think they haven't decided to raise the bar significantly, on future hackers?


Hard, yes, but they're not going to be rocking the Heavy Metal in those things. Like he said: if you can crack open black research facilities, you can crack a goddamned on-demand delivery distribution center.

QUOTE
Oh, and that OSHA bribe? You're asking someone to be left swinging in the wind for your theft, and possibly face revocation of his SIN. That bribe, therefor, is not going to be cheap.


Then forge the damn badge. Or blackmail the OSHA inspector. Mind control him into taking you along and introducing you as a trainee.


QUOTE
Faraday cage: 100 nuyen.gif per cubic meter. Let's assume this "back room" is, oh, 4m by 5m by 3m. Sixty cubic meters, or, 6,000 nuyen.gif


That makes no sense, since a faraday cage is just any volume which is enclosed by the wire mesh. You may be thinking of the surface area of a prism, which is 2ab + 2bc + 2ac. Let's say that a = 4, b = 5, and c =3.

You only need one hundred square meters of mesh to turn this room into a faraday cage. So only 1,000 nuyen.gif

ShadowDragon8685

QUOTE
Full stop. If the system "thinks it's fancy paper", and you make that happen before the order is boxed and trucked? Then what you get will BE fancy paper. And even when it's on the truck, even when the truck is en route ... internal error-checking routines may say "oops we boxed the wrong stuff, don't deliver those boxes ... and promptly box up some fancy paper, and put it on a truck all by it's lonesome to get it delivered within the promised window.


Dude, what are you not getting here? If they have this much hacked access, they can tell the computer that boxes A through Z contain fancy paper and any contradictory evidence is clearly a glitch in the system.

"Internal error-checking routines" can suck a hacker's e-peen every time. Drones have pissant brains, they're even easier to e-fuck than a facility will be.

QUOTE
Which would rather be a problem for you, wouldn't it?


No, because they're not idiots with a GM who will pull any shit out of his ass to smack down on their plans because he wants his heist game where his players don't go off the rails at all costs.


QUOTE
This is part of why the Fake SIN needs to be R3 or R4. The delivery drone is going to want a biometric signature - a thumbprint, say - and is going to check against the fake SIN. It may only be an R2 or R3 scanner, but even so, if you try to cheap out with an R1 SIN, you stand too great a chance of being caught.


Cheaping out on a fake SIN is a bad idea, I agree.

Much easier to use someone else's real SIN and arrange for your biometrics to match theirs.


QUOTE
And if you get caught, it WILL still make the delivery - while sending out a Panic Button alert to local law enforcement.


Too bad for it that that hacker is in mutual signal range of it and intercepts and kills that call.

QUOTE
Except the security RFIDs embedded under the mailing labels, and/or inside ten or fifteen of every box's 200+ styrofoam packing peanuts, are flat out immune to Tag Erasers.


Security RFIDs cost 100 nuyen.gif each. They're not packing them under goddamn mailing labels. Even if they are, this is still a relatively simple fix: Cart all this stuff into you your faraday room, wrap it all up in nice faraday wallpaper, repackage it all in innocuous containers, and haul it right back out again. Those little bastards can squeal their heads off all they want, they're shouting into the void. Then you take 'em home and crush the little bastards inside another faraday room.



QUOTE
The rental truck means another check against that fake SIN he's using - probably with a higher rating than the delivery drone, too. Not to mention, a hefty deposit (probably 10% the cost of the vehicle, maybe more), and of course, the rental fee. Oh, and more data trail to worry about. Meanwhile, this loading is on the cameras in the hallway, and in the docking bay. Someone from the building's security contractor might wonder why the same boxes are going right back OUT, within minutes of having been delivered - and they remember the delivery because they had to clear the drone to enter the site in the first place.


No they don't. It's not affecting them, it's not threatening the bottom line of their employer, it's not threatening the building's safety. You do not get proactive in shit like this unless one of those conditions is met. And that's assuming (big assumption) that this building has metahuman security staff, and enough to watch all of this.

Anyway, as I said above, it's easy enough to edit the feeds.

ShadowDragon8685

QUOTE
There may also be physical eyes on all of this, in the form of workers in or around the loading dock. Who might also wonder who gets X delivered, then immediately loads it onto a cheap by-the-hour rental truck.


Spreading around about 100 nuyen.gif a man will make sure they didn't see nuffink, honest.


QUOTE
... and noone shows up to collect the deposit? OOPS.


Generally speaking, after using a rented vehicle in criminal acts, you're going to want to skip the step where you go back to get your deposit.

QUOTE
And here's the fun part: you forgot to wipe the rental truck's node. It has an exact GPS record of everywhere it went - and it's whole route, and who ordered it to follow that route.


Presumably hackers remember to do that as par for the course. Even if not, though, the rental truck remembers driving around for a while and then parking in... An abandoned industrial park for a while. Big damn deal.

QUOTE
The rental van's AccessID was recorded by the loading dock security node(s) at the office building. You never spoofed it, changed it, or otherwise gimmicked it. So when the delivery company tracks down that a very expensive order was delivered to that building - and that is never a question of "if", it's only a question of "when" - they will know that the person who signed for it (with a now determined to be forged SIN) loaded it onto that truck. They go to the rental agency, and get the truck's route records for that hour. Now they know where you made the transfer to the team's own vehicle.

Worse: they have camera records of the entire team, most of whom you did not specify were disguised. And the team's vehicle(s), with their AccessIDs (hope you paid to install spoof chips and morphing license plates!!). They can then go to the city, and possibly track your team's subsequent movements, at least some of them, via the city's traffic-monitoring network.


You're grasping at straws, man. You're really, really grasping at straws. If you apply this level of protological scrutiny to your group's ordinary Runs, they've been busted by about the second run, haven't they?

But no, they haven't been. Because you don't. Because that's them following your Plot, not them going off the rails and deciding to make a quick buck for themselves. You Can't Have That; have to keep them starving for money so they'll be willing to do whatever Mr. Johnson tells them to do so they can grab at whatever scraps of nuyen he deigns to throw them. Because if they could do this, then you'd have to seriously up the financial reward for Mr. Johnson's runs to be remotely interesting to them.


QUOTE
Once, yeah, I can see a team pulling this off. Twice, not so easily. Three or more times, and you're probably an"ongoing investigation" by some full detectives. Five or more times, and the local constabulary has probably convened a task force to catch you.


That's why you:
(a) Don't do it more than once a quarter (so go BIG when you do),
(b) Don't do it in one city more than once every two years if you can help it,
© Don't do it to the same company more than once every two years if you can help it,
(d) Don't do it in the same national/megacorporate jurisdiction if you can help it.

Or did you forget that Shadowrun is, in fact, a splintered dystopia where jurisdictions don't want to share information? You could do it in Portland and a week later in Seattle and they'd never know about it.

QUOTE
Hardened at least as well as a local Bank office, for sure.


At most, they're rocking a Rating 4 Nexus and Gray IC; Black maybe, but only if it's an extraterritorial site.

The off-hacker in my group could do it.

QUOTE
Honestly, if your hacker is able to pull this kind of stuff off, he might be better off just trying to forge certified credsticks, and using those to actually buy the desired gear.


Remember what I said about not fucking with the same company too often?
The Zurich-Orbital Gemeinschaft Bank is one of those ones you really, really don't want to fuck with very often! They literally have an unlimited amount of money to track you down with, even if they have to print some.
Warlordtheft
QUOTE (StealthSigma @ Aug 29 2012, 04:46 PM) *
You have a dangling K at the end of your 2,000. As written you say they won't investigate 2,000,000 nuyen worth of merchandise but they will investigate 10,000 nuyen worth.

Fixed. smile.gif

_Pax._
QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 29 2012, 04:04 PM) *
This just adds another hack, to make sure the building security records nothing untoward. Not that big a deal.

This is Shadowrun. Making outlay to pull off a heist for profit is the name of the game.

This is a simple fix. While you have all this access to the delivery facility, insert a command in its backup structure that tells it to leave the bits where it says what you're sending to yourself out of the backed-up logs.

(a) More than one hack. Your neighbors might just have cameras watchign their own doors, too. And maybe the docks as well.

(b) My point was that the initially cited expense was too low. IOW, this particular heist entails a much higher outlay thanmerely 3K nuyen.gif .... by my estimates, probably loser to 15K or even 20K.


QUOTE
Hard, yes, but they're not going to be rocking the Heavy Metal in those things. Like he said: if you can crack open black research facilities, you can crack a goddamned on-demand delivery distribution center.

Then forge the damn badge. Or blackmail the OSHA inspector. Mind control him into taking you along and introducing you as a trainee.

That makes no sense, since a faraday cage is just any volume which is enclosed by the wire mesh. You may be thinking of the surface area of a prism, which is 2ab + 2bc + 2ac. Let's say that a = 4, b = 5, and c =3.

(a) Unlike "black research facilities", Fullfillment Centers are not averse to extensive record-keeping. In fact, if they err on the subject of logs, backups, and backups of the backups, they err on the side of more than needed. Which means it is much, much more likely that the access logs for a fullfillment center are backed-up off site, in an entirely separate computer network. And that the backups happen much more often - once or twice hourly, perhaps. Remember, that making a hack hard doesn't just entail driving the numbers upwards. It can also mean just making it so the hacker has to do more separate things, at all, to succeed (or have more specialised tools, like Corrupt to use on those access logs, so that backups aren't as big a problem).

(b) Forging a government ID? Riiiight, nwo you're talking a separate fake SIN, and if you dare go below R4 you're insane. Blackmailing an actual OSHA inspector, or mind-controllign him? Great, he's a loose end on two legs, now.

© Sense or not, that's ow the RAW treats it: it's priced per cubic meter.

QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 29 2012, 04:04 PM) *
Dude, what are you not getting here? If they have this much hacked access, they can tell the computer that boxes A through Z contain fancy paper and any contradictory evidence is clearly a glitch in the system.

"Internal error-checking routines" can suck a hacker's e-peen every time. Drones have pissant brains, they're even easier to e-fuck than a facility will be.

No, because they're not idiots with a GM who will pull any shit out of his ass to smack down on their plans because he wants his heist game where his players don't go off the rails at all costs.

(a) What you're not getting is that in order to fetch Item X from Shelf Y on Rack Z, the order has to specify that item, rack, and shelf. If the order says "fancy paper", then that's what you get. If the order says "fancy paper" in the text box, but has the right inventory control ID to get the items you REALLY want? Then "fancy paper" is a waste of an Edit roll, because the ICID is what matters.

(b) An agent working inventory control checks the manifest of what's going out, compared to the manifest of what's been ordered. If you somehow manage to get something onto the truck, whose ICID does not match what the system thinks is supposed to be on the truck? It doesn't take brains to figure ou there's a problem. Hell, even now, without AIs and agents and such, fulfillment centers track their products that well within the warehouse.

© Drop the personal attacks.

QUOTE
Too bad for it that that hacker is in mutual signal range of it and intercepts and kills that call.

Security RFIDs cost 100 nuyen.gif each. They're not packing them under goddamn mailing labels. Even if they are, this is still a relatively simple fix: Cart all this stuff into you your faraday room, wrap it all up in nice faraday wallpaper, repackage it all in innocuous containers, and haul it right back out again. Those little bastards can squeal their heads off all they want, they're shouting into the void. Then you take 'em home and crush the little bastards inside another faraday room.

No they don't. It's not affecting them, it's not threatening the bottom line of their employer, it's not threatening the building's safety. You do not get proactive in shit like this unless one of those conditions is met. And that's assuming (big assumption) that this building has metahuman security staff, and enough to watch all of this. Anyway, as I said above, it's easy enough to edit the feeds.

(a) The hacker has to actually, you know, hack into the drone for that; you can't just kill the call from outside. And unless you hack in before the SIN check, the first you'll know that there's a problem, is when the signal has already gone out. At which point, nice job closing the barn door after the horse has left.

(b) No, Security RFIDs do not cost 100 each. They cost 100 for a box of twenty - which means they cost only 5 nuyen each. For an order that's 86K nuyen.gif like the OP described, yes, they would happily use a double-handful of the things, and not even notice the expense.

© Putting a camera in the hall, to watch your own front door = part of your own in-office security system. Putting your own camera on the loading dock = making sure you get your deliveries with no "exploratory shrinkage". As for human staff - they don't have to be in the building, but even a "pure drone" security setup involves human oversight from SOMEwhere.

QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 29 2012, 04:05 PM) *
Spreading around about 100 nuyen.gif a man will make sure they didn't see nuffink, honest.

Generally speaking, after using a rented vehicle in criminal acts, you're going to want to skip the step where you go back to get your deposit.

Presumably hackers remember to do that as par for the course. Even if not, though, the rental truck remembers driving around for a while and then parking in... An abandoned industrial park for a while. Big damn deal.

(a) Says you. Me, I wouldn't be so certain of that. Some people are just too principled to take a bribe, no matter HOW good you smooth-talk them. It's just not in their character. So, there's always a risk. (Improving the plan would, IMO, simply involve re-boxing the goods, with an appropriate faked corporate logo on the boxes. But the OPs plan didn't specify that, so ... those eyes, electronic and organic alike, remain a problem.)

(b) Yes and no. Not collecting it might throw up more red flags. And regardless? There's another chunk of cash laid out for the heist, that isn't coming back. (Personally, I'd rather see the team have a vehicle with Chameleon Coating, morphing license plates, and spoof chips do the docking-bay pickup; cuts out one more bit of data trail).

© Not all hackers deal with drones and vehicles on a regular basis. Also, what occurs to me is, the truck may have been backing up it's route plan the whole time, right to it's actual owners. After all, if you only paid the in-city rental rates, then hop on the highway and go four towns over? The agency wants to know that you should be up-charged to the "in-state" rates, or whatever.

QUOTE
You're grasping at straws, man. You're really, really grasping at straws. If you apply this level of protological scrutiny to your group's ordinary Runs, they've been busted by about the second run, haven't they?

The OP asked. I answered. Better to assume the authorities are omniscient, and try to plan accordingly - than to assume they're idiots, and not bother planning much at all. The former will never give you a bad surprise; the latter, not so much.

QUOTE
But no, they haven't been.[...]

I told you once - stop the personal attacks. This is the second time I'm compelled to type this (even if it's the same post in the end). There won't be a third - I'll just go back and report each bloodypost to the moderators and be done with it.


Yerameyahu
"protological"? That was a new one on me, but the definition doesn't fit your use of it anyway. biggrin.gif
DireRadiant
QUOTE (_Pax._ @ Aug 29 2012, 03:50 PM) *
© Drop the personal attacks.

I told you once - stop the personal attacks. This is the second time I'm compelled to type this (even if it's the same post in the end). There won't be a third - I'll just go back and report each bloodypost to the moderators and be done with it.


Term of Service includes both Personal Attacks, and doing the jobs of the Mods as things that you shalt not do.

Just report using the report button please.

And to continue, the Mods review the entire thread and relevant posts before determining who gets Warnings. So it is quite possible for anyone doing Bad Things regardless of whether or not it is Reported to get a Warning.

Hida Tsuzua
Really this is just a reskin of the good old "why not just steal cars?" argument. For their skill level and capital investment, shadowrunners sell themselves short. They really could be making much better money* for equal or less risk than shadowrunning. Generally you can come up with reasons why shadowrunners don't do them, but that causes oddness such as white collar fraud or carkacking apparently being way more dangerous than breaking into highly secure facilities. This and other reasons is why I don't like "I'm just in it for the cash" motivations for shadowrunners.

*- In my experience payment is between 5000-15000Y per team member for a run. If you're way above this, this problem goes away, but it really needs to be in the 50000+Y to get out of this problem. A lot of GMs won't pay that much for a variety of reasons anyways.
LurkerOutThere
QUOTE (almost normal @ Aug 29 2012, 10:38 AM) *
There's always evidence. It's whether or not the cost of a technomancer's resonance search plus the cost of the hit squad will equal the amount of money the company expects to lose again.


There's a fair bit of stuff i absolutely abhor about the recent fluff. Trivilializing resonance realm data recovery is one of them, other then that carry on.
Yerameyahu
Yeah, Hida Tsuzua. This is also partially based on a 'the rules allow X' argument, though. Like I said, if the crunch fails to describe how we know the world works, that just means the crunch is wrong, though.
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (Fatum @ Aug 29 2012, 02:21 PM) *
Mathematically speaking, glitching on a pool of six dice is rather improbable, glitching on a pool of eight or more is all but impossible in its unlikeness.

Oh, and sure if you get non-subtle about it, you're getting caught. That's why I think it's better to represent the benefits available to an enterprising runner with Hacking the Lifestyle, instead of devoting separate runs to it.


I Have seen Glitches on 12 Dice, 14 Dice, 15 Dice, and even a Critical Glitch on 18 Dice. They do happen, even if they are rare. They are NOT all but Impossible, especially in our group. smile.gif
_Pax._
QUOTE (DireRadiant @ Aug 29 2012, 05:43 PM) *
Term of Service includes both Personal Attacks, and doing the jobs of the Mods as things that you shalt not do.

To be clear, I wasn't trying to do anyone's job, just say "stop doing ____ to me".
CanRay
Going through the Black Market ensures that you're going to at least get some quality for what you're paying for. Stealing something... Who knows what kind of condition it's in before you take it?

That said, I doubt many 'Runners buy Ford Americars. wink.gif
Starmage21
Oddly enough, I have ZERO issues with what the OP argues. It is EXACTLY the kind of awesome player-driven content that is worthy of the gametable, and enough planning has gone into it to suggest that it is indeed a worthy run.

The best runner teams dont always get their jobs from Mister Johnson, sometimes they just think of their own ways to stick it to the man.
KnightAries
QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Aug 29 2012, 08:12 PM) *
Oddly enough, I have ZERO issues with what the OP argues. It is EXACTLY the kind of awesome player-driven content that is worthy of the gametable, and enough planning has gone into it to suggest that it is indeed a worthy run.

The best runner teams dont always get their jobs from Mister Johnson, sometimes they just think of their own ways to stick it to the man.


I think most teams prefer sticking it to "the corps" as the make more and are more dangerous then "the man" is now days. biggrin.gif
Yerameyahu
Are the corps not the man?
_Pax._
QUOTE (Starmage21 @ Aug 29 2012, 10:12 PM) *
Oddly enough, I have ZERO issues with what the OP argues.

I don't have a problem with the concept. I just think the plan has a few potentially-large holes in it. smile.gif
Fatum
QUOTE (LurkerOutThere @ Aug 30 2012, 02:55 AM) *
There's a fair bit of stuff i absolutely abhor about the recent fluff. Trivilializing resonance realm data recovery is one of them, other then that carry on.
I couldn't agree more with this.

Also, yeah, things like what the original post offers are perfectly fine in Shadowrun. If you have a proactive group who are willing to show some initiative, and not just perform exactly what the Johnson says them, you should consider yourself lucky. In my experience, such players are pretty rare (and I am bad at that, too).
Midas
QUOTE (Hida Tsuzua @ Aug 29 2012, 11:51 PM) *
Really this is just a reskin of the good old "why not just steal cars?" argument. For their skill level and capital investment, shadowrunners sell themselves short. They really could be making much better money* for equal or less risk than shadowrunning. Generally you can come up with reasons why shadowrunners don't do them, but that causes oddness such as white collar fraud or carkacking apparently being way more dangerous than breaking into highly secure facilities. This and other reasons is why I don't like "I'm just in it for the cash" motivations for shadowrunners.

*- In my experience payment is between 5000-15000Y per team member for a run. If you're way above this, this problem goes away, but it really needs to be in the 50000+Y to get out of this problem. A lot of GMs won't pay that much for a variety of reasons anyways.

It all depends on how the GM sees things. In my gameworld, even with a high Loyalty chop-shop contact, stealing too many cars is gonna get you in trouble with the gang the chop-shop regularly uses (protection comes with the "business relationship"), organized crime (who don't want newbs muscling in on "their" territory) and so on. The odd car nobody's gonna really notice or give a shit, but turn it into a profession and you are gonna be stepping on peoples toes ... think Breaking Bad but for cars and you should get an idea how I run things.

As to the OP and his plan, the premise seems reasonable enough, but Pax is right in that things will depend on how inventory is checked before shipment. This is entirely up to the GM of course, but I imagine that goods would be checked when they are taken from the shelves, and then checked again on the loading dock (hell, this is common practice IRL these days).

The other potential stumbling block, according to my take on the RFID world, is that Stealth RFID tags might not be caught by TAG erasers unless they are active when the sweep is made. The more expensive the merchandise, the more stealth tags there are (a few with hourly sends, a few daily and a few weekly). For 100K newyen's worth of merchandise, perhaps there are not so many, for higher price tag goods there will be more; professionals with industry knowledge (the places the tags are often put etc) can probably take the goods apart and clean them up, but that is an additional cost in that they will want a decent fee for their service.

It is not a bad idea (and his low-balling the value of the haul stands to his advantage IMHO), and with a few tweaks could be made to work, who knows?
DuckEggBlue Omega
Yes, this is a perfectly valid, player generated run. I just don't see that it has any better risk/effort vs reward ratio than a regular run, minus the plot - especially if the intent is to steal regular gear for other runs. Specialist gear would be a different story. So yeah, it's cool if players want to do it, I'm just not sure why they would.

One thing:
QUOTE (ShadowDragon8685 @ Aug 30 2012, 06:34 AM) *
QUOTE (_Pax._ @ Aug 30 2012, 05:55 AM) *

Faraday cage: 100 nuyen.gif per cubic meter. Let's assume this "back room" is, oh, 4m by 5m by 3m. Sixty cubic meters, or, 6,000 nuyen.gif

That makes no sense, since a faraday cage is just any volume which is enclosed by the wire mesh. You may be thinking of the surface area of a prism, which is 2ab + 2bc + 2ac. Let's say that a = 4, b = 5, and c =3.

You only need one hundred square meters of mesh to turn this room into a faraday cage. So only 1,000 nuyen.gif

The only way your maths works is if 1 cubic meter=10 sqaure meters somehow. Which is just... uh?
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (CanRay @ Aug 29 2012, 08:56 PM) *
Going through the Black Market ensures that you're going to at least get some quality for what you're paying for. Stealing something... Who knows what kind of condition it's in before you take it?

That said, I doubt many 'Runners buy Ford Americars. wink.gif


What is wrong with the Ford Americar? Solid piece of engineering and ubuquitous. Who wouldn't want one as a 'Runner? smile.gif
FuelDrop
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Aug 30 2012, 08:47 PM) *
What is wrong with the Ford Americar? Solid piece of engineering and ubuquitous. Who wouldn't want one as a 'Runner? smile.gif

I think he means that runners don't pay for them because they steal them.
I could be wrong, though.
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (DuckEggBlue Omega @ Aug 30 2012, 03:27 AM) *
One thing:

That makes no sense, since a faraday cage is just any volume which is enclosed by the wire mesh. You may be thinking of the surface area of a prism, which is 2ab + 2bc + 2ac. Let's say that a = 4, b = 5, and c =3.

You only need one hundred square meters of mesh to turn this room into a faraday cage. So only 1,000 nuyen.gif

The only way your maths works is if 1 cubic meter=10 sqaure meters somehow. Which is just... uh?


I think what he is saying is that the whole Cube is not a Mesh. The outer walls, floors, and ceiling are composed of the Mesh, so really, you are only covering the exterior surfaces. Which is a MUCH different calculation than the entirety of the Cube itself. At least that is how I read it. smile.gif
DuckEggBlue Omega
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Aug 30 2012, 10:22 PM) *
I think what he is saying is that the whole Cube is not a Mesh. The outer walls, floors, and ceiling are composed of the Mesh, so really, you are only covering the exterior surfaces. Which is a MUCH different calculation than the entirety of the Cube itself. At least that is how I read it. smile.gif

Yes, the surface area would be MORE (atleast the for the example - actually 94 but he said 100>60). The only way it comes out cheaper as in his example is if you're pricing the mesh at 10 nuyen.gif per square meter, and given the quoted price of 100 nuyen.gif per cubic meter, means he is, for whatever reason, assuming 1 cubic meter = 10 square meters.

So again... Huh? It's possible I'm completely spacing on the maths, but I don't think so.

Yes the quoted price should be in square meters because that's how you would use the product, but where is this arbitrary conversion rate coming from? Wouldn't it be better to assume a typo and just make it 100 nuyen.gif per square meter? This makes the cost 9,400 nuyen.gif, so HIGHER. Or maybe they literally sell it in cubes, but wouldn't that make the conversion rate 1:6?

So yes, calculating it the way Pax did makes no sense in real terms (as opposed to whatever the RAW is), it should be MORE expensive.
CanRay
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Aug 30 2012, 07:47 AM) *
What is wrong with the Ford Americar? Solid piece of engineering and ubuquitous. Who wouldn't want one as a 'Runner? smile.gif
Never said there was anything wrong with one. Good American Engineering.
QUOTE (FuelDrop @ Aug 30 2012, 07:52 AM) *
I think he means that runners don't pay for them because they steal them.
I could be wrong, though.
No, you're right. biggrin.gif
Tymeaus Jalynsfein
QUOTE (DuckEggBlue Omega @ Aug 30 2012, 07:23 AM) *
Yes, surface area would be MORE (atleast the for the example - 100>60). The only way it comes out cheaper is if you're pricing the mesh at 10 nuyen.gif per square meter, and given the quoted price of 100 nuyen.gif per cubic meter, means he is, for whatever reason, assuming 1 cubic meter = 10 square meters.

So again... Huh?

Yes the quoted price should be in square meters because that's how you would use the product, but where is this arbitrary conversion rate coming from? Wouldn't it be better to assume a typo and just make it 100 nuyen.gif per square meter? This makes the cost 10,000 nuyen.gif, so HIGHER. Or maybe they literally sell it in cubes, but wouldn't that make the conversion rate 1:6?

So yes, calculating it the way Pax did makes no sense in real terms (as opposed to whatever the RAW is), it should be MORE expensive.


Indeed... I see what you are saying. Yes, it should be 100 nuyen.gif per Square Meter (not Cubic Meter) of coverage.
Yerameyahu
If he did what the RAW says, it's hard to fault *him* for that.
almost normal
QUOTE (LurkerOutThere @ Aug 29 2012, 05:55 PM) *
There's a fair bit of stuff i absolutely abhor about the recent fluff. Trivilializing resonance realm data recovery is one of them, other then that carry on.


I'm not sure saying "X service has a cost" is trivializing.
almost normal
QUOTE (Tymeaus Jalynsfein @ Aug 30 2012, 07:47 AM) *
What is wrong with the Ford Americar? Solid piece of engineering and ubuquitous. Who wouldn't want one as a 'Runner? smile.gif


Ford makes great trucks. Cars... not so much. This never changes.
Speed Wraith
QUOTE (almost normal @ Aug 30 2012, 10:47 AM) *
Ford makes great trucks. Cars... not so much. This never changes.


Freakin' Ford almost cost me a Christmas when I was young. Damn Bronco wouldn't start if it was cold. Or wet. Or anything other than a perfect sunny day in the middle of summer with a light breeze blowing from the south-east and while Mars was in retrograde.

Found on Road Dead. Fix or Repair Daily. Failed on Race Day. These acronymical jokes exist for a reason. nyahnyah.gif
Fatum
QUOTE (almost normal @ Aug 30 2012, 06:42 PM) *
I'm not sure saying "X service has a cost" is trivializing.
Turning something from an esoteric undertaking with unclear results into a well-defined service with a cost is trivializing.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012