Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Computers and Memory/storage question
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3
SentineloftheMountain
Hi. I am playing a hermetic mage and want to have his Sorcery library level 6 on a computer. The SR source book 167 states that a level6 library would take 36,000 Mp to store (rating * rating * 1,000 Mp).

If I am getting a desktop computer to hold this information then what rating of a computer do I need.

How do you calculate storage space on for a computer that is not a deck??

I starting doing for math on this and the numbers started getting above 500,000 nuyen for 36,000 Mp memory cost. Is this right??

I hope not because I have two other libraries I need to store on a computer as well(total of three libraries) at level 6 rating. That would mean a 1+ million computer system.

Thanks for the help.
Austere Emancipator
[Edit]Teaches me to RTFM.[/Edit]
Necro Tech
Size is (rating *rating * 100MP). Cost is (rating * rating * 1000 nuyen.gif ) Whole different ballgame there. Plus, the library comes on chip or in a book, your choice so the basic cost includes a format. Keeping it on your computer costs 20 nuyen.gif an MP.
Austere Emancipator
QUOTE (Necro Tech)
Plus, the library comes on chip or in a book, your choice so the basic cost includes a format.

Good points there. Maybe I should read the Magic Section through again.
SentineloftheMountain
So, assuming I want the library in chip form a rating level 6 library would have a file size of 3600 Mp (6*6*100 Mp) and cost 72000 nuyen in memory(20*3600 Mp).

Is this correct?? This seems high to me.

TheScamp
QUOTE
Keeping it on your computer costs 20  an MP.

Unless you just want to slot the chip that it comes on; then you can use it in any computer with a chip reader (which should be pretty much all of them).
Kanada Ten
3600 MP requires a computer with 3600 MP only if you do not want to use the chips. Otherwise, any computer will do. Yes, the cost of computers is insane in SR. You can in theory have it all on one* chip and, assuming that is a copy of the library, the chip would cost 1,800 nuyen. *You may need four chips to hold all the data if the chips are capped at 1000MP (cannot remember), in which case get a computer with four slots. Personally I think they should errata the computer cost to 2 nuyen per MP since they divided by 10 with the chips.

QUOTE
Errata
p. 296: Skillsofts and Chips Table [12]
The price for optical memory chips should be Mp x 0.5¥, and the Concealability of the skillsoft jukebox was changed to 6
Kagetenshi
I hadn't realized how insane the computer costs were until I was helping my girlfriend make a rigger and realized that the lowest-cost deck was a more economical way to store recorded footage than a pocket computer of equal storage.

I'm still inwardly praying that I screwed up in those calculations.

~J
GrinderTheTroll
QUOTE (SentineloftheMountain)
So, assuming I want the library in chip form a rating level 6 library would have a file size of 3600 Mp (6*6*100 Mp) and cost 72000 nuyen in memory(20*3600 Mp). 

Is this correct??  This seems high to me.


I don't think you can stick an entire library on one OMC, but SR3 doesn't explicitly give th size limit of an OMC. You could just store the Library using Offline-Storage (50+5 per MP) and just access the data using a Personal Computer.

Again, no specific rules about needing to hold the whole library in memory, so I don't think you'd need a ton of 20 x MP memory, just enough to rune a program to browse it (these take minimal impact per the personal computer info on SR3:307).

Thinking about this in real-life terms, RAM cost more per MB than Harddrive space. You don't need 5GB of RAM to run an installed 5GB game, just enough RAM to run the software that will access the game. I think the same applies here.

So I'd say 50 + (3600 x 5) = 19050 for the offline-storage and then another 2000 for a 100 Mp Personal Computer (100 x 20 for cost) to access it.



lokugh
Of course, ten-fifteen years ago, all these prices were perfectlhy reasonable. I do remember the times when buying 2 MB of memory cost me $400, and a 200MB hard drive was almost $1,000 and that was only 1994-ish. That is the era from whence come the computer prices in this game. The computer chip glut of the late 90's changed this, but the computer prices were never altered.
Kagetenshi
I still remember when someone three years younger than me tried to guess the size of my first hard drive. He guessed a gigabyte.

*Pats the 156 megabyte drive he filled with Civilization saved games*

That's not counting the hard-driveless Mac Classic…

~J
Sargasso
I never understood why a library would take up so much memory? They're text files. Let's say they're images even. We're talking about storage memory sixty years more advaned. Storage for a few throusand books should be cheap, not expensive.
lokugh
QUOTE (Kagetenshi @ Sep 21 2004, 05:27 PM)
I still remember when someone three years younger than me tried to guess the size of my first hard drive. He guessed a gigabyte.

*Pats the 156 megabyte drive he filled with Civilization saved games*

That's not counting the hard-driveless Mac Classic…

~J

Size of my first harddrive was 40MB, added to a Tandy 1000 so I could play Civ smile.gif

Sargasso, how large would a library full of image files be (imagine you are limited to .GIF's smile.gif ?) I don't know what goes into a hermetic library, but I always figured there was not all that much text. And I suspect it includes things like its own operating system, encryption, etc. Again, this was all based on 10 to 15 year old computer technology and then thinking ahead (remember, as early as 20 years ago, Bill Gates and company did not believe any computer would ever need more than 650K of memory. That 650K limit was what made DOS such a bitch to run games on. So, thinking 60-80 years ahead is hard).
GrinderTheTroll
QUOTE (lokugh)
QUOTE (Kagetenshi @ Sep 21 2004, 05:27 PM)
I still remember when someone three years younger than me tried to guess the size of my first hard drive. He guessed a gigabyte.

*Pats the 156 megabyte drive he filled with Civilization saved games*

That's not counting the hard-driveless Mac Classic…

~J

Size of my first harddrive was 40MB, added to a Tandy 1000 so I could play Civ smile.gif

Sargasso, how large would a library full of image files be (imagine you are limited to .GIF's smile.gif ?) I don't know what goes into a hermetic library, but I always figured there was not all that much text. And I suspect it includes things like its own operating system, encryption, etc. Again, this was all based on 10 to 15 year old computer technology and then thinking ahead (remember, as early as 20 years ago, Bill Gates and company did not believe any computer would ever need more than 650K of memory. That 650K limit was what made DOS such a bitch to run games on. So, thinking 60-80 years ahead is hard).

Yeah this always did bug me, but who knows what the library looks like. I doubt it's all text if it's computerized. Probably lots of multimedia and stuff, but I doubt 3600MP worth, that's alot even by SR standards.

The other part of an eletronic libary is that you are already paying for it (1000 x Rating) and now you have to pay to store it and view it?

I suppose it's the cost of convenience, but that means you are paying for "something" so what is it? Disks? OMC chips? How many? Can I just read them with my computer already? Starts to get me thinking that the medium cost is already a factor and that you'd just need some device to access it.

Anyone get the same vibe?
Sargasso
It's not hard to guess. a Hermetic's physical library takes up X cubic meters. What is the bulk of the value of that? Text, images, diagrams, maybe a small sculpture as a pneumonic device. That's what, maybe a million pages of data? I have 459 books in my bedroom, (I cleaned throroughly the other day, and I counted). They cover four seperate bookshelves, stacked two deep. They average 500 pages or so apeice. That's only 229,500 pages. Books average 200-300 words, especially paperbacks, which most of mine are. That's only 57,375,000 words. I'm supposed to belive that's a few dozen megapulses?
Kanada Ten
QUOTE (Sargasso)
I never understood why a library would take up so much memory? They're text files. Let's say they're images even.

I assume a rating 6 library is 6 thousand books, mostly images and symbols, several hundred code books and several hundred more decoding books, thousands of essays, a few thousand progressive starcharts and 6 newsletter subscriptions. Plus a few things I'll think of latter.

QUOTE
We're talking about storage memory sixty years more advaned. Storage for a few thousand books should be cheap, not expensive.

You can get away with 1800 nuyen for storage on the rating 6 library, not bad really.
Sargasso
Oh, the information within is valuable, but why is the storage medium so costly? Look at Cds, I can burn a CD with 700+ megabytes of data for pennies apeice.
Kanada Ten
This isn't really a new issue. I've made my suggestion in this thread, and others have made theirs in previous. If you'd like to make a topic and/or suggest an improvment, that'd be great.

Personally, I like dividing the memory costs by ten, and then it's really a non-issue to me.
Sargasso
Well, why not makes the storage medium free? If you go to your local talismonger's shop, the choice between chip and hardcopy should be about as meaningful as the choice between paper or plastic at the grocery checkout lane. I'm sure the talismonger would rather not store hundreds of pounds of books. giving you a break for buying chips means they don't have to bother with wharehousing issues.
Kanada Ten
Well, it is free. The cost of the library includes the storage of chip or book. The original poster just wanted it all on one computer, not chip or paperback. SR computer memory is generally considered overpriced. Also, I doubt the local talismonger has anything above rating 2 in store.
lokugh
QUOTE (Sargasso @ Sep 21 2004, 05:47 PM)
It's not hard to guess. a Hermetic's physical library takes up X cubic meters. What is the bulk of the value of that? Text, images, diagrams, maybe a small sculpture as a pneumonic device. That's what, maybe a million pages of data? I have 459 books in my bedroom, (I cleaned throroughly the other day, and I counted). They cover four seperate bookshelves, stacked two deep. They average 500 pages or so apeice.  That's only 229,500 pages. Books average 200-300 words, especially paperbacks, which most of mine are. That's only 57,375,000 words. I'm supposed to belive that's a few dozen megapulses?

Ok, you have paperbacks. Novels, I am assuming, mostly. That wouldn't take much to store, although storing the covers as image files would take up almost as much room as the combined text would.

Now, assume instead of paperback novels, you had 450 art books, full of full color plates of various paintings and sculptures. First, they are much larger. (usually coffee-table size or slightly smaller. That would take probably 100 times at much storage (more for really high res images) as your library of paperback novels.

Here are the sizes:

Rating 6 library:

3600 MP or six cubic meters of physical space, if it is not computerized.

Six cubic meters is ~212 cubic feet.

To address other questions, no, it can be assumed you purchase the storage media (chips) when you buy the library. What you do need is a computer (if you buy the chip) or some boxes and bookshelves if you buy the books (and I hope you got a decent lifestyle, if you bought the books, or as a GM, I might be evil and make them deteriorate).

As far as the computer goes, you do not need to buy one with 3600MP of memory any more than you need to buy a computer with 2 Gigabytes of memory in order to play Morrowind today (although it might not hurt smile.gif ). If you want to install the library on the computer, you will need 3600MP of offline storage however (a harddrive...this is not necessary...you can always just read directly from the chips).
GrinderTheTroll
QUOTE (lokugh)
To address other questions, no, it can be assumed you purchase the storage media (chips) when you buy the library. What you do need is a computer (if you buy the chip) or some boxes and bookshelves if you buy the books (and I hope you got a decent lifestyle, if you bought the books, or as a GM, I might be evil and make them deteriorate).

As far as the computer goes, you do not need to buy one with 3600MP of memory any more than you need to buy a computer with 2 Gigabytes of memory in order to play Morrowind today (although it might not hurt ). If you want to install the library on the computer, you will need 3600MP of offline storage however (a harddrive...this is not necessary...you can always just read directly from the chips).

Yeah that's what I've gathered from re-reading SR3 and absorbing the posts...It already comes on a chip, disk, whatever, you just need something to read it with which is cheap.

I suppose i need to RTFM more closely. embarrassed.gif
Sargasso
Yeah, ditto there. this is what I get for letting my players borrow my core book for months on end.
SentineloftheMountain
Thanks for the input everyone.

So, what computer equipment do I need then to view a hermetic library on computer chip format or where do I look in a sourcbook for pricing information for the equipment??

I had assumed I needed 3600 Mp memory on a computer in order to view/use the library by computer. I take it that this is not the case.

The only place I place I saw for offline storage was in the Matrix Sourcebook for cyberdecks.
Where should I look for this information??

Thanks again.
Kanada Ten
SR3 page 304 has off-line storage; it can work with any computer. I think you need only 100MP computer to view the files, personally (talk with your GM). But I suggest a printer and maybe multiple displays.

[edit] McMakie's GM View DAT is sweet, BTW.
Cray74
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
I still remember when someone three years younger than me tried to guess the size of my first hard drive. He guessed a gigabyte.

*Pats the 156 megabyte drive he filled with Civilization saved games*

20MB. I had a Tandy 286, 12MHz, 20MB, and I was the envy of my high school Pascal class. And I recall futzing around on computers with cassette tape drives as a kid...TRS-80s?

I still recall my friend (now possessor of a masters in computer science) asking why I needed a $300, 320MB to upgrade my freshman college-era computer. "120MB was enough for him." A little more than a decade later, I've got a Flash "pendrive" with 256MB and an 80GB hard drive.
Necro Tech
Your computer doesn't have to have any memory at all the view the library if it on a chip, just a chip port. Since a desk top is bought only as memory, you have to figure the cost of the monitor, key board, etc is already figured in. For the library, anything that can display chips, (pocket sec, simsense deck, cyberdeck) and has a monitor of some type (personal telecom, headware w/image link, electronic suite in rigger van) can be used if you are doing research on the go. Hell, a chipjack with image link allows you to watch it at your leisure. It is only sold in book form for those who like a retro feel.
Herald of Verjigorm
Pocket secretary is a nice choice. The cost of 100MP of palmtop computing with some other features thrown in at no extra cost.
Necro Tech
And for the record, I had a 2MB, then upgraded to a whopping 8MB to go with my 300 Baud modem.
Kanada Ten
QUOTE (Necro Tech @ Sep 21 2004, 06:56 PM)
Your computer doesn't have to have any memory at all the view the library if it on a chip, just a chip port.

While I agree in principle, I think you'd want enough memory to run a translator, dictation, animation, and do a decent search. A basic software package, which is stated to include almost any "mudane" program imagined, is also included in the computer cost, but many GMs will scale the package to the memory. Can you imagine trying to search a 3600 MP file with only 5 MP?

[edit] Franklin Ace 100
hobgoblin
the way i view sr chip storage is a kind of computer on a chip. think back to the days of 8 and 16 bit nintendo and sega machines. before the cd-rom became popular for games. those days anything shiped on chips and was slotted into the main box. many of the later 16-bit nintendo games had special chips in those "casettes" to pull of new stunts. think of it like haveing the executable stored in nonvolatile ram, cut the power and the chips just stops there and when power is reapplyed it will resume where it ended (or be reset, maybe best in case of a crash). data isnt loaded into memory before being searched, the storage media is optical and probably more similar to ram then rom. only thing the computer needs is a bit of space to store variables and so on for when the "app" is in use. no need for a special pdf app to read that format of files. every pdf file comes wraped in its own reader. data and app is no longer seperate, in many ways its MPAA/RIAA's wet dream as it allows for very tight content control.

there was talk about the us goverment buying huge "ram" drives when the terrorist hunt was hot. basicly they where normal hardrives wrapped in ram so that the whole content of the drive (most likely a database) was loaded into that ram. then you dont have to overload the computers own ram with working with that database and can most likely speed up searches a lot as you remove the load time.

the reason for ram these days is that the storage medium isnt so fast that the cpu can request information straight of it. just watch how your computer slows down when it have to swap stuff into or out of virtual memory (basicly a area of the hd the os accesses as if its a kind of ram, be it a special file or a precreated partition). computers of tomorow will be more like mobiles. instant on and ready to go to work. the only reason a java app on a cellphone have to load is that java apps are stored in independent bytecode rather then native binary of the individual phones cpu and therefor have to be translated. and even that prosess is quicker then a normal computer loading a application. pick up a smartphone and look how fast it can fire up a installed app and then dream about that as a full size desktop computer.

as for why there is active memory in a cyberdeck? gamebalance. in effect you may as well be useing all the apps at any time without needing to swap memory all the time. doing programing only need storage to hold the code your working on. ok so maybe its a safety design carryed over from the virus battles. atleast VR2 and later eliminated the internal loadtimes (now all you have to care about is uploading the icon part to the host your interacting with).
lokugh
QUOTE (SentineloftheMountain @ Sep 21 2004, 06:34 PM)
Thanks for the input everyone.

So, what computer equipment do I need then to view a hermetic library on computer chip format or where do I look in a sourcbook for pricing information for the equipment??

I had assumed I needed 3600 Mp memory on a computer in order to view/use the library by computer.  I take it that this is not the case.

The only place I place I saw for offline storage was in the Matrix Sourcebook for cyberdecks.
Where should I look for this information??

Thanks again.

While you can theoretically get by with a pocket secretary and such, you are a mage...which usually means no datajack. Which means, if you want to do any matrix usage, you need soemthing beefier. If nothing else, there are high level hermetic libraries online, which let you access them for a fee (usually around nuyen.gif 1200 per hour... nuyen.gif 100xrating per hour and most are around rating 12).

For this, you want a cyberterminal. These come with a screen and keyboard (SR3, 207). If you have T:Matrix handy, they are listed in there. They can be used to access the matrix. I also assume they come with a chip reader (I can't imagine a computer without one, and cyberterminals have to have some way to load programs on them). The most expensive one is only nuyen.gif 7,500, but you can get by with the cheapest one (forget price). You can upgrade storage and memory for them at the same prices as cyberdecks. You don't need to just to read your library, but you may need to to download research some day.
Kagetenshi
Datajacks are cheap and easy. Most hermetics would probably have one.

~J
lokugh
QUOTE (Kagetenshi)
Datajacks are cheap and easy. Most hermetics would probably have one.

~J

Giving up that 1 magic point at chargen is rough. I personally prefer to live without one, or add one later, at or around the time I can initiate.
Kagetenshi
Given the amount of power and knowledge available to a mage from a quickly-searchable library, the one magic point or associated geas is paltry.

~J
Kanada Ten
What's wrong with a trode rig? And secondly, why would ASIST be needed to search a libary? A PC can access the Matrix, it just can't do the simsense.
Eyeless Blond
If a Mermetic mage is dumb enough to buy his libraries at chargen, he probably has resources B or something like. With that kind of cash you've got plenty left over for some other useful 'ware other than just a datajack, like artwinkulation, Boosted 1, a trauma dampener, plastic bone lacing, etc. The dj is just there to round out the 1.00 Essence of cyberware, which will probably be geased off.

But really there's no reason a trode rig won't work, just as there's no reason to buy the libraries at chargen anyway. Well, maybe the bonjuring library....
Kagetenshi
Keep in mind that I'm arguing for mages in general having datajacks, not for PC mages to take them at chargen. Trode rigs are inconvenient and give a kludgy feel to things, you know? And searchable is the wrong term.

~J
Eyeless Blond
Heh, okay, from a roleplaying standpoint then. Datajacks are convenient; they're almost required for most middle-class people. Without one you're as technologically crippled as you are without an internet connection today; sure you can get by without it, but you're really missing something. It's a one-time investment of 20-100% of one month's rent to have one installed, which is pretty damn cheap considering how much people spend on their computers today.
Kanada Ten
A trode rig that looks like a baseball hat that doesn't infringe on your connection to the ecstacy of magical power, with promises of wireless connections in a few months to years... Yeah, I don't need to think twice about it. If half the SIN population can't be bothered to get a datajack, I don't see more than half the hermetics getting one.
Kagetenshi
The ecstasy of magical power comes from knowledge. What are you, some kind of shamanist?

~J
Kanada Ten
I totally disagree. As a hermetic, I'd consider lossing Essence comparable to having your member cut off and geasa being required to use a pump to get it up.

And yes, that's totally just my opinion.
Nylan
thats delightful, Kanada...thats the image I want in my head right before I go to bed.
Jason Farlander
QUOTE (Kanada Ten)
I totally disagree. As a hermetic, I'd consider lossing Essence comparable to having your member cut off and geasa being required to use a pump to get it up.

And yes, that's totally just my opinion.

This is one viable type of hermetic personality. One of many. I would argue that it would be one more towards the fringes, though. Most hermetics are just as capable of weighing benefits and drawbacks of implants objectively as anyone else - they just have one more thing to consider.
Kagetenshi
And I'd consider a datajack to be a Mr. Studd implant.

~J
Kanada Ten
And what are the benefits of a datajack compared to a wireless trode rig?
Kagetenshi
First off, the wireless bit doesn't exist yet. Second, no fiddling with nets and soforth or getting it out of alignment. Third, better responsiveness out of the interface.

Fourth, ability to easily use for other things like driving cars.

~J
Kanada Ten
And that overweighs having a barrier between you and magic? I don't see anywhere near half hermetics agreeing with you. Plus there is a chance of losing more magic if the doctor has an accident. The wireless part doesn't exist for datajacks either so you still must fiddle with wires.

[edit] I don't even think cars come standard with a datajack port. Do most people even drive their cars? I would think AutoNAV is the wave of the future.
Nemo
@Kanada Ten
The Limit of 1.000Mp per chip was in the Shadowbeat-SB
Jason Farlander
Hey, K-10, could you please point out the relevant passages in the descriptions of shamanic and hermetic approaches to magic that imply that hermetics as a whole are more power-hungry than shamans?

This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012