Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Bunraku math...
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4
CanRay
Here's a good question for the legality of the thing... Is a Bunraku Parlor "John" guilty of statutory rape?

It's not like the Puppet can say "No" while the personasoft is running, now, can (s)he?

Makes for some big hooped blackmail... Being put in the game group as the short eyes. Think about having to transmit your SIN in a lot of places, and the laws involving sexual offenders today? You better bet they have their SIN flagged so that people can see they're on "The List" for whatever reason.
Christian Lafay
I would think the employees would sign some kind of long standing contract stating their willingness to certain acts. Something like a 5-year contract with a no anal clause. This idea taken from the mock sex-slave trade done at certain parties. People sign up to be slaves. Write down what they aren't willing to do. The auctioneer lets the crowd know. The "slave" is bought until sunrise. The money goes towards hosting the next party.
CanRay
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 01:21 PM) *
I would think the employees would sign some kind of long standing contract stating their willingness to certain acts. Something like a 5-year contract with a no anal clause.
For the legal parlors. Or, hell, even the illegal ones would have the paperwork, even if the person didn't sign it. It's not like they can complain after the surgery...
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 05:25 PM) *
For the legal parlors. Or, hell, even the illegal ones would have the paperwork, even if the person didn't sign it. It's not like they can complain after the surgery...

No more trustworthy than a will.
CanRay
Oh great... Lawyers.
MortVent
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 12:30 PM) *
Oh great... Lawyers.



The only thing that can make a dragon blink in amazement at the webs within webs of a contract and wonder if they will ever be that good
CanRay
I remember in "Good Omens" that Crowley sent a copy of Windows 3.1's User Agreement back down to hell with a Post-It note saying, "Here guys, LEARN!", or something like that.
hobgoblin
QUOTE (MortVent @ Nov 26 2011, 02:49 PM) *
A lot of issues are not really touched, but they are out there.

And the first thing they will have to deal with is trust issues. Not being able to trust yourself leads to major issues trusting others.

It also leads to building of walls between yourself and others, because not only can you not trust them to a point you don't trust yourself not to do something wrong that you will not remember

In a way the data filter is one of the most evil items out there to implant in someone, you take away their ability to trust themselves and others as well as set up situations where paranoia can set in hard as they know folks smiling at them know things they can't remember. Or they wonder why people look at them with disgust or fear. When you can't remember being a monster it's very hard on someone, you might remember a trigger but nothing till you are standing there with someone talking to you soothingly while holding a gun with white knuckles telling you it's okay you can relax it's over.

It's one of the implants that should be forbidden or a lot more restricted than it is really. Especially since it can be hooked up and paired with a personafix/skill cluster and turn someone into a monster/joy toy with a push of a button.

I think the old standby example is the personal aide equipped with one during a hush hush meeting...

It becomes a bit like trusted computing. It is not about you trusting the computer, it is about some third party trusting it to not spill data they do not want spilled...

In SR, if your not some exec or similar your basically a biological robot with a task to perform...

Hell, the worry of ending up thrown away may be what keeps the not so fervent believers in the corporate agenda in line...
kzt
The core issue with the filter is who has control of the filter. If it requires that the subject actively turn it on and can rely that it will go off it's a whole lot different than something that can be done to you at any time.

In this particular case it also means that effectively you are not there. You clock in, activate a program that starts up the filter and the persona-replacement, bot of which are running on a timer, and suddenly there is someone who just looks like you in the room. X hours later you step out of shower and you are suddenly back.

The issue really is trust. Which is kind of lacking in the SR universe.
Christian Lafay
"Work hard enough to not get fired and pay enough so they don't quit" seems to no longer apply in SR.
CanRay
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:01 PM) *
"Work hard enough to not get fired and pay enough so they don't quit" seems to no longer apply in SR.
Mr. Eaton was said to have mentioned something like enjoying the Great Depression, as he could get his workers to work as hard as possible, as there were ten people waiting for their jobs if they didn't work hard enough.
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 10:03 PM) *
Mr. Eaton was said to have mentioned something like enjoying the Great Depression, as he could get his workers to work as hard as possible, as there were ten people waiting for their jobs if they didn't work hard enough.

"Do a job for a nickel what a (black person) does for a dime and a white man used to get a quarter for." -The Butcher
pbangarth
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 05:12 PM) *
"Do a job for a nickel what a (black person) does for a dime and a white man used to get a quarter for." -The Butcher

Is that word such a pariah now, that even in a quote it has to be euphemized?
CanRay
QUOTE (pbangarth @ Nov 26 2011, 06:38 PM) *
Is that word such a pariah now, that even in a quote it has to be euphemized?
Considering how much trouble I got into saying it last time, referring it to the equivalent of "Trog"... Yes.
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (pbangarth @ Nov 26 2011, 10:38 PM) *
Is that word such a pariah now, that even in a quote it has to be euphemized?

Whenever you think it safe you will find that one person who is offended.
CanRay
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:44 PM) *
Whenever you think it safe you will find that one person who is offended.
It's always confused me that I can make Mic jokes and Mac jokes with no problem, but the moment I make a Mi'kmaq joke, I'm a racist... nyahnyah.gif
3278
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:08 PM) *
Here's a good question for the legality of the thing... Is a Bunraku Parlor "John" guilty of statutory rape?

To be honest, I'd just sort of assumed bunraku parlors were illegal, full stop, but it occurs to me they needn't be, depending on one's vision of the setting.
MortVent
QUOTE (3278 @ Nov 26 2011, 07:02 PM) *
To be honest, I'd just sort of assumed bunraku parlors were illegal, full stop, but it occurs to me they needn't be, depending on one's vision of the setting.


The catch is the personafix

The legal ones would have to be lacking the BTL chip/software so the person would have to be a willing participant understanding they will not remember anything about what happens

kzt
QUOTE (MortVent @ Nov 26 2011, 05:12 PM) *
The catch is the personafix

The legal ones would have to be lacking the BTL chip/software so the person would have to be a willing participant understanding they will not remember anything about what happens

Why? If you agree to have the the personafix why would that be illegal? It's also allows you to separate yourself even more from what you do, because it isn't "you" begging someone you have never known to use you. So not only do you not remember it, it wasn't even you. You just get paid for the time.
CanRay
Actually, it'd likely be kept illegal so that the price can be jacked up for the "Sleaze" factor and "Danger", giving the gangs control of it and not having to muscle out legitimate competition.
Christian Lafay
I don't think gangs would do something like that. MAYBE the gangs that border on syndicates. But I think most would still to plain old prostitution. Maybe not even "plain old". "Hey buddy, you look like a guy who would appreciate some good centaur lovin'."
hobgoblin
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 11:03 PM) *
Mr. Eaton was said to have mentioned something like enjoying the Great Depression, as he could get his workers to work as hard as possible, as there were ten people waiting for their jobs if they didn't work hard enough.

Sounds like present day work environment in various "low cost" places around the globe...
3278
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 12:22 AM) *
If you agree to have the the personafix why would that be illegal?

QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 27 2011, 12:26 AM) *
Actually, it'd likely be kept illegal so that the price can be jacked up for the "Sleaze" factor and "Danger", giving the gangs control of it and not having to muscle out legitimate competition.

QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 27 2011, 12:28 AM) *
I don't think gangs would do something like that. MAYBE the gangs that border on syndicates.

And that's why I say, "depending on one's vision of the setting." And given a handful of people here have differing ideas of what's logical, you can bet a handful of people in the setting would have differing ideas, as well, so all the possibilities mentioned here are likely true, somewhere, at some time, in Shadowrun. It's a big game, with a lot of room for differences; I used to live in a neighborhood full of middle-class students and retirees, and could you could hear automatic weapons fire from the next block, which was deep urban hood. If that's the difference one block can make in the real world, imagine, with Shadowrun's intensity and balkanization and extremism, how varied the ideas of different jurisdictions and voters, gangs and syndicates, prostitutes and johns would be.
kzt
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 05:26 PM) *
Actually, it'd likely be kept illegal so that the price can be jacked up for the "Sleaze" factor and "Danger", giving the gangs control of it and not having to muscle out legitimate competition.

Umm, IRL gangs just kidnap kids and young women, gang rape them for a week, addict them to drugs, terrify the hell out of them and put them to work, beating the crap out of them if they don't make enough money, plus occasionally murdering one to keep the rest in line. It's much more cost effective approach. No fancy electronics needed.
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 12:58 AM) *
Umm, IRL gangs just kidnap kids and young women, gang rape them for a week, addict them to drugs, terrify the hell out of them and put them to work, beating the crap out of them if they don't make enough money, plus occasionally murdering one to keep the rest in line. It's much more cost effective approach. No fancy electronics needed.

I think there should be different words to separate gangs who just like to run drugs and hurt people (Bloods) and those that will carve up a man infront of his brothers to send a messages (MS13).
CanRay
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 08:28 PM) *
I don't think gangs would do something like that. MAYBE the gangs that border on syndicates. But I think most would still to plain old prostitution. Maybe not even "plain old". "Hey buddy, you look like a guy who would appreciate some good centaur lovin'."
I still like that Centaur cop that was asked about "Pony Rides". nyahnyah.gif
QUOTE (hobgoblin @ Nov 26 2011, 08:49 PM) *
Sounds like present day work environment in various "low cost" places around the globe...
It was right then, why wouldn't it be right today?
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 26 2011, 08:58 PM) *
Umm, IRL gangs just kidnap kids and young women, gang rape them for a week, addict them to drugs, terrify the hell out of them and put them to work, beating the crap out of them if they don't make enough money, plus occasionally murdering one to keep the rest in line. It's much more cost effective approach. No fancy electronics needed.
True, but you can't get them to play multiple roles for a John who wants something in particular. Also you don't have them stealing money, knifing Johns, getting arrested and spilling info to the DA for a easier sentence... Or get money from a Cybernetics Corporation that needs some new equipment tested on someone and have no volunteers.
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 09:08 PM) *
I think there should be different words to separate gangs who just like to run drugs and hurt people (Bloods) and those that will carve up a man infront of his brothers to send a messages (MS13).
"Punks" and "Sociopaths"?
Paul
It's a pretty common tactic for even low level gangs to use sexually predatory tactics to control people, and make money. Rape is kind of one of the easiest crimes to commit-which is why rape and assault are so much easier than say forging ID's.
kzt
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:08 PM) *
I think there should be different words to separate gangs who just like to run drugs and hurt people (Bloods) and those that will carve up a man infront of his brothers to send a messages (MS13).

I'm not sure that difference exists. Does it really?
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 01:13 AM) *
I'm not sure that difference exists. Does it really?

I believe so. From the people I've known it always seemed a difference between acts of "necessity" and ones of desire.
CanRay
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 26 2011, 09:13 PM) *
I'm not sure that difference exists. Does it really?
Yes, it does. Most street gangs who don't think second thoughts about shooting up a street with automatics to hit one guy in a drive-by to send a message will likely be ill to slowly kill a person to death in front of their tied-up and helpless family to send a message. Especially if they then move onto the family and kill all of them the same way. Yes, even the one in the crib.

Shove a knife in a guys guts, maybe. Slowly cut off piece. After piece. After piece. And mail the parts one bit at a time to the police or reporters as a message against investigating or reporting on them?

I wish I could say the world is a fragged up place now, but, honestly, *Sighs* have we ever changed?
Paul
Then we get to the sliding scale of what constitutes necessary. I could introduce you to a dozen plus murderers, twice that many rapists and more who can all articulate why what they did was necessary. I get what you're after-but unfortunately life isn't so polite.
CanRay
The problem is that morality and ethics are not universal even within the same culture.

What I'd do and what some other Ontarian living in Manitoba would do in the same situation could be two vastly different things.
Christian Lafay
I simply blame how imprecise English can be. The only real example I have without calling on those I've known, since I have seen Sons of Anarchy referenced here, is that Oppie kills out of necessity and Happy does it out of desire.
Christian Lafay
By they way I do enjoy when topics like this pop up on the boards.
kzt
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:17 PM) *
I believe so. From the people I've known it always seemed a difference between acts of "necessity" and ones of desire.

Well, sending a message is a "necessity" to people in that life.
CanRay
Oppie kills out of vengence. Happy does it out of desire. Tig just needs to remember why he beats hookers. nyahnyah.gif

Jax planting the pool cue into the guy's junk and having it lift up like a flagpole as he fell down was a necessity.
kzt
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 06:19 PM) *
slowly kill a person to death in front of their tied-up and helpless family to send a message. Especially if they then move onto the family and kill all of them the same way. Yes, even the one in the crib.

Traditionally it's done in the reverse order.
Christian Lafay
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 01:23 AM) *
Well, sending a message is a "necessity" to people in that life.

Agreed. The difference comes from a grunt being ordered to do it or one going "I got this! Man, I been waiting to test out my new machete ALL DAY!"
CanRay
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 26 2011, 09:25 PM) *
Traditionally it's done in the reverse order.
I think it's a positive sign that I don't know how to traditionally do something like that.
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 09:25 PM) *
Agreed. The difference comes from a grunt being ordered to do it or one going "I got this! Man, I been waiting to test out my new machete ALL DAY!"
Soldier or Sociopath.
Irion
@Christian Lafay
QUOTE
Agreed. The difference comes from a grunt being ordered to do it or one going "I got this! Man, I been waiting to test out my new machete ALL DAY!"

Which is none, to be exactly.
Yeah, did not do any dirty talk, while I raped her, makes it so much better.... wobble.gif wobble.gif wobble.gif

QUOTE
I believe so. From the people I've known it always seemed a difference between acts of "necessity" and ones of desire.

Necessity is just saying I do not want to walkt the other way. Sometimes it just means: I think thats the easier way.
@CanRay
QUOTE
The problem is that morality and ethics are not universal even within the same culture.

I disagree with that. But I think there is no use to go into details here. Lets just but it like that, that this is not the modern view on that topic. (For example human rights are seen as law, which applys to everyone and everywhere...)
last_of_the_great_mikeys
QUOTE (CanRay @ Nov 26 2011, 05:21 PM) *
The problem is that morality and ethics are not universal even within the same culture.

What I'd do and what some other Ontarian living in Manitoba would do in the same situation could be two vastly different things.


Does anybody really live in Manitoba? nyahnyah.gif
hobgoblin
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 27 2011, 02:17 AM) *
I believe so. From the people I've known it always seemed a difference between acts of "necessity" and ones of desire.

Seems to echo the impression i get of crimes in general. Most are done on a necessity/desperation basis, while minority is done because the perpetrators enjoy doing them.
Christian Lafay
Well, let's take it away from crime to give a different light to it. "Occupy that town, soldier" versus "Take the village! TAKE THE WHOLE F*CKING VILLAGE!" Two commanders with the same goal but different drives.
CanRay
QUOTE (last_of_the_great_mikeys @ Nov 26 2011, 10:58 PM) *
Does anybody really live in Manitoba? nyahnyah.gif
Quite a few people, there are a lot of places that are nice. Winnipeg isn't one of them.

Honestly, I think the First Nations communities saw Fort Garry being set up and laughed their asses off. "Trust those Europeans to settle in the ONE PLACE that's totally unlivable most of the year." "I know, even we only visit on the few nice months of the year to trade with the other tribes on the rivers."

'Course, it's a Urban Native Reserve as well, so maybe I might be mistaken. nyahnyah.gif
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 11:32 PM) *
Well, let's take it away from crime to give a different light to it. "Occupy that town, soldier" versus "Take the village! TAKE THE WHOLE F*CKING VILLAGE!" Two commanders with the same goal but different drives.
Which Vietnam movie was it where the soldier went, "Let's do the Village! Let's do the whole F$%#ING VILLAGE!!!".

I know it was "Full Metal Jacket" where the protagonist asked the Side Gunner, "How can you shoot Women and Children?". "Don't lead them as much.", was the reply, as he let out another burst from the M-60.
Christian Lafay
Platoon.
kzt
QUOTE (Irion @ Nov 26 2011, 07:38 PM) *
I disagree with that. But I think there is no use to go into details here. Lets just but it like that, that this is not the modern view on that topic. (For example human rights are seen as law, which applys to everyone and everywhere...)

If you found your sister had been raped, would the person you'd want to kill be your sister or the rapist?

In a not insignificant part of the world you would feel it was essential to kill your sister to restore the family honor.
CanRay
QUOTE (Christian Lafay @ Nov 26 2011, 11:49 PM) *
Platoon.
Thanks.
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 12:08 AM) *
If you found your sister had been raped, would the person you'd want to kill be your sister or the rapist?

In a not insignificant part of the world you would feel it was essential to kill your sister to restore the family honor.
And some you would have to kill the rapist. And others you'd have to kill both. And in the "Better" parts of the world you have to wait until the Police can get around to it and hope the statute of limitations hasn't run out yet. I lack a sister, but... *Shudders* That's a dark place in my mind I don't want to go to.

*ME*.
Grinder
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 05:08 AM) *
If you found your sister had been raped, would the person you'd want to kill be your sister or the rapist?

In a not insignificant part of the world you would feel it was essential to kill your sister to restore the family honor.


Keep it related to the 6th World, ok? No "what if" spelcuations based on today's world.
Irion
QUOTE (kzt @ Nov 27 2011, 05:08 AM) *
If you found your sister had been raped, would the person you'd want to kill be your sister or the rapist?

In a not insignificant part of the world you would feel it was essential to kill your sister to restore the family honor.

Do not take offence in that, but there was a reason I said, I do not want to go into detail. This would just lead to far. It would start with Hobbes, Schoppenhauer and Kant and end up with views on natural rights of the modern philosophie. (When saying starting, I mean you can start from there, you could also go back to Aristoteles or the new testament.)

Grinder
Dude, did you read my last post?
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012