QUOTE (MJBurrage @ Feb 27 2010, 08:47 AM)
Amazon gives you a good deal now, but that ignores the damage they due to the brick-and-mortar stores that keep our hobby alive by selling books at a price that would put a normal store out of business.
Without those stores as gathering places—and the new customers they bring into gaming—the hobby as-we-know-it will wither.
The problem is analogous to Walmart. The chain can save the average American family a few thousand a year, but it does so by pricing production out of the United States, forcing the loss of good domestic jobs. In the end Walmart costs the average family more in lost income then they saved in buying goods there.
Personally, I will only buy things from Amazon, that are not available from my local retailers.
My Local Gaming Store (I refuse to put "friendly" in front of that) sucks. I, and all my friends, dutifully shopped there for years (I think '92 was the first time I went there), paying higher prices than I could get down the street at a normal brick and mortar store, because they had a fantastically odd selection of games (all my Cheapass Games products and Car Wars and Starfleet Battles and Illuminati card game and other out of print stuff came from my then-Friendly LGS).
Then the owners sold it. The incredible variety that brought people in constantly disappeared overnight to make room for card tables so that they could run Magic tournaments.
Then they stopped carrying everything except tabletop games (warhammer & the ilk), CCGs, D&D, and White Wolf games.
Then they stopped carrying White-Wolf books.
Then they stopped selling used books, which made up a thriving portion of their business (half of my white-wolf out of print splat books were used)
Then they cut their D&D offerings by 75%.
Then they started cutting back on the tabletop games to make room for the anime section, where you could rent anime, or purchase the same used, scratched discs for more than you'd pay down at the mall at the over-priced DVD store.
All this inventory they moved to another location 45 miles away. I refuse to drive 45 miles one way to browse.
They also have a horrible, horrible tendency to open board games, play with them, then box them up and sell them as new. They make you pay in advance for a special order, and at least three times they have lost the special order and refuse to refund the buyer's money, saying there was never a purchase of the item. The last three times I went there in the last 5 years or so I went for impulse shopping, to buy basics that I didn't have. They didn't have primer paint for figs (!) or for that matter *any* paint for figs (they had figs though) but would special order it for me, they didn't have a battle mat, but would special order it for me, they didn't have markers, but would special order it for me. Ship time would be 2-3 weeks. And I'd be paying at least full MSRP. The primer paint was a little more than MSRP. The last time I went in to buy something they did have (dice), I waited 15 minutes while the guy who was supposed to ring me up played a round of heroclix. If I didn't need the dice that night I would have left.
If I have to wait 2-3 weeks to get an item, I want it on discount, even if it's 5-10% as a nod towards not going through Amazon or directly online. If I need it that same day, I'll gladly pay more than what Amazon charges/full price. Otherwise it's idiotic of me to pay 20-30% *more* for worse service from my LGS than through Amazon.
Sorry this is off topic, but it strikes me as silly to completely vilify Amazon. If CGL doesn't want to do business with Amazon that's their prerogative entirely, but at least in my case, Amazon is the only real option I have in my town, as my LGS is run by clowns. I'm sure my town isn't anywhere near unique.
On topic, I did order the LE through battleshop. Shipping was way steep (15 bucks for same-coast shipping) but it was worth it to me. Lately the quality of hardcover books I've received from places like Amazon & B&N.com have been very, very sub-standard (broken spines, scratched covers, pages creased/torn). For something this expensive, I'm willing to pay the shipping premium. Can't wait to see it. I have every shadowrun core book except for the 20th anniversary edition (which I'll be picking up), so this will make a nice addition to my collection.