QUOTE (Blade @ Sep 19 2012, 08:59 AM)

Premises:
- Runners need to have good skills/ware/gear/powers/etc. in order to be able to do shadowruns.
- People with good skills/ware/gear/powers/etc. can usually make money without running the shadows.
- Runners need to have a reason to run the shadows.
I would add in that under the standard PC build rules virtually every player character will have exceptional skills, ware, etc.
QUOTE
Assumption 1
- Money is not the only reason why Shadowrunners run the shadows.
Conclusion 1
- Runners CAN make money without running (doesn't mean they do, but it's possible without breaking the game world).
I would change that to "Money is never the reason why a Shadowrunner is running the shadows, unless he wants 9 figures or more."
The rules make this manifestly possible in a number of ways.
QUOTE
Assumption 2
- Money is the only reason runners run the shadows.
Conclusion 2
- Running the Shadows is the best way for shadowrunners to get money.
This is a manifestly false assumption and a manifestly false conclusion.
QUOTE
This second case can be explained by many things, such as:
1. Shadowrunners make more money running the shadows than doing something else.
Except under the rules they actually don't. Runners can make more money running the shadows but it requires decent payments and not the farce that is Mission payouts. In the games I play in Runners do make more money running than they would doing pretty much anything else but as both a player and GM we are more than willing to throw out 10K pay days for even the most trivial of runs and anything with real difficulty can easily end up with a six or seven figure pay day.
QUOTE
2. Even if they have good skills/ware/powers/gear/etc. runners can't make decent money without running the shadows.
This is again manifestly false.
QUOTE
---
Personally, I prefer a game where runners don't make millions running the Shadows. I like to keep it "street-level" so I consider that:
- Runners are outcasts, just like most SINless. They're dysfunctional people, that no corps will accept as employees. Maybe they're good, but they don't fit the corproate mould, and they're not good enough for the corps to tolerate that.
At the skill level PC runners operate at the corps don't care if you diddle little boys and then torture them to death. Especially if you are a mage or technomancer. And if the PC's were really that dysfunctional then they are unlikely to have acquired their skills and ware in the first place.
QUOTE
- This leaves crime (including doing a legitimate business but doing it illegally). The criminal syndicates control that kind of activities. They won't prevent a runner from doing it, but they'll want their cut. The runner can refuse, but you don't oppose a criminal syndicate for long, even if you're a powerful streetsam or mage.
Except, much like the corps, the syndicates don't really care what you do so long as you provide their cut. Try to move your two hundred thousand worth of drugs on the street and the syndicates will be displeased, sell your 200,000 worth of drugs to the syndicate at 30% of street price (60,000 nuyen) and you will be their best friend.
QUOTE
- This leaves heists/contracts and other "Shadowrunny" jobs. They could do them without any Johnson backing them up (stealing a prototype and selling it to the highest bidder, but it's risky business. With a Johnson, you're pretty sure that you'll be paid for the prototype or that the corp will stop looking for you once they realize that you don't have the prototype and were just a contractor.
There is no reason that the corp should realize anything different whether you have a Johnson or not.
QUOTE
- Runs aren't paid millions, but you can still get a few thousands nuyens for one. And once you're big enough, you can get better paid jobs.
I could walk into any real life city tomorrow and walk out with a job to courier 10K worth of drugs across the nation for a 2K payday upon delivery. This is in real life without any applicable runner skills. Someone with a shadowrunners skill set? A few thousand is chump change.
QUOTE
With these premises, Shadowrunners can't make much money without running. But this is all because of my design choices.
Except your premises are basically made up whole cloth and don't actually stand up to even the most basic of analysis.
A runner could easily say "You know what? I don't want to run against corps and the like, it is way too risky and requires way too much planning. I will instead do street level runs." and then your payments and premises make sense, but without such a decision by the runner they don't.