Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Storm Front is out!
Dumpshock Forums > Discussion > Shadowrun
Pages: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22
hermit
Edit: For those short on time, patience or attention span, I added individual ratings to all chapters (save one, because there's not really much there to even be rated). I also added a tl;dr rating at the end.

QUOTE
Being impartial and try to stay as objective as possible for example.
Your personal opinion will of course always show through, but that should be kept to a minimum.
In this review your dislike of the product and CGL is clearly visible and everyone who reads the review to inform himself would always wonder if the book really is that bad or if its just you using hyperboles because of a personal vendetta.

In media reviews, impartiality isn't as important. That said, I do give props where props are due. You didn't even read what I wrote, so you making claims about the content of my review in total is a bit bold. And you know, your own opinion is showing here. Just as a heads-up. wink.gif
Ixal
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 12:20 AM) *
In media reviews, impartiality isn't as important. That said, I do give props where props are due. You didn't even read what I wrote, so you making claims about the content of my review in total is a bit bold. And you know, your own opinion is showing here. Just as a heads-up. wink.gif


I do not know what media reviews you normally look like, but unless you are talking among a group who you know have the same opinion as you a more professional tone is much more informative and convincing.
And I did not read more than the 1st chapter and a few glances of the others because I honestly couldn't stomach all the vitriol even though the underlying problems in the book are real.
Presentation matters as much as content. And in my eyes the presentation of this review taints to content so much so that it is unusable to use it for information of the product.
hermit
So you read things superficially, and judge them then? That's amusing on so many levels, considering what you complain about.

QUOTE
I do not know what media reviews you normally look like, but unless you are talking among a group who you know have the same opinion as you a more professional tone is much more informative and convincing.

Like? Not mentioning flaws, so it looks more fair and balanced? Maybe a little undue praise?
tasti man LH
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 22 2013, 04:20 PM) *
In media reviews, impartiality isn't as important. That said, I do give props where props are due. You didn't even read what I wrote, so you making claims about the content of my review in total is a bit bold. And you know, your own opinion is showing here. Just as a heads-up. wink.gif


Impartiality is kind of important.

ESPECIALLY if it's the kind of review that people look to on whether to decide to buy a product or not. It's kind of hard to take someone's word seriously if they're reviewing a product from a company that they do not like. And while adding humor is fine, having your entire review dripping with snark will leave people with the impression that you aren't taking things seriously (or that you're taking one too many reviewing lessons from the Angry Video Game Nerd or the Nostalgia Critic).

(and for the record, I DID read your review in it's entiriety. and considering the rather divisive opinions on Storm Front, my personal conclusion on the matter is: "I guess I'll just have to pick up the book (the dead-tree version, not the PDF) and see for myself".)
Ixal
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 12:31 AM) *
So you read things superficially, and judge them then?


As do you when you believe Pepsi.
And I do not call my judgment a review.

QUOTE
Like? Not mentioning flaws, so it looks more fair and balanced?


I forgot to delete the like. Guess that qualifies me as a CGL proofreader.
But interesting that you bring up fair and balanced. That review certainly fits their style. And personally I do not consider that a sign of quality.
hermit
QUOTE
ESPECIALLY if it's the kind of review that people look to on whether to decide to buy a product or not.

I will post a shorter review (with a lot less of the things I want to tell the writers) on DriveThru and other RPG sales pages, if that makes you feel better. This is not a review primarily intended for potential buyers. It is equal parts feedback to authors and a general posting of opinion on a fan message board. A potential customer could care less about my concerns for the line's direction.

I would mention the bad editing, though, since that is product quality.

QUOTE
As do you when you believe Pepsi.

Yeah, because people with a chip on their shoulder because they don't like being called out are a good, unbiased source.

You seem awfully preoccupied with personal attacks. Do you take personal offense in reading (or rather, not reading, in your case) opinions you don't like? And you demand fairness, but give none. Love blanket statements, but dodge responsibility for them. That's funny really. You sure you're not a fan of them? wink.gif
Ixal
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 12:38 AM) *
I would mention the bad editing, though, sicne that is product quality.


Of course you should as you should mention all other bad things in the book. Just don't bury them under so much snark/vitriol so that the reader has to guess if those points actually exist or are just imagined.
tasti man LH
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 22 2013, 04:38 PM) *
I will post a shorter review (with a lot less of the things I want to tell the writers) on DriveThru and other RPG sales pages, if that makes you feel better. This is not a review primarily intended for potential buysers. It is equal parts feedback to authors and a general posting of opinion on a fan message board. A potential customer could care less about my concerns for the line's direction.


Considering the nature of what Storm Front is, I don't think it would be the kind of thing casual buyers or first-time SR players would pick up on their first try.

Most of the buyers of Storm Front would be people that are already familiar with the meta-plot of SR, and I would think would have already been buying SR books long before Storm Front.

Unless if you're seriously telling me that there are people out there who buy this book because they think it actually is about storm fronts and other weather phenomena....
Ixal
QUOTE (tasti man LH @ Mar 23 2013, 12:52 AM) *
Unless if you're seriously telling me that there are people out there who buy this book because they think it actually is about storm fronts and other weather phenomena....


Or people who want to start/get back with Shadowrun 5E and heard that this is a transition book.
bannockburn
Honestly, I'm not quite sure, why all these plots suddenly were required to 'end' or be wrapped up.
I guess, ultimately, this is a matter of creative freedom for the next edition. There is a LOT of baggage coming from 25 years of background, and in the end, I can only assume that this was a development decision.

On another on-topic note: I absolutely LOVE the Seattle chapter. I'm almost finished reading it and having played and GMed some of the Missions (I hope I haven't spoilered [yes, that's a word now!] myself too much) makes it feel like being a participant on the direction this took smile.gif
I hope the next Missions season will be incorporated into the material as well.
tasti man LH
^Considering that most of the resolved plot threads were fairly unpopular (at least from what I understand, as I have yet to be fully caught up on most of the 4e fluff), I guess they just wanted them done and over with so people won't have to deal with them come 5e.
Angelone
There has been a disturbing lack of Drop Bears in recent plot threads.
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Angelone @ Mar 22 2013, 09:11 PM) *
There has been a disturbing lack of Drop Bears in recent plot threads.


Or the Dreaded Drop-Bear Army of DOOM!
tasti man LH
...you people are INSANE...

I mean: air-dropping Drop Bears on corpsec as a viable tactical option?! Who does that?!???!

There's pink mohawk and then there's...that.
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (tasti man LH @ Mar 22 2013, 09:36 PM) *
...you people are INSANE...

I mean: air-dropping Drop Bears on corpsec as a viable tactical option?! Who does that?!???!

There's pink mohawk and then there's...that.


You gotta admit. Corp sec standing around. They hear a 'Foompt!!" and a parachute comes down. They all draw down on it as a box about the size of a trashcan lands. They call out orders. Nothing happens. Finally one inches forward... at about 10 feet a proximity detector unlocks the box and out comes a pissed off Dropbear..... that's one hell of a distraction.
Angelone
Or just parachuting the Drop Bears right on corp sec. They'll be standing around joking and suddenly they are covered in parachute and claws.
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Angelone @ Mar 22 2013, 09:48 PM) *
Or just parachuting the Drop Bears right on corp sec. They'll be standing around joking and suddenly they are covered in parachute and claws.


INFECTED claws. lol
RHat
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 22 2013, 05:38 PM) *
I will post a shorter review (with a lot less of the things I want to tell the writers) on DriveThru and other RPG sales pages, if that makes you feel better. This is not a review primarily intended for potential buyers. It is equal parts feedback to authors and a general posting of opinion on a fan message board. A potential customer could care less about my concerns for the line's direction.


To be fair, however, a review should observe a distinction between "not to my tastes", and "bad".

And I do think that there are some connections you're simply not making, too. For example:

[ Spoiler ]


And on a more general note regarding the whole Lofwyr/Alamais thing: it seems to me that the whole thing was about a battle of ideas as much as a military battle. If Lofwyr just got a ton of dragons together to kill Alamais and his followers, it would have proven nothing - and in fact, all it would have meant is that the next time a great wanted to advance such ideas, they'd be far more subtle about it. The point, then, was to demonstrate that Alamais was wrong; interestingly, this backs up Celedyr's edict and advances Hestaby's agenda. I'm not inclined to assume that's a coincidence. Note especially that Lofwyr has been shown in previous fiction to have been pushing for leniency towards Hestaby even while pushing for slaughtering Alamais and his contingent. And that Hestaby launched an attack against Alamais that notably softened up the compound, Alamais, and probably a few other dragons. It's quite possible there was a conspiracy between the three of them, and Hestaby's end of it just didn't work out as well as it was supposed to (it's also possible that it DID work out as planned, as she may now be in a better position to forward her agenda...).
Critias
Not to interrupt the argument(s), but FWIW I appreciate the feedback (I don't recall if I've come out and said which bits I wrote, but folks can probably take a few good guesses). wink.gif
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Critias @ Mar 22 2013, 10:27 PM) *
Not to interrupt the argument(s), but FWIW I appreciate the feedback (I don't recall if I've come out and said which bits I wrote, but folks can probably take a few good guesses). wink.gif


Which ones did you write?
Critias
Oh, c'mon. At least take a guess!
RHat
20 bucks on the Tír section.
Wakshaani
[ Spoiler ]


(Man, will all of this even fit in one post? Better copy n paste to be safe!)
Bull
QUOTE (bannockburn @ Mar 22 2013, 07:01 PM) *
On another on-topic note: I absolutely LOVE the Seattle chapter. I'm almost finished reading it and having played and GMed some of the Missions (I hope I haven't spoilered [yes, that's a word now!] myself too much) makes it feel like being a participant on the direction this took smile.gif


Just want to drop in and say... "Awesome!" That's what we were shooting for with Missions. We'll likely never be a major, big time, "OMG! Stop this or the WORLD ENDS!" set of adventures, but we wanted what you did in Missions to feel impactful and meaningful.

One thing about that section that really made me smile were all the little references to "This team I'm working with" and "These really promising up and coming runners that pulled this job". Because anyone who plays through the Season can then sit back and go "Hey, that was me!" Which is often something that's hard to do in Shadowrun. Too often the players end up being spectatcors to the big event, or at best escorting major NPCs around while they do all the important stuff. And we didn't want to do that. Even with my GM PC involved wink.gif

(And as a side note, you guys do realize that EVERY character here is a GM PC to one degree or another? That's the nature of creating characters for fiction, there's very little difference between the two other than an actual PC you actually have a handle on their stats and they often have a much more detailed personality and backstory to work with. There *IS* the danger of making them a Mary Sue where everyone loves them, they always succeed, etc. But I don't like to play characters like that, and Bull is often deeply, deeply flawed, and I try and make sure that comes through. He's also probe to blowing up and losing limbs. It's also why I was against him becoming a Jackpoint Admin, but I got overruled on that one smile.gif)

QUOTE
I hope the next Missions season will be incorporated into the material as well.


I hope that as well. I have some interesting ideas for Season 5 (I think), and we'll see how they play out. smile.gif

(If you're not subscribed to the SR Missions Facebook page, I posted a teaser of one of the Season 5 Contacts/NPCs there already, and more will be going up in the near future. I tend to use Facebook for most of my sneak peeks and teasers smile.gif)

Bull
Bull
QUOTE (RHat @ Mar 22 2013, 10:49 PM) *
20 bucks on the Tír section.


I'm surprised Critias hasn't gone and gotten skin grafts to give himself elf ears yet. smile.gif
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Bull @ Mar 23 2013, 02:08 AM) *
One thing about that section that really made me smile were all the little references to "This team I'm working with" and "These really promising up and coming runners that pulled this job". Because anyone who plays through the Season can then sit back and go "Hey, that was me!" Which is often something that's hard to do in Shadowrun. Too often the players end up being spectatcors to the big event, or at best escorting major NPCs around while they do all the important stuff. And we didn't want to do that. Even with my GM PC involved wink.gif


I -did- catch this during the read through. The "missions" are probably the only stuff I don't buy asap.

Reading the chapter I defiantly caught those instances and grinned a bit. I think it was Netcat or something that describes them as talented but a bit rough around the edges or could use some work or something and chuckled.

Glad to know, it is what I thought it was, with out being 'too' overt.
Wakshaani
QUOTE (Bull @ Mar 23 2013, 12:10 AM) *
I'm surprised Critias hasn't gone and gotten skin grafts to give himself elf ears yet. smile.gif


Says the man with Ork tusks in his drawer. biggrin.gif
Bull
QUOTE (Wakshaani @ Mar 23 2013, 01:36 AM) *
Says the man with Ork tusks in his drawer. biggrin.gif


If I had the money, I'd totally get a custom set of ork dentures smile.gif
Grinder
QUOTE (Angelone @ Mar 23 2013, 02:48 AM) *
Or just parachuting the Drop Bears right on corp sec. They'll be standing around joking and suddenly they are covered in parachute and claws.


love.gif
hermit
@Wakshaani
[ Spoiler ]
hermit
@Bull
[ Spoiler ]
Nath
[ Spoiler ]

Fatum
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
Art is, otherwise, consistently high quality, and two pieces deserve special kudos; more on that in the appropriate section of the review.
Except a few of the pics don't fit the text at all. See p.59, p.93, p.147 or p.182.

[ Spoiler ]


[ Spoiler ]


[ Spoiler ]


QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
And there're implausibilities galore. There're glass beads dropped by mterialising spirits. Where were the beads before? Did they dematerialise too? How? Please keep to the established things magic can and cannot do and don't just write every crap up to "Magic!" like a lazy, unimaginative, and incompetent writer, thanks?
Ha, I totally missed this one.

QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
One is that at least one Techno believes Paragons are actual 1st Gen AI, bringing them in line with both my theory on them (heh) and the second Sprawl trilogy book's (Neuromancer's successor, Biochips) take on the Matrix after the Singularity of Wintermute/Neuromancer.
She believes a first-gen AI can be a Paragon, not that all Paragons are first-gen AIs. That's a huge difference.
Fatum
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
At least this story seems to follow some inner logic for now, and the Matrix maybe is demagicized. I'm all for that, I absolutely loathed 4e's magical take on Mancers and the Matrix.
Except deckers were called matrix mages as well; so 4E Matrix is not any more "magicized" than before.

QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
Now it expands into South America because the people there are too poor to be of interest to megas and have no economies - apparently the authors have stopped considering SoLA canon?
Have they started considering it such, to begin with?

QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
Not good enough, though not quite as bad as Aztlan's Triump [sic!] either.
Okay, I'll cave: I've just rechecked, and I can't see Atzlan's Triumph spelled wrong anywhere.

QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
I also wonder if this plot originated in Hardy's lemons-to-lemonade philosophy that also spawned the JackPoint intrusion by the Poster With No Nick, to deal with vastly inaccurate and faulty and badly researched and lazily written shadowposters.
Going by the previous posts in the thread, yeah.

QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 01:21 AM) *
And I am certain I am not alone in the observation that SR seems to drift towards a highly America-centric and American-dominated world view. Kind of like Tom Clancy was made Line Dev.
Even for someone buying Pegasus stuff, it's kinda hard not to notice Shadowrun has always been America-centric.
bannockburn
QUOTE (Bull @ Mar 23 2013, 07:08 AM) *
Just want to drop in and say... "Awesome!" That's what we were shooting for with Missions. We'll likely never be a major, big time, "OMG! Stop this or the WORLD ENDS!" set of adventures, but we wanted what you did in Missions to feel impactful and meaningful.

Well, in my opinion, you succeeded smile.gif
And it's appreciated that the runs stay on the street level. That was one reason why I liked Harlequin 1 and loathed Harlequin 2 (even with the adventures being very creative if taken for themselves).

QUOTE
One thing about that section that really made me smile were all the little references to "This team I'm working with" and "These really promising up and coming runners that pulled this job". Because anyone who plays through the Season can then sit back and go "Hey, that was me!" Which is often something that's hard to do in Shadowrun. Too often the players end up being spectatcors to the big event, or at best escorting major NPCs around while they do all the important stuff. And we didn't want to do that. Even with my GM PC involved wink.gif

Funny thing is, Netcat is even one of the connections I use wink.gif
And I'll echo here, that Bull is not that bad as a 'GM PC' (although I believe, he's far beyond that status). He's a mover and a shaker, sure, but he's not a sparkling example of everything that's cool. Quite the opposite, indeed, with his refusal to use hip language!

QUOTE
(If you're not subscribed to the SR Missions Facebook page, I posted a teaser of one of the Season 5 Contacts/NPCs there already, and more will be going up in the near future. I tend to use Facebook for most of my sneak peeks and teasers smile.gif)

That's too bad, I hate Facebook and don't use it wink.gif


QUOTE (Fatum @ Mar 23 2013, 11:09 AM) *
Okay, I'll cave: I've just rechecked, and I can't see Atzlan's Triumph spelled wrong anywhere.

Check the thumb marker on the side. It is on _every_ page.

QUOTE
Even for someone buying Pegasus stuff, it's kinda hard not to notice Shadowrun has always been America-centric.

There's a difference between being America-centric and pushing current American views into the game world.
America-centric writing is quite alright, after all an author should write about what he knows. I even like the American setting better than the crowded European one. But it takes a special effort to not overdo it.
SR started out with a splintered America (& Canada, how funny is that? wink.gif) where they _lost_ the big war. Not even Vietnam can have been that hard on the collective self-image. The government was powerless, the army was rented out and not even that mentionable anymore and most of the continent belonged to the natives. Even Hawaii seceded.

Nowadays, there's a certain paradigm shift and it rubs me the wrong way. It's subtle, but I'll go ahead and say that I've noticed it, too.
However, discussing this topic in depth goes too far into RL political views, so maybe we should nip this in the bud and just take it as a caveat lector.
Fatum
QUOTE (bannockburn @ Mar 23 2013, 01:49 PM) *
Check the thumb marker on the side. It is on _every_ page.
Oh. Well. I...I mean..

QUOTE (bannockburn @ Mar 23 2013, 01:49 PM) *
Nowadays, there's a certain paradigm shift and it rubs me the wrong way. It's subtle, but I'll go ahead and say that I've noticed it, too.
Dunno, the FMC shenanigans are ridiculous, of course; but other than that, I can't say I see anything all that worse than what we previously had.
lokii
QUOTE (bannockburn @ Mar 23 2013, 12:49 PM) *
SR started out with a splintered America (& Canada, how funny is that? wink.gif) where they _lost_ the big war. Not even Vietnam can have been that hard on the collective self-image. The government was powerless, the army was rented out and not even that mentionable anymore and most of the continent belonged to the natives. Even Hawaii seceded.
Taken together with Crimson Skies, they must have had some real counterculture-infested hippie-leftovers employed at FASA. biggrin.gif
Wakshaani
Oh man, Crimson Skies, don't get me started. Such a great game world! It died too young. frown.gif
Sengir
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 22 2013, 11:21 PM) *
[ Spoiler ]

Dragon society is obviously heavily inspired by the old fealty system. As such, one of Big L's vassals misbehaving in public would a serious stain on his reputation. Or on a more pragmatic note, he needed to give the impression that the humans would not be considered forlon hope fodder wink.gif
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Hermit)
Runners and dragons start off uneasy, and a dragon bites a merc who wanted to pet it. Lofwyr, seeing this might make the runners uneasy, orders the dragon executed. What the hell, Lofwyr. I mean, it's nice that you suddenly discovered your heart for humans, but seriously? Are you ... drunk or on Zen or weed? Do you have Morbus Schletz? Are you still Lofwyr?


Well the problem with this thing is.... that's just not what happened. Colorful language aside. It just didn't go down that way.

Yes, the Dragons and mercs were uneasy.
No, a merc didn't try and pet a dragon. Fallacy one. (For the record the dragon just killed the merc for no reason that the storyteller in that section could ascertain what so ever.))
No Lofwyr didn't order the dragon Executed. It's on page 50 if you want to look. SCALES, the Drake steps in to stop the violence from erupting. Acting on Lofwry's behalf (Not even with a direct order).... ordered the dragon killed. There is a difference. Yes one of Lofwyr's people ordered the death, but it wasn't Lo himself. So that's fallacy two.
The death wasn't "Seeing this might make the runners uneasy" in causation either. This is a very important point. The dragon wasn't killed, for killing the merc. The dragon was killed, --For violating Lofwyr's standing order---.... of non violence. There's a huge huge difference there. It wasn't reactionary. It wasn't to placate humans. It wasn't to even keep the uneasy peace (Though it functioned for that as well)) The dragon was killed, for violating an order from their leader. So that's Fallacy three.

So the rest of the point there about Lo suddenly discovering his heart for humans drunk or Zen or on weed is just hyperbole. The scene didn't shake down like was indicated and the reasoning wasn't as stated, and Lofwyr wasn't even the one that commanded it. His lieutenant was. Lofwyr didn't even show up at the camp --till the next day--. He wasn't even there.

This is the sort of thing that I mentioned on Hermit's review. Alot of the stuff that he 'reviewed' or said, just wasn't based on what actually happened in the book. It's flowery and very pissy, but doesn't actually address the book in many places. It's why I said he should go back and re-read. He seems to have skimmed or missed things in his first read through.
CanRay
QUOTE (Bull @ Mar 23 2013, 01:10 AM) *
I'm surprised Critias hasn't gone and gotten skin grafts to give himself elf ears yet. smile.gif
Probably holding out to see how my operation goes.
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (CanRay @ Mar 23 2013, 12:13 PM) *
Probably holding out to see how my operation goes.


I've seen about 5 people that have had their ears pointed... I just say. Be careful. 2 worked out quite well. One just.. not really at all, the last two.... all I can say is --EWWWWww-- and --OUCH---. lol
Critias
QUOTE (RHat @ Mar 22 2013, 10:49 PM) *
20 bucks on the Tír section.

Yup, but another one, too!

QUOTE (Bull @ Mar 23 2013, 01:10 AM) *
I'm surprised Critias hasn't gone and gotten skin grafts to give himself elf ears yet. [img]http://forums.dumpshock.com/style_emoticons/default/smile.gif[/img]


You kiddin'? No way I can afford that on freelancer and adjunct faculty pay!

Err, I mean, not that I've looked into it. blush.gif
Umidori
Find a Street Doc.

No, really. Do a little research, schlep on down to Mexico, have it done for 1/10th the normal price or less.

~Umi
Pepsi Jedi
QUOTE (Umidori @ Mar 23 2013, 12:28 PM) *
Find a Street Doc.

No, really. Do a little research, schlep on down to Mexico, have it done for 1/10th the normal price or less.

~Umi


Dude!! No no no no no. Do NOT schlep down to Mexico to have medical procedures done!! lol You'll go to get your ears pointed, and come back with out a liver or something even worse!
Critias
Hahah. No, no. I'm not about to go get cosmetic surgery for elf ears. And I wouldn't run down to Mexico to get it done, if I was.
lokii
QUOTE (Critias @ Mar 23 2013, 08:43 PM) *
And I wouldn't run down to Mexico to get it done, if I was.
Yes, I see. Cuba, right?
Bull
QUOTE (hermit @ Mar 23 2013, 04:26 AM) *
@Bull
[ Spoiler ]


Totally understand that, and have been there myself more than once, where you sat there for several game sessions feeling like YOU were the NPC to the GM's pet character. Not fun, which is why I try and be very careful whenever I use Bull in writing myself. Anyway, glad you enjoyed the Missions side of things at least. smile.gif
hermit
@Fatum

QUOTE
Who's Morbus Schletz?

The personality-eating whatever plague in Fractures and Cracks. Until it has an official name, I'll call it Morbus Schletz, after the initial patient (Scott "Wolf" Schletz).

QUOTE
She believes a first-gen AI can be a Paragon, not that all Paragons are first-gen AIs. That's a huge difference.
(...)
At least this story seems to follow some inner logic for now, and the Matrix maybe is demagicized. I'm all for that, I absolutely loathed 4e's magical take on Mancers and the Matrix.

True enough, but that WOULD be consistent with the fact that at least one of the AI has the same mindset and icon as a paragon. And by 'demagicizing' I meant that the Matrix is not treated as an awakened realm where things happen because "Magic!", since it is entirely artificial and entirely man-made and machine-controlled.

QUOTE
Have they started considering it such, to begin with?

Synner said so quite clearly once, and I heared that from old guard writers repeatedly, too. I am not sure about the new writers, nor Hardy's stance on this.

QUOTE
Even for someone buying Pegasus stuff, it's kinda hard not to notice Shadowrun has always been America-centric. (...) Dunno, the FMC shenanigans are ridiculous, of course; but other than that, I can't say I see anything all that worse than what we previously had.

SR3 and early SR4 were different - the setting grew more international, even writeups in different languages were acknowledged. I'm pretty certain the writers of that time being from all over contributed a lot; today, it's pretty much all white, American, and a good deal Mormon. And even back in the early days, where Seattle was the only setting (with some nods to Chicago and NYC), there was a lot less chest-drumming and flag-waving. The FMC are the most crass example, and the one that really annyoed me, but please, look into 10 Mercs and where the units there - a supposedly international selection of mercenaries - are from. It's rather disproportional, especially given North America is the least interesting continent to mercenaries in SR (except maybe Antarctica). The UCAS also is often taken to be a military powerhouse (it shouldn't be), and then there're slips of ideology soemthines that ... are just plain unpleasant. War! was full of them, of course, but so were the Gun Haven books.

Maybe I am overreacting there a bit - Wakshaani seems to have put in his Exceptuionalism bit with the exact opposite in mind - but it's something I wanted to bring to attention after observing the trend for some time now. Probably, most really isn't conscious, but born out of the cultural homogenity of the current writers. But seriously, the FMC is taking this too far.

@Sengir
QUOTE
Dragon society is obviously heavily inspired by the old fealty system. As such, one of Big L's vassals misbehaving in public would a serious stain on his reputation. Or on a more pragmatic note, he needed to give the impression that the humans would not be considered forlon hope fodder

He could have slapped the dragon and told it off, then glared at humans, and be done with it. A life for a life seems very, very off for Keyser "Lofwyr" Soze.

@Critas
QUOTE
Yup, but another one, too!

Denver, right?

@Bull
QUOTE
Totally understand that, and have been there myself more than once, where you sat there for several game sessions feeling like YOU were the NPC to the GM's pet character. Not fun, which is why I try and be very careful whenever I use Bull in writing myself. Anyway, glad you enjoyed the Missions side of things at least. smile.gif

Missions is sadly underrated, I think; it could be a major selling point for the setting if more muscle was put behind it. And I think that reflex is unfair for Bull as an NPC as written; it is just a knee jerk reflex develped overthe years I guess. I usually enjoy reading Bull a lot.
CanRay
As my "Author Avatar" is Slamm-0! (amongst others), I love making Bull suffer. biggrin.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Dumpshock Forums © 2001-2012